Efficient reconstruction of constrained MSSM parameters from LHC data: A case study

Leszek Roszkowski, Roberto Ruiz de Austri, Roberto TrottaPhysical 2010 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

We present an efficient method of reconstructing the parameters of the constrained MSSM from assumed future LHC data, applied both on their own right and in combination with the cosmological determination of the relic dark matter abundance. Focusing on the ATLAS SU3 benchmark point, we demonstrate that our simple Gaussian approximation can recover the values of its parameters remarkably well. We examine two popular noninformative priors and obtain very similar results, although when we use an informative, naturalness-motivated prior, we find some sizeable differences. We show that a further strong improvement in reconstructing the SU3 parameters can by achieved by applying additional information about the relic abundance at the level of WMAP accuracy, although the expected data from Planck will have only a very limited additional impact. Further external data may be required to break some remaining degeneracies. We argue that the method presented here is applicable to a wide class of low-energy effective supersymmetric models, as it does not require one to deal with purely experimental issues, e.g., detector performance, and has the additional advantages of computational efficiency. Furthermore, our approach allows one to distinguish the effect of the model's internal structure and of the external data on the final parameters constraints.

Introduction

If Supersymmetry (SUSY) exists at the TeV scale, the Large Hadron Collider (LHC) is poised to discover a vast array of new particles. However, a significant challenge remains: the "inverse problem." The LHC does not directly measure fundamental high-energy parameters like $m_0$ or $m_{1/2}$; instead, it observes low-energy signatures such as decay edges and mass differences. Mapping these signatures back to the underlying theory typically requires computationally intensive Markov Chain Monte Carlo (MCMC) scans and full detector simulations. This paper introduces a computationally efficient "shortcut" for reconstructing fundamental SUSY parameters from future LHC data by employing a Gaussian approximation of the experimental likelihood and integrating cosmological constraints.

Methodology

The proposed framework relies on several key innovations to bypass traditional bottlenecks:

  • Gaussian Likelihood Approximation: Rather than performing full event-level simulations, the authors model expected ATLAS results as a multidimensional Gaussian centered on a benchmark point. This approach effectively captures the correlations between different mass measurements.
  • Nested Sampling: Utilizing the MultiNest algorithm allows for more efficient exploration of complex parameter spaces and more accurate calculation of Bayesian evidence compared to standard MCMC.
  • Bayesian Inference with Diverse Priors: The study evaluates the impact of different statistical "priors"—comparing non-informative (Flat and Log) priors against an informative "naturalness-motivated" CCR prior that penalizes fine-tuning.
  • Cosmological Integration: The relic density of dark matter ($\Omega_\chi h^2$) is incorporated as an external constraint, using both current WMAP-level data and projected Planck-level precision.

The ATLAS SU3 Benchmark

The study centers on the ATLAS SU3 benchmark point, a specific region in the Constrained Minimal Supersymmetric Standard Model (CMSSM) parameter space where many sparticles are light enough for LHC detection.

CMSSM and SM parameters for the ATLAS SU3 benchmark.

This benchmark provides a concrete testbed for the reconstruction method, defining the high-energy mass scales and Standard Model inputs used to generate the simulated data.

Results and Parameter Recovery

The method demonstrated remarkable efficiency, completing the entire analysis in approximately 24 hours on eight 3GHz processors—a significant speedup over traditional methods. For the SU3 benchmark, parameters like $m_{1/2}$ (300 GeV) and $m_0$ (100 GeV) were recovered with high precision.

Superpartner mass spectrum for the SU3 benchmark.

The predicted mass spectrum (shown above) highlights the "plethora" of particles the LHC would observe. While gaugino masses were well-constrained, the trilinear coupling $A_0$ remained difficult to pin down, exhibiting a persistent sign ambiguity.

Discussion

A key insight from the study is the role of the model's internal mathematical structure. The correlations between sparticle masses in the CMSSM often act "orthogonally" to experimental constraints, effectively "filling in the gaps" of LHC data. Furthermore, while the choice of non-informative priors (Flat vs. Log) became irrelevant once LHC data was included, "naturalness" priors still exerted a strong influence, indicating that theoretical assumptions remain significant.

The integration of cosmological data proved vital. While the LHC excels at measuring gaugino masses, it struggles with the common scalar mass $m_0$. Adding dark matter relic density data from WMAP acted as a powerful anchor, drastically improving $m_0$ reconstruction. Interestingly, the jump from WMAP to Planck-level precision offered only marginal gains, suggesting that theoretical uncertainties in SUSY calculations may eventually become the dominant bottleneck.

Conclusion

The Gaussian approximation method offers a powerful, efficient tool for phenomenological studies of SUSY. While some degeneracies remain—particularly for $\tan \beta$ and $A_0$—the combination of LHC data and cosmological constraints provides a robust path forward. Future work will need to address regions where theoretical errors are larger and incorporate additional external data, such as direct dark matter detection or B-physics measurements, to further break parameter degeneracies.

Summary updated

Abstract

We present an efficient method of reconstructing the parameters of the constrained MSSM from assumed future LHC data, applied both on their own right and in combination with the cosmological determination of the relic dark matter abundance. Focusing on the ATLAS SU3 benchmark point, we demonstrate that our simple Gaussian approximation can recover the values of its parameters remarkably well. We examine two popular noninformative priors and obtain very similar results, although when we use an informative, naturalness-motivated prior, we find some sizeable differences. We show that a further strong improvement in reconstructing the SU3 parameters can by achieved by applying additional information about the relic abundance at the level of WMAP accuracy, although the expected data from Planck will have only a very limited additional impact. Further external data may be required to break some remaining degeneracies. We argue that the method presented here is applicable to a wide class of low-energy effective supersymmetric models, as it does not require one to deal with purely experimental issues, e.g., detector performance, and has the additional advantages of computational efficiency. Furthermore, our approach allows one to distinguish the effect of the model's internal structure and of the external data on the final parameters constraints.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{roszkowski2010efficient,
  author = {Leszek Roszkowski and Roberto Ruiz de Austri and Roberto Trotta},
  title = {{Efficient reconstruction of constrained MSSM parameters from LHC data: A case study}},
  booktitle = {Physical},
  year = {2010},
  doi = {10.1103/physrevd.82.055003},
}
Figure