Efficient Algorithms And Representations For Chance-constrained Mixed Constraint Programming

Cheng FangIJCAI 2017 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper tackles the challenge of making decisions under uncertainty more reliable by improving "chance-constrained constraint programming" (CC-CP). The authors introduce novel ways to represent uncertainty using data-driven quantile bounds, which are more flexible and less prone to over-conservatism than existing methods, paving the way for more robust autonomous systems.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Autonomous systems often struggle with reliability due to inherent uncertainties in their environment. Chance-constrained constraint programming (CC-CP) aims to address this by allowing agents to specify constraints on controllable decisions while also bounding the probability of violating constraints related to uncontrollable environmental factors. However, current CC-CP methods face two main hurdles: they often rely on computationally expensive nonlinear optimization solvers, limiting their scalability to real-world problems, and they tend to use overly conservative uncertainty representations, especially when dealing with data-driven probability distributions. This paper seeks to develop more efficient and less conservative methods for CC-CP by focusing on novel uncertainty representations.

Methods

The core of this paper's contribution lies in its novel approach to uncertainty representation. Instead of fitting probability distributions directly from data (which can lead to over-fitting), the authors propose constructing "uncertainty sets" from data. Specifically, they leverage order statistics and the Beta distribution to derive statistically sound lower and upper bounds for quantiles of random variables. This allows them to define probabilistic guarantees without assuming a specific underlying distribution. The algorithm, named "Fantana," constructs these bounds with explicit confidence levels, providing robustness against sampling variations. This approach allows for the creation of multiple, flexible uncertainty sets, which can be reasoned over during optimization, offering a more nuanced approach than traditional robust optimization.

Datasets

The authors evaluated their method using a dataset of 48,361 Boston subway traversal times between Davis Square and Porter Square. This dataset was used to test the accuracy and conservatism of their quantile-based bounds compared to kernel density estimation.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Data-Driven Quantile Bounds: Directly estimating quantile bounds from data, rather than fitting a full distribution, offers a more robust and less assumption-heavy way to represent uncertainty.
  • Explicit Confidence: Providing explicit confidence intervals for these quantile bounds makes the uncertainty representation itself more reliable and transparent.
  • Flexibility in Uncertainty Sets: The ability to construct multiple, flexible uncertainty sets allows agents to choose representations that best suit the specific problem and risk tolerance, avoiding the "one-size-fits-all" conservatism of some robust optimization methods.
  • Discrete Choices for Robustness: Using discrete quantile bounds can be leveraged by discrete search techniques, potentially leading to more efficient solutions than optimizing over continuous, nonlinear density functions.

Key Results

The empirical evaluation on the Boston subway traversal time data showed promising results:

  • The proposed method was not overly conservative, with an average proportion of test data points falling below the lower bound of 3.4% (compared to the target of 5%).
  • Crucially, the method demonstrated correctness with respect to the 99% confidence bound, meaning that in all 10,000 trials, the proportion of test data points smaller than the chosen lower bound was less than 5%.
  • In contrast, kernel density estimation provided an incorrect bound in 9.89% of the trials, highlighting the robustness of the proposed quantile-based approach.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that their current implementation of Fantana focuses on constructing uncertainty sets. Future work will concentrate on demonstrating how these sets can be used to achieve faster computation for chance-constrained constraint programming, particularly in the context of chance-constrained probabilistic simple temporal problems (cc-pSTPs). They plan to explore decomposition strategies for cc-pSTPs, separating risk management from temporal consistency checking, and to develop efficient scheduling algorithms and cut-learning techniques for these problems. This includes generalizing cut learning for the broader class of problems described in Problem 1 and iteratively constructing uncertainty sets for risk allocation.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{fang2017efficient,
  author = {Cheng Fang},
  title = {{Efficient Algorithms And Representations For Chance-constrained Mixed Constraint Programming}},
  booktitle = {International Joint Conference on Artificial Intelligence},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.24963/ijcai.2017/749},
}
Figure