Efficiency Allocation of Provincial Carbon Reduction Target in China’s “13·5” Period: Based on Zero-Sum-Gains SBM Model

Wen Guo, Tao Sun, Hongjun DaiSustainability 2017 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel "Zero-Sum-Gains" Slacks-Based Measure (ZSG-SBM) model to efficiently allocate China's national carbon reduction targets to individual provinces. The ZSG-SBM model, by treating carbon emissions as a "bad" output and incorporating a game theory approach, demonstrates that an efficiency-oriented allocation leads to better long-term low-carbon economic development compared to traditional administrative approaches.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

China, aiming for sustainable development, has set national carbon reduction targets, such as the 18% reduction in carbon intensity during the "13th Five-Year Plan" period (2016-2020). However, provinces within China have vastly different economic scales, resource endowments, and industrial structures. Simply applying a uniform reduction target or an "equity-oriented" administrative allocation can lead to inefficiencies and hinder the optimal path towards a low-carbon economy. The challenge is to find an efficient and equitable way to distribute these reduction targets among provinces, considering their unique circumstances and the overall national goal.

Methods

The core methodological contribution is the development of the Zero-Sum-Gains Slacks-Based Measure (ZSG-SBM) model. This model builds upon the traditional Slacks-Based Measure (SBM) model, which is adept at evaluating the efficiency of decision-making units with multiple inputs and outputs, including "undesirable" outputs like carbon emissions.

The ZSG-SBM model incorporates two key innovations:

  1. "Zero-Sum-Gains" Game Theory: This concept is applied to the allocation of carbon reduction targets. It assumes that the total carbon emissions remain constant, meaning any increase in emissions in one province must be offset by a decrease in another. This reflects a competitive allocation scenario where the sum of gains and losses is zero.
  2. Efficiency-Oriented Allocation: Unlike administrative approaches that might prioritize fairness based on historical data or resource endowments, the ZSG-SBM model focuses on achieving Pareto optimality. It reallocates "undesirable output slacks" to ensure all provinces reach an efficiency frontier, thereby optimizing the use of resources and minimizing carbon emissions for a given economic output.

The paper also sets up four development scenarios for China's economic system during the "13th Five-Year Plan" period, considering variations in economic growth (low vs. high speed) and energy consumption structure (changed vs. unchanged). These scenarios are used to test the robustness of the ZSG-SBM model.

Datasets

The study utilizes data for China's 30 provinces for the "13th Five-Year Plan" period (2016-2020). The data includes:

  • Inputs: Population (as a proxy for labor), Capital (estimated using the perpetual inventory method), Energy consumption.
  • Desirable Output: Gross Domestic Product (GDP).
  • Undesirable Output: Carbon emissions.

The data for inputs and outputs were predicted based on the four defined scenarios and collected from sources like the China Statistical Yearbook and China Energy Statistical Yearbook. Tibet was excluded due to a lack of energy statistics.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Efficiency over Equity for Long-Term Goals: The study strongly suggests that an "efficiency-oriented" allocation of carbon reduction targets, as achieved by the ZSG-SBM model, is more aligned with the long-term requirements of a low-carbon economy than "equity-oriented" administrative allocations. While administrative methods might offer short-term feasibility, they can lead to efficiency losses.
  • Dual Constraints Enhance Efficiency: Implementing both carbon intensity and energy intensity constraints simultaneously leads to better provincial carbon emission efficiency compared to considering only carbon intensity. This dual constraint forces provinces to optimize their energy consumption structures, pushing them closer to the efficiency frontier.
  • Provincial Heterogeneity Matters: The significant differences in carbon emission efficiency among provinces highlight the need for tailored allocation strategies. A one-size-fits-all approach is inefficient.
  • "Zero-Sum-Gains" as a Realistic Allocation Framework: The ZSG-SBM model's ability to ensure total carbon emissions remain unchanged across provinces (under the defined constraints) provides a robust framework for national target achievement.

Key Results

  • The ZSG-SBM model successfully allocates carbon reduction targets, leading to all 30 provinces reaching the efficiency frontier (hZSG* = 1.0000). This signifies an effective allocation of inputs and outputs and Pareto optimality.
  • In contrast, an average distribution principle for carbon reduction targets results in significant efficiency differences, with a maximum gap of 54.56% between Beijing and Shanxi province.
  • Sixteen provinces were found to require further reduction targets (i.e., their allocated targets were above the national average of 18%), often those with lower carbon emission efficiency and underdeveloped economies, or major industrial provinces.
  • The study categorizes provinces into four areas based on per capita GDP and carbon emission reduction pressure, providing tailored development path recommendations for each. For example, developed eastern provinces are advised to focus on clean energy, while resource-rich provinces like Shanxi need to accelerate the elimination of overcapacity in coal and steel industries.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Data Limitations: The study acknowledges the lack of energy statistics for Tibet, leading to its exclusion.
  • Scenario-Based Predictions: The analysis relies on predicted data for the "13th Five-Year Plan" period, which inherently involves uncertainty.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that governments could adopt a hybrid approach, combining "fairness-oriented" and "efficiency-oriented" methods to balance short-term feasibility with long-term efficiency goals. Further research could explore more sophisticated allocation strategies and incorporate additional factors influencing provincial development paths.

Summary updated

Abstract

Firstly, we introduce the “Zero Sum Gains” game theory into the SBM (Slacks-based Measure) model, and establish the ZSG-SBM model. Then, set up 4 development scenarios for the China’s economic system in “13·5” (The Chinese government formulates a Five-Year Planning for national economic and social development every five years, “13·5” means 2016 to 2020.) period through two dimensions as economic growth and energy consumption structure, and make the efficient allocation in provincial level of carbon reduction target by using the above ZSG-SBM model based on the China’s overall carbon reduction constraint (18%) which is set in “13·5” planning. Finally, we analyze the provincial development path of low-carbon economy by comparing the economic development status with the allocated result of carbon reduction target. Results show that: After the ZSG-SBM model being applied to the efficiency allocation of carbon emission, the input and output indicators of the 30 provinces realize the effective allocation, and the carbon emission efficiency reaches the efficiency frontier. The equity-oriented administrative allocation scheme of government will bring about efficiency loss in a certain degree, and the efficiency allocation scheme, based on the ZSG-SBM model, fits better with the long-term development requirement of low-carbon economy. On the basis of carbon intensity constraint, the re-constraint of energy intensity will force the provinces to optimize their energy consumption structure, thereby enhancing the overall carbon emission efficiency of China. Sixteen provinces’ allocation results of carbon reduction target are above China’s average (18%) in “13·5” period, all the provinces should select appropriate development path of low-carbon economy according to the status of their resource endowment, economic level, industrial structure and energy consumption structure.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{guo2017efficiency,
  author = {Wen Guo and Tao Sun and Hongjun Dai},
  title = {{Efficiency Allocation of Provincial Carbon Reduction Target in China’s “13·5” Period: Based on Zero-Sum-Gains SBM Model}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.3390/su9020167},
}
Figure