Efficacy of Possible Strategies to Mitigate the Urban Heat Island Based on Urbanized High-Resolution Land Data Assimilation System (u-HRLDAS)

Meiling Gao, Fei Chen, Huanfeng Shen, Michael Barlage, Huifang Li, Zhenyu Tan, Liangpei ZhangJournal of the Meteorological Society of Japan Ser II 2019 · DOI

Abstract

Summer heat waves are a significant public health threat in China. This paper takes Wuhan, one of the country's "furnace cities," as a case study to explore strategies for mitigating the surface urban heat island (UHI). Using the urbanized High-Resolution Land Data Assimilation System (u-HRLDAS) at 1-km resolution, researchers evaluated green roofs, cool roofs, bright pavements, and altered building patterns. The model uniquely accounts for Wuhan's abundant lakes using a dynamic lake model. Results indicate that considering lake effects reduces UHI intensity by up to 1.0 K. While green and cool roofs are effective daytime mitigators, changing urban building patterns—specifically homogenizing building density—provides the most consistent cooling throughout the day and night, reducing UHI by 1.2–2.6 K.

Introduction: The Challenge of Urban Heat in Wuhan

The Urban Heat Island (UHI) effect, where cities are significantly warmer than surrounding rural areas, is a growing public health crisis. Wuhan is a prime example of a mega-city facing extreme thermal stress. Modeling UHI in Wuhan is particularly challenging due to the presence of over 160 lakes, which significantly influence local microclimates. Most standard models either ignore these water bodies or use outdated land-use data. This study fills these gaps by providing a comprehensive, high-resolution comparison of mitigation strategies, including the often-overlooked impact of urban geometry.

Methodology: High-Resolution Modeling and the Lake Effect

The researchers employed the urbanized High-Resolution Land Data Assimilation System (u-HRLDAS). Unlike fully coupled atmospheric models, this "offline" system provides high-resolution (1-km) results with lower computational requirements. A key novelty was the integration of a 1D dynamic lake model to account for Wuhan’s water bodies. Additionally, the team updated land-use maps using GlobeLand30 and Landsat 8 data to accurately reflect the city’s rapid urbanization.

Geographical context of Wuhan, illustrating its administrative boundaries, topography (DEM), and significant lake and river systems.

Key Findings: Mitigation Strategies and Their Efficacy

The study evaluated 11 different simulations to determine the most effective cooling methods:

  • The Lake Effect: Including lakes in the simulation reduced UHI intensity by 1.0 K during the day and 0.5 K at night. Ignoring these water bodies leads to a significant overestimation of urban heat.
  • Green vs. Cool Roofs: Green roofs outperformed cool roofs slightly, reducing daytime UHI by up to 2.1 K through shading and evapotranspiration. Cool roofs (high albedo) provided a maximum reduction of 1.8 K. Both, however, offer minimal relief at night.
  • The Power of Urban Geometry: Changing the urban building pattern was the only strategy that provided significant cooling 24/7. "Density-driven" changes—distributing building density more uniformly—were particularly effective, reducing UHI by 1.2–2.6 K. "Height-driven" changes (raising building heights while increasing surrounding vegetation) reduced UHI by 0.4–0.9 K.
  • Bright Pavements: These were the least effective strategy, as city roads are often shaded by buildings, limiting the amount of solar radiation the reflective pavement can interact with.
Spatial distribution of simulated UHI mitigation effects across Wuhan for different urban planning and material strategies.

Conclusion and Policy Implications

While reflective materials and green infrastructure are valuable for daytime cooling, strategic urban planning regarding building density and height offers the most robust solution for mitigating heat stress. For lake-rich cities, accurate modeling must include water bodies to provide reliable data for policymakers. These findings offer a practical guideline for creating more habitable and resilient mega-cities.

Summary updated

Abstract

Summer heat waves are a significant public health threat in China. This paper took Wuhan (one of the four hottest furnace cities in China) as an example to explore several strategies for mitigating the surface urban heat island (UHI), measured by the land surface temperature, including green roofs, cool roofs, bright pavements, and altered urban building patterns. The offline urbanized High-Resolution Land Data Assimilation System (u-HRLDAS) was used to conduct 1-km resolution numerical simulations, which also accounts for the effects of Wuhan's abundant lakes on UHI evolution, with a dynamic lake model. The diurnal cycle and spatial distribution of simulated UHI were analyzed under different mitigation strategies. Results show that considering lake effects reduces daytime (nighttime) UHI intensity by about 1.0 K (0.5 K). Green roofs and cool roofs are more effective in mitigating daytime UHI than bright pavements. The maximum UHI reduction is about 2.1 K at 13:00 local time by replacing 80 % of conventional roofs with green roofs. The UHI mitigation efficiency increases with larger fractions of green roofs, and increased albedo of roofs and roads. In contrast to green roofs, cool roofs and bright pavements are ineffective during nighttime, changing the urban building pattern to mitigate UHI is effective throughout the day. “Height-driven building structure changing” (raising the building height while changing the fraction of impervious surface in each grid to keep the total building volume intact) can reduce surface UHI intensity by 0.4-0.9 K, and “density-driven building structure changing” (distributing building density uniformly and modifying the building height to make the total building volume unchanged) reduces UHI by 1.2-2.6 K. These results showed new insights in mitigating UHIs for mega cities, like Wuhan, and provides a practical guideline for policymakers to offer more habitable cities.
BibTeX
@article{gao2019efficacy,
  author = {Meiling Gao and Fei Chen and Huanfeng Shen and Michael Barlage and Huifang Li and Zhenyu Tan and Liangpei Zhang},
  title = {{Efficacy of Possible Strategies to Mitigate the Urban Heat Island Based on Urbanized High-Resolution Land Data Assimilation System (u-HRLDAS)}},
  journal = {Journal of the Meteorological Society of Japan Ser II},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.2151/jmsj.2019-060},
}
Figure