Elasticity of dense actin networks produces nanonewton protrusive forces

Marion Jasnin, Jordan Hervy, Stéphanie Balor, Anaïs Bouissou, Amsha Proag, Raphaël Voituriez, Isabelle Maridonneau‐Parini, Wolfgang Baumeister, Serge Dmitrieff, Renaud PoinclouxbioRxiv 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

Scientists have discovered that the remarkable forces generated by cellular structures called podosomes, which are crucial for cell movement and sensing, don't come from simple filament pushing. Instead, these forces arise from the elastic energy stored within a dense, bent network of actin filaments, acting like a compressed spring. This finding revolutionizes our understanding of how cells generate significant mechanical power at the nanoscale.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Cells use intricate networks of actin filaments to perform a multitude of tasks, from crawling to dividing. Individual actin filaments can generate forces in the piconewton (pN) range, but cellular structures like podosomes can exert forces tens to hundreds of times stronger, in the nanonewton (nN) range. It's been a long-standing mystery how these small forces from individual filaments add up to such large forces. Previous hypotheses suggested that simply summing up the forces of many polymerizing filaments might be enough, or that filaments might push at shallow angles. This paper investigates the nanoscale architecture of macrophage podosomes to understand the mechanism behind their powerful protrusive forces.

Methods

The researchers employed cryo-electron tomography (cryo-ET), a cutting-edge technique that allows visualization of cellular structures in their native, frozen-hydrated state at near-atomic resolution. This enabled them to reconstruct the 3D architecture of podosomes. They combined this with quantitative analysis of filament organization, measuring parameters like filament length, density, and orientation. To understand the forces, they developed theoretical models based on linear elasticity to quantify the elastic energy stored in the actin network. They also referenced protrusion force microscopy (PFM) data from previous studies to compare their findings.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on imaging and analysis of in situ cellular structures (podosomes) from human macrophages.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Beyond Simple Pushing: The study definitively shows that the collective force of actin polymerization at the membrane is insufficient to explain the nN forces of podosomes.
  • Elastic Energy Storage: The core of the podosome is a dense network of bent actin filaments. This bending allows the network to store significant elastic energy, much like a compressed spring.
  • Spring-Loaded Mechanism: The stored elastic energy in the bent filaments acts as a "spring-loaded" system, releasing force to drive membrane protrusion.
  • Bulk Network Matters: Understanding force generation requires considering the entire actin network's bulk properties, not just the interface with the membrane.
  • Podosomes as Force Generators: Podosomes are not just passive structures but active force generators, using their internal architecture to exert substantial mechanical influence on their environment.

Key Results

  • Filament Organization: Podosome cores are characterized by dense, shorter, and more obliquely oriented actin filaments compared to the surrounding network.
  • Polymerization Force Limit: The sum of polymerization forces from filaments pushing against the membrane was estimated to be below 1 nN, significantly lower than observed protrusive forces.
  • Elastic Energy Density: The density of elastic energy stored within the podosome core is 3 to 10 times higher than in the surrounding regions.
  • Elastic Force Generation: The calculated elastic force generated by the compressed actin network is in the nanonewton (nN) range (around 9.7 ± 4.2 nN), matching experimental PFM measurements.
  • Young's Modulus: The estimated Young's modulus of the podosome core is 1.7 MPa, which is compatible with high actin density and allows for significant force generation with small strains.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Underestimation of Force: The authors acknowledge that their calculation of elastic energy might be an underestimate, as it doesn't fully account for energy stored in crosslinkers or non-bent filament segments. The resting state of the network under pressure might also lead to an overestimation of the force.
  • Assembly Under Force: The precise mechanism by which actin filaments assemble while under such significant force remains an open question.
  • Role of Myosin: While the study focuses on elastic energy, the authors suggest that actomyosin contractility (driven by myosin II) might also contribute to loading the network, especially in scenarios where myosin II is inhibited.
  • Future Directions: The authors anticipate that advancements in cryo-ET will allow for the investigation of other degrees of freedom for elastic energy storage, such as crosslinker deformation and filament twisting, and will shed light on other cellular force generation mechanisms. They also suggest that combining experiments with simulations will be crucial for fully understanding the assembly of these "spring-loaded" networks.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Actin filaments assemble into force-generating systems involved in diverse cellular functions, including cell motility, adhesion, contractility and division. It remains unclear how networks of actin filaments, which individually generate piconewton forces, can produce forces reaching tens of nanonewtons. Here we use in situ cryo-electron tomography to unveil how the nanoscale architecture of macrophage podosomes enables basal membrane protrusion. We show that the sum of the actin polymerization forces at the membrane is not sufficient to explain podosome protrusive forces. Quantitative analysis of podosome organization demonstrates that the core is composed of a dense network of bent actin filaments storing elastic energy. Theoretical modelling of the network as a spring-loaded elastic material reveals that it exerts forces of up to tens of nanonewtons, similar to those evaluated experimentally. Thus, taking into account not only the interface with the membrane but also the bulk of the network, is crucial to understand force generation by actin machineries. Our integrative approach sheds light on the elastic behavior of dense actin networks and opens new avenues to understand force production inside cells.
BibTeX
@misc{jasnin2021elasticity,
  author = {Marion Jasnin and Jordan Hervy and Stéphanie Balor and Anaïs Bouissou and Amsha Proag and Raphaël Voituriez and Isabelle Maridonneau‐Parini and Wolfgang Baumeister and Serge Dmitrieff and Renaud Poincloux},
  title = {{Elasticity of dense actin networks produces nanonewton protrusive forces}},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1101/2021.04.13.439622},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}
Figure