Efficacy of Biological and Physical Enhancement on Targeted Muscle Reinnervation

Siyang Zhong, Zijun Zhang, Huan Su, Chenyang Li, Yifeng Lin, Wei Lu, Zhendong Jiang, Lin YangCyborg 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates methods to improve outcomes for patients undergoing Targeted Muscle Reinnervation (TMR) surgery, a technique crucial for advanced prosthetic control. Researchers found that combining low-frequency electrical stimulation (FES) and nerve growth factor (NGF) with TMR in a rat model significantly enhanced neuromuscular function recovery compared to TMR alone. This suggests a promising dual-approach strategy for better rehabilitation after nerve injury.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Peripheral nerve injuries, often resulting from trauma, ischemia, or dislocations, can lead to significant functional deficits, including muscle atrophy, sensory loss, and chronic pain. Targeted Muscle Reinnervation (TMR) is a surgical technique designed to restore myoelectric signal acquisition for advanced prosthetic control by rerouting residual nerves to reinnervate denervated muscles. While TMR offers a way to regain control signals, the functional recovery of the reinnervated muscles themselves is often suboptimal. This is due to the slow rate of nerve regeneration, muscle denervation, and subsequent atrophy. The paper addresses the challenge of accelerating and improving this functional recovery post-TMR, aiming to enhance the effectiveness of prosthetic limb control and overall patient quality of life.

Methods

The researchers established a TMR rat model using Sprague-Dawley (SD) adult male rats. These rats were divided into three groups:

  • TMR group: Received TMR surgery only.
  • TMR + FES group: Received TMR surgery followed by low-frequency electrical stimulation (FES) therapy.
  • TMR + NGF group: Received TMR surgery followed by local injection of nerve growth factor (NGF).

Key aspects of their methodology include:

  • Surgical Procedure: A detailed description of the TMR surgery is provided, involving the division and anastomosis of the median nerve to the deep pectoral muscle. Electrode implantation for EMG signal acquisition was also performed.
  • Postoperative Treatments:
    • FES: Applied using a low-frequency electrical stimulation device (20 Hz, 200 μs pulse width, 3-5 mA intensity) for 30 minutes daily over four weeks.
  • NGF: Injected into the pectoralis major muscle (20 µg daily for four weeks).
  • EMG Signal Acquisition: Electromyography (EMG) signals from the pectoralis major muscles were recorded weekly for four weeks using a biosignal acquisition system while the rats were on a treadmill.
  • Signal Analysis:
    • Wavelet Packet Decomposition: Used to analyze the complex EMG signals, allowing for better time-frequency localization and extraction of relevant information. This technique decomposes signals into different frequency bands to analyze local details.
  • Average Rectified Value (ARV): Calculated from the EMG signals as a measure of mean muscle activity and used to compare muscle activation levels across groups.
  • Statistical Analysis: SPSS 21.0 was used for statistical analysis, employing ANOVA and independent sample t-tests to compare groups and paired t-tests for within-group comparisons.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study utilized data collected from the experimental rat models.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Synergistic Effects: The study strongly suggests that a combination of physical (FES) and biological (NGF) enhancement therapies can synergistically improve neuromuscular recovery after TMR, yielding better results than either treatment alone.
  • Cumulative Effect: The researchers hypothesize that the benefits of FES and NGF are cumulative. While individual treatments might show modest effects over short periods, their repeated application over time leads to significant, potentially overlooked, improvements.
  • Neuroplasticity and Age: The paper touches upon the importance of neuroplasticity and suggests that younger rats might be more responsive to FES and NGF due to higher regenerative capacity, highlighting age as a factor in treatment efficacy.
  • Advanced Signal Processing: The use of wavelet packet decomposition for EMG signal analysis is a key methodological insight, enabling a more nuanced understanding of muscle activity by separating and analyzing different frequency components of the signal.

Key Results

  • Improved EMG Amplitude: Both the TMR + NGF and TMR + FES groups showed generally stronger EMG amplitudes compared to the TMR group at one week post-surgery. By the fourth week, all groups showed increased EMG amplitude, with the TMR + FES and TMR + NGF groups exhibiting significantly greater amplitude than the TMR group.
  • ARV Trends: The ARV values of the pectoralis major muscle increased significantly from week 1 to week 4 in all groups. Notably, the TMR + FES and TMR + NGF groups showed more pronounced growth and better recovery compared to the TMR group at week 4. While the TMR + NGF group's ARV exceeded the TMR + FES group at week 4, the difference was not statistically significant (P > 0.05).
  • Successful Reinnervation: EMG signals were successfully acquired from the target muscles in all rats, indicating successful reinnervation and functional recovery to some extent across all groups.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Small Sample Size: The authors acknowledge that the small sample size might have limited their ability to completely account for individual differences between rats, which could influence the experimental results.
  • Individual Differences: The presence of two rats in the TMR group with significantly higher ARV values at week 4 than others in the same group highlights the impact of individual variability.
  • Treatment Parameter Optimization: The paper notes that many factors influence FES efficacy, including time, intensity, frequency, pulse width, duration, and electrode placement. Similarly, NGF administration routes and its protein structure require further consideration.
  • Future Direction: The authors propose investigating the therapeutic effect of combining FES and NGF for neurological reconstruction, exploring related factors affecting this combined therapy, and aiming to develop more applicable rehabilitation programs. They also suggest further research into the specific mechanisms of NGF's action and its interaction with other factors in nerve repair.

Summary updated

Abstract

Targeted muscle reinnervation (TMR) is a microsurgical repair technique to reconstruct the anatomical structure between the distal nerve and the muscle stump to provide more myoelectric information to the artificially intelligent prosthesis. Postoperative functional electrical stimulation treatment of the patient's denervated muscle or proximal nerve stump as well as nerve growth factor injection is effective in promoting nerve regeneration and muscle function recovery. In this experiment, we successfully established a TMR rat model and divided Sprague-Dawley (SD) adult male rats into TMR group, TMR + FES group, and TMR + NGF group according to TMR and whether they received FES treatment or NGF injection after surgery, and the recovery effect of rat neuromuscular function was assessed by analyzing EMG signals. Through the experiments, we confirmed that growth factor supplementation and low-frequency electrical stimulation can effectively promote the regeneration of the transplanted nerve as well as significantly enhance the motor function of the target muscle and have a positive effect on the regeneration of the transplanted nerve.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhong2022efficacy,
  author = {Siyang Zhong and Zijun Zhang and Huan Su and Chenyang Li and Yifeng Lin and Wei Lu and Zhendong Jiang and Lin Yang},
  title = {{Efficacy of Biological and Physical Enhancement on Targeted Muscle Reinnervation}},
  booktitle = {Cyborg},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.34133/2022/9759265},
}
Figure