Electricity use in big area additive manufacturing of fiber-reinforced polymer composites

Hao Chen, Srikanth Pilla, Gang Li, Muzan Williams Ijeoma, Michael Carbajales‐DaleScientific 2024 · DOI

Abstract

In recent years, additive manufacturing (AM), especially large-format additive manufacturing (LFAM), has gained momentum in the manufacturing industry. While LFAM offers benefits over conventional manufacturing processes, such as minimizing material waste and providing vast geometric freedom, assessing its sustainability remains challenging due to limited data, particularly on energy consumption. Most existing data pertain to small-scale or desktop AM and are not directly applicable to LFAM. In this study, we conducted real-time measurements of electricity usage for a type of LFAM known as big area additive manufacturing (BAAM), which typically uses fiber-reinforced polymer pellets as feedstock. We collected electricity usage data from fifteen printing jobs over two months in an industrial production setting. These data fill the existing gap and can be reused to enhance the community's understanding of LFAM electricity usage, support further research, and promote sustainable development in advanced manufacturing technologies.

The Energy Data Gap in Large-Format Additive Manufacturing

While additive manufacturing (AM) is frequently characterized as a "green" technology due to its ability to reduce material waste, its actual energy footprint remains poorly understood at industrial scales. Most existing energy consumption literature focuses on desktop-scale Fused Deposition Modeling (FDM), which utilizes filaments and operates at relatively slow speeds.

Large-Format Additive Manufacturing (LFAM), specifically Big Area Additive Manufacturing (BAAM), operates on a fundamentally different scale. These systems utilize polymer pellets as feedstock and can achieve throughput rates up to 50 kg/h. Because energy intensity typically decreases as production rates increase, desktop-scale data cannot be accurately extrapolated to predict the environmental impact of industrial LFAM. Prior to this study, the primary reference for BAAM energy consumption was a single-point measurement from 2014 that lacked material specifications and operational context. This research addresses that decade-old data gap by providing high-resolution, real-world measurements.

Methodology and Experimental Setup

The study was conducted at an industrial facility (Additive Engineering Solutions) using a commercial BAAM system. Unlike desktop printers, the BAAM system integrates a large-scale gantry and a single-screw extruder to process fiber-reinforced pellets.

The BAAM system components (a) and a schematic of the single-screw extrusion process (b).

To capture electricity usage, researchers installed Onset HOBO current clamps on the system’s three-phase industrial power supply (460 V). Current was recorded at 10-second intervals continuously for two months. The total energy (E) and Specific Energy Consumption (SEC)—defined as the energy used per kilogram of printed material—were calculated assuming a power factor of 0.9. The study focused specifically on the active printing phase, excluding startup, warm-up, and idle times to provide a clean metric for the deposition process itself.

Characterizing 15 Industrial Print Jobs

The resulting dataset contains 15 distinct printing jobs utilizing various fiber-reinforced composites, including carbon fiber (CF) and glass fiber (GF) reinforced polymers such as ABS, PEI, and PC. Each job entry includes critical operational metadata: bed temperature, melting temperature, layer thickness, bead width, and gantry speed.

Real-time current measurements for the 15 industrial printing jobs monitored over a two-month period.

Because the data was collected in a working factory rather than a controlled laboratory environment, it reflects the inherent variability of real production, including load imbalances and varying part geometries. This makes the dataset a robust tool for future Life Cycle Assessments (LCA).

Key Findings: Efficiency at Scale

The most significant insight from this study is the confirmation of the relationship between process rate and energy intensity. The BAAM system's high throughput allows the "fixed" energy costs—such as maintaining heater temperatures and gantry movement—to be spread over a much larger mass of material compared to desktop systems.

  • Process Rates: The monitored jobs achieved deposition rates between 9.5 and 32 kg/h, with a median of 18.83 kg/h.
  • Energy Efficiency: The median Specific Energy Consumption (SEC) was 0.24 kWh/kg.
  • Comparative Advantage: To put this in perspective, desktop FDM systems typically range from 11.4 to 78.0 kWh/kg. This data demonstrates that BAAM is roughly two orders of magnitude more energy-efficient per kilogram of material than its desktop counterparts.
  • Technological Maturity: The measured SEC values are significantly lower than the 1.2 kWh/kg reported in 2014, suggesting that advancements in system efficiency and operational parameters have more than halved the energy required per unit of production in the last decade.

Limitations and Future Directions

While this study provides a vital benchmark, the authors identify several areas for further refinement. First, because the data reflects varied customer orders, it was not possible to systematically isolate how individual parameters (like gantry speed or layer height) influence energy use while keeping geometry constant.

Second, the main SEC calculation excluded peripheral energy costs such as the desiccant dryer and post-process CNC machining. While data for the dryer was collected separately, standardizing these costs is difficult because drying requirements vary by material storage conditions and CNC needs vary by the required surface finish. Future research should aim to integrate this printing data into a holistic LCA that includes material synthesis and end-of-life recycling to create a comprehensive environmental profile for LFAM.

Summary updated

Abstract

In recent years, additive manufacturing (AM), especially large-format additive manufacturing (LFAM), has gained momentum in the manufacturing industry. While LFAM offers benefits over conventional manufacturing processes, such as minimizing material waste and providing vast geometric freedom, assessing its sustainability remains challenging due to limited data, particularly on energy consumption. Most existing data pertain to small-scale or desktop AM and are not directly applicable to LFAM. In this study, we conducted real-time measurements of electricity usage for a type of LFAM known as big area additive manufacturing (BAAM), which typically uses fiber-reinforced polymer pellets as feedstock. We collected electricity usage data from fifteen printing jobs over two months in an industrial production setting. These data fill the existing gap and can be reused to enhance the community's understanding of LFAM electricity usage, support further research, and promote sustainable development in advanced manufacturing technologies.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{chen2024electricity,
  author = {Hao Chen and Srikanth Pilla and Gang Li and Muzan Williams Ijeoma and Michael Carbajales‐Dale},
  title = {{Electricity use in big area additive manufacturing of fiber-reinforced polymer composites}},
  booktitle = {Scientific},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1038/s41597-024-04240-w},
}
Figure