Efficient Few-Shot Learning for Pixel-Precise Handwritten Document Layout Analysis

Axel De Nardin, Silvia Zottin, Matteo Paier, Gian Luca Foresti, Emanuela Colombi, Claudio PiciarelliWACV 2023

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel few-shot learning framework for pixel-precise layout analysis of historical handwritten documents. By employing dynamic instance generation and a segmentation refinement process, the method achieves performance comparable to state-of-the-art fully supervised approaches while requiring significantly less annotated data.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Analyzing the layout of historical handwritten documents is crucial for humanities research, enabling easier study and facilitating subsequent tasks like optical character recognition. However, this task is challenging due to the inherent variability in layout, degradation from aging, and the complexity of intertwined text, corrections, and marginalia. Traditional approaches often rely on fully supervised learning, which demands extensive pixel-precise annotations. Creating these annotations is time-consuming and requires specialized knowledge, making them scarce for historical documents. This paper addresses the need for efficient layout analysis methods that can perform well with limited labeled data, a scenario where few-shot learning is particularly relevant but underexplored for this specific task.

Methods

The proposed framework combines a powerful Deep Convolutional Neural Network (DeepCNN) backbone with two novel components:

  • Dynamic Instance Generation: To maximize the exploitation of limited data, the authors first split document pages into non-overlapping patches to form a baseline training set. Then, during training, they dynamically generate random crops from these images. This approach aims to enhance generalization capabilities by providing more training instances without generating excessive data beforehand. The number of generated instances is proportional to the dataset's complexity.
  • Segmentation Refinement Process: For improved pixel-precise segmentation, a refinement process is applied during inference. This process leverages the Sauvola thresholding technique, an adaptive method for document binarization. By applying a binary mask derived from Sauvola's algorithm to the coarse segmentation maps produced by the backbone network, the method effectively separates foreground elements (text, decorations) from the background, leading to more precise predictions.

The backbone network used is DeepLabV3, chosen for its ability to maintain higher spatial resolution in feature maps through atrous (dilated) convolutions and its Atrous Spatial Pyramid Pooling (ASPP) module, which captures information at multiple scales.

Datasets

The primary dataset used is the DIVA-HisDB dataset [22]. This dataset comprises 150 high-resolution, annotated pages from three medieval manuscripts (CSG18, CSG863, and CB55), characterized by complex layouts and varying levels of degradation. The dataset provides pixel-level ground truth segmentation for four classes of elements. For training their few-shot model, the authors used only 6 images (2 from each manuscript), a significant reduction compared to typical training sets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Few-shot learning is viable for historical document layout analysis: The paper demonstrates that effective pixel-precise layout analysis can be achieved with very limited training data, challenging the assumption that large annotated datasets are always necessary.
  • Dynamic data augmentation is crucial: The "dynamic instance generation" is not just about increasing data quantity but about intelligently creating relevant training samples that adapt to the complexity of the data, improving generalization.
  • Post-processing refinement significantly boosts precision: The Sauvola thresholding-based refinement step is highlighted as the most impactful component, substantially improving the accuracy of segmentation maps, especially for distinguishing fine details.
  • Balancing computational cost and performance: The proposed method achieves competitive results while significantly reducing the data requirements, making it more practical for real-world scenarios where data annotation is a bottleneck.

Key Results

The proposed framework achieved performance comparable to state-of-the-art fully supervised methods on the DIVA-HisDB dataset, despite using only 6 training images.

  • Ablation Study: The segmentation refinement process alone improved mean scores by 5.5% to 9%, while dynamic crop generation provided an additional 2% boost. Combined, these strategies yielded a 9% average improvement across metrics, with IoU increasing by 12.3%.
  • Comparison with other models: The proposed method outperformed other popular semantic segmentation models (FCN, LRASPP, PSPNet, DeepLabV3, DeepLabV3+) in terms of IoU and F1-score, achieving an average improvement of 2.9% across metrics compared to the second-best model (DeepLabV3+).
  • Comparison with MLA (State-of-the-art): The framework significantly closed the gap with MLA, a heavier system trained on 180,000 patches, achieving a 0.8% difference in Precision and a 1.6% average margin across metrics, while using only 4000 patches (a 45x reduction in data).

Qualitative results show that the proposed method correctly identifies all three foreground classes (main text, comments, decorations) with high precision, outperforming other models in accurately delineating character boundaries and handling complex layouts.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Manual parameter selection: The authors acknowledge that the segmentation refinement process currently requires manual selection of additional parameters.
  • Future Work: They propose exploring automated solutions for parameter selection in the refinement process, aiming to further improve the framework's predictions and address this limitation.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{nardin2023efficient,
  author = {Axel De Nardin and Silvia Zottin and Matteo Paier and Gian Luca Foresti and Emanuela Colombi and Claudio Piciarelli},
  title = {{Efficient Few-Shot Learning for Pixel-Precise Handwritten Document Layout Analysis}},
  booktitle = {IEEE/CVF Winter Conference on Applications of Computer Vision},
  year = {2023},
}
Figure