Elasticity of podosome actin networks produces nanonewton protrusive forces

Marion Jasnin, Jordan Hervy, Stéphanie Balor, Anaïs Bouissou, Amsha Proag, Raphaël Voituriez, Jonathan Schneider, Thomas Mangeat, Isabelle Maridonneau‐Parini, Wolfgang Baumeister, Serge Dmitrieff, Renaud PoinclouxNature Communications 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper reveals that the remarkable nanonewton-scale forces generated by cellular structures called podosomes are not solely due to actin filament polymerization, but rather arise from the storage and release of elastic energy within a dense, bent network of actin filaments. This finding shifts our understanding of cellular force generation, emphasizing the importance of the entire network's bulk properties, not just its interaction with the membrane.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Cells use intricate networks of actin filaments to perform a myriad of functions, from movement and adhesion to division. A key question has been how these individual actin filaments, which generate forces in the piconewton (pN) range, can collectively produce much larger forces, in the nanonewton (nN) range, required for processes like cell protrusion. Specifically, macrophage podosomes, which are crucial for probing the extracellular environment, generate forces of tens of nN. Previous hypotheses focused on the sum of polymerization forces or filaments pushing at shallow angles, but these couldn't fully explain the observed forces. This paper aims to bridge this gap by investigating the nanoscale architecture of podosomes and its contribution to force generation.

Methods

The researchers employed cryo-electron tomography (cryo-ET), a powerful technique that allows for the visualization of cellular structures at near-atomic resolution in their native, frozen-hydrated state. This enabled them to reconstruct the three-dimensional (3D) architecture of macrophage podosomes with unprecedented detail, resolving individual actin filaments.

Key methodological steps included:

  • Cryo-FIB milling: Precisely thinning the vitrified cells to allow electron beam penetration for cryo-ET.
  • Tomogram reconstruction: Generating 3D density maps from the tilt series of images.
  • Automated filament segmentation: Identifying and tracing individual actin filaments within the tomograms.
  • Quantitative analysis: Measuring filament density, orientation, length, curvature, and correlation length as a function of radial distance from the podosome core.
  • Theoretical modeling: Using principles of linear elasticity to estimate the elastic energy stored in the bent filaments and the resulting elastic force.

This integrative approach combined high-resolution imaging with biophysical modeling to link structure to function.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on cryo-ET data acquired from primary human monocyte-derived macrophages.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Polymerization alone is insufficient: The study definitively shows that the sum of forces generated by actin filaments polymerizing against the cell membrane is orders of magnitude lower than the observed protrusive forces of podosomes.
  • The core is a "spring-loaded" system: The central core of the podosome is not just a dense collection of filaments, but a network of bent actin filaments. This bending implies that elastic energy is stored within the network.
  • Elastic energy storage is key: The dense, bent architecture of the actin filaments within the podosome core acts like a compressed spring, storing significant elastic energy.
  • Bulk properties matter: Understanding force generation requires considering the entire volume of the actin network, not just its interface with the membrane.
  • Radial tension balances core compression: The outward force generated by the compressed core is counteracted by tension in the radial actin filaments connecting to the adhesion ring, maintaining structural integrity.

Key Results

  • Filament organization: Podosome cores are characterized by a dense network of bent actin filaments with a mean orientation of ~47° relative to the plasma membrane, while filaments outside the core are flatter.
  • Polymerization force estimate: The estimated polymerization force at the core membrane is less than 1 nN, significantly lower than the experimental values.
  • Elastic energy density: The density of elastic energy stored within the podosome core is substantially higher than in the surrounding regions.
  • Elastic force generation: Theoretical modeling predicts that the stored elastic energy in the bent actin filaments can generate an elastic force of 27.7 ± 11.8 nN, which is in the nanonewton range and consistent with experimental measurements.
  • Young's Modulus: The estimated Young's modulus of the podosome core is approximately 13.2 ± 2.3 MPa, compatible with the high actin density.
  • Surface tension: The radial filaments exert a surface tension of approximately 56 mN/m to counterbalance the core's compressive force.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Overestimation of elastic force: The authors acknowledge that their calculation of elastic force might be an overestimation because they assume all stored elastic energy can be released, and the resting state of the network might already possess some elastic energy.
  • Role of cross-linkers: While the study focuses on filament bending, the contribution of elastic energy stored in cross-linkers and other actin-binding proteins is not fully quantified but is suggested to further increase the generated force.
  • Actomyosin contribution: The role of actomyosin cables and myosin II in loading the network is mentioned as a potential alternative or complementary mechanism for force generation, particularly in response to myosin inhibition.
  • Future directions: The authors suggest that future work could explore other degrees of freedom for elastic energy storage, such as filament twisting, and further investigate the interplay between polymerization, actomyosin activity, and elastic energy storage in generating cellular forces. They also highlight the potential of cryo-ET to address similar questions in other complex actin-based cellular machineries.

Summary updated

Abstract

Actin filaments assemble into force-generating systems involved in diverse cellular functions, including cell motility, adhesion, contractility and division. It remains unclear how networks of actin filaments, which individually generate piconewton forces, can produce forces reaching tens of nanonewtons. Here we use in situ cryo-electron tomography to unveil how the nanoscale architecture of macrophage podosomes enables basal membrane protrusion. We show that the sum of the actin polymerization forces at the membrane is not sufficient to explain podosome protrusive forces. Quantitative analysis of podosome organization demonstrates that the core is composed of a dense network of bent actin filaments storing elastic energy. Theoretical modelling of the network as a spring-loaded elastic material reveals that it exerts forces of a few tens of nanonewtons, in a range similar to that evaluated experimentally. Thus, taking into account not only the interface with the membrane but also the bulk of the network, is crucial to understand force generation by actin machineries. Our integrative approach sheds light on the elastic behavior of dense actin networks and opens new avenues to understand force production inside cells.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{jasnin2022elasticity,
  author = {Marion Jasnin and Jordan Hervy and Stéphanie Balor and Anaïs Bouissou and Amsha Proag and Raphaël Voituriez and Jonathan Schneider and Thomas Mangeat and Isabelle Maridonneau‐Parini and Wolfgang Baumeister and Serge Dmitrieff and Renaud Poincloux},
  title = {{Elasticity of podosome actin networks produces nanonewton protrusive forces}},
  booktitle = {Nature Communications},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.1038/s41467-022-30652-6},
}
Figure