Efficient Collaborative Tree Exploration with Breadth-First Depth-Next

Romain Cosson, Laurent Massoulié, Laurent ViennotDISC 2023 · OpenReview

TL;DR

This paper introduces BFDN, a novel algorithm for collaborative tree exploration by a team of robots. BFDN achieves a near-optimal runtime of $2n/k + O(D^2 \log k)$ rounds, significantly improving upon existing methods, especially for trees with large depths. The algorithm's analysis relies on a new two-player game that also offers insights into resource allocation under uncertainty.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Imagine a team of robots tasked with exploring an unknown tree structure, like a network or a maze, and reporting back to the starting point. The goal is to traverse every edge of the tree as quickly as possible. This is known as collaborative tree exploration. The challenge lies in coordinating multiple robots in an unknown environment, where they discover the structure as they go (online exploration). Existing algorithms have trade-offs: some are efficient for large numbers of robots but struggle with deep trees, while others have better theoretical guarantees but are complex or less practical. This paper aims to provide a simpler, more efficient algorithm that performs well across a wide range of tree structures and robot team sizes.

Methods

The core contribution is the Breadth-First Depth-Next (BFDN) algorithm. BFDN combines two exploration strategies:

  • Breadth-First (BF) phase: When a robot is at the root, it's assigned an "anchor" node. It then moves towards this anchor using a breadth-first approach, prioritizing nodes closer to the root that are adjacent to unexplored edges. This phase is about efficiently reaching new areas.
  • Depth-Next (DN) phase: Once a robot reaches its anchor, it switches to a depth-first-like exploration within the subtree rooted at that anchor. It prioritizes exploring dangling (unexplored) edges and moves upwards towards the root if no such edges are available. This phase is about thoroughly exploring a specific region.

The analysis of BFDN is grounded in a novel two-player zero-sum game involving "balls in urns." In this game, one player (the adversary) tries to prolong the game, while the other (the player) tries to end it quickly. The player's strategy, which involves assigning balls to the least loaded urns, mirrors how BFDN assigns robots to anchors. This game-theoretic approach provides a powerful tool for bounding the algorithm's performance. The paper also extends BFDN to handle restricted communication, adversarial robot failures, and exploration of general graphs. Finally, a recursive version, BFDN$_\ell$, is proposed to further optimize performance for very deep trees.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The problem is theoretical and involves exploring arbitrary tree structures.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Hybrid Exploration Strategy: Combining breadth-first (for reaching new areas) and depth-first (for thorough exploration) is key to BFDN's efficiency. This hybrid approach allows robots to efficiently cover the tree without getting stuck in deep branches too early.
  • Anchor-Based Exploration: Assigning robots to specific "anchors" within the tree provides a structured way to manage exploration, especially in deeper parts of the tree. This breaks down the problem into smaller, more manageable sub-problems.
  • Game Theory for Algorithm Analysis: The "balls in urns" game provides a surprisingly effective and elegant way to analyze the competitive performance of BFDN. This highlights the power of abstracting algorithmic problems into game-theoretic frameworks.
  • Resource Allocation Analogy: The game's strategy of assigning tasks (balls) to the least loaded resources (urns) directly translates to how BFDN assigns robots to explore subtrees. This suggests broader applications of the game's insights to real-world resource management problems.
  • Recursive Improvement for Depth: The recursive BFDN$_\ell$ algorithm demonstrates that for very deep trees, a hierarchical, recursive approach can yield significant performance gains, further pushing the boundaries of exploration efficiency.

Key Results

  • BFDN Runtime: The proposed BFDN algorithm achieves a collaborative tree exploration time of $2n/k + O(D^2 \log k)$ rounds, where $n$ is the number of nodes, $k$ is the number of robots, and $D$ is the tree depth.
  • Performance Improvement: This runtime significantly outperforms previous algorithms like CTE ($O(n/\log k + D)$) and Yo* ($O(n/k + D)$ with a large additive term) for many parameter ranges, particularly for trees with large depths ($D = o(\sqrt{n})$).
  • Game Theory Result: The two-player "balls in urns" game is shown to end in at most $k \min\{\log \Delta, \log k\} + 2k$ steps, where $\Delta$ is the maximum degree of the tree. This result has implications for online resource allocation.
  • Extensions: BFDN is shown to be adaptable to scenarios with limited memory/communication, adversarial robot breakdowns, and exploration of general graphs, maintaining strong performance guarantees.
  • Recursive BFDN$_\ell$: A recursive version achieves a runtime of $O(n/k^{1/\ell} + \log k \cdot D^{1+1/\ell})$ for parameter $\ell \ge 1$, offering improved performance for trees with large depths.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Graph Exploration Complexity: While BFDN can be adapted for general graphs, its guarantees are weaker and require additional assumptions (e.g., robots knowing their distance to the origin). The paper notes that for general graphs, the problem is significantly harder.
  • Adversarial Settings: The paper explores adversarial robot breakdowns and a specific type of adversary. More complex adversarial models (e.g., an adversary that observes moves before blocking) could be investigated.
  • Open Questions: The authors highlight an open question: whether a deterministic exploration algorithm with a guarantee of $2n/k + O(D^c)$ for $c < 2$ exists. They also suggest exploring continuous-time exploration scenarios.
  • Practical Implementation: While BFDN is described as simple to implement, further work on practical deployment and empirical validation on real-world robotic systems would be valuable.

Summary updated

Abstract

We study the problem of collaborative tree exploration introduced by Fraigniaud, Gasieniec, Kowalski, and Pelc [Pierre Fraigniaud et al., 2006] where a team of k agents is tasked to collectively go through all the edges of an unknown tree as fast as possible and return to the root. Denoting by n the total number of nodes and by D the tree depth, the 𝒪(n/log(k)+D) algorithm of [Pierre Fraigniaud et al., 2006] achieves a 𝒪(k/log(k)) competitive ratio with respect to the cost of offline exploration which is at least max{{2n/k,2D}}. Brass, Cabrera-Mora, Gasparri, and Xiao [Peter Brass et al., 2011] study an alternative performance criterion, the competitive overhead with respect to the cost of offline exploration, with their 2n/k+𝒪((D+k)^k) guarantee. In this paper, we introduce "Breadth-First Depth-Next" (BFDN), a novel and simple algorithm that performs collaborative tree exploration in 2n/k+𝒪(D²log(k)) rounds, thus outperforming [Peter Brass et al., 2011] for all values of (n,D,k) and being order-optimal for trees of depth D = o(√n). Our analysis relies on a two-player game reflecting a problem of online resource allocation that could be of independent interest. We extend the guarantees of BFDN to: scenarios with limited memory and communication, adversarial setups where robots can be blocked, and exploration of classes of non-tree graphs. Finally, we provide a recursive version of BFDN with a runtime of 𝒪_𝓁(n/k^{1/𝓁}+log(k) D^{1+1/𝓁}) for parameter 𝓁 ≥ 1, thereby improving performance for trees with large depth.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{cosson2023efficient,
  author = {Romain Cosson and Laurent Massoulié and Laurent Viennot},
  title = {{Efficient Collaborative Tree Exploration with Breadth-First Depth-Next}},
  booktitle = {DISC},
  year = {2023},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=pu5zw9ELsx},
}
Figure