Efficacy and Safety of Sodium Citrate and Argatroban in Continuous Renal Replacement Therapy of Patients with High Risk of Bleeding

李兰 Li Lan, Lingling Gu, Yao Zhang, Zhiwei Zhuang, Yanxia Yu, Qian Zhang, Jinhui Xu, Xiaowen Xu, Lian TangResearch Square 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

For critically ill patients requiring dialysis-like support (CRRT) but facing a high risk of bleeding, choosing the right "blood thinner" is a delicate balancing act. This study finds that while Regional Citrate Anticoagulation (RCA) keeps filters running longer and prevents clotting better than low-dose Argatroban, Argatroban offers a significantly better safety profile with fewer metabolic complications.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Continuous Renal Replacement Therapy (CRRT) is a life-saving intervention for patients with acute kidney injury. However, because blood is being pumped through an external circuit, it tends to clot, which can clog filters and interrupt treatment. To prevent this, clinicians use anticoagulants.

The "gold standard" is often heparin, but for patients already at high risk of bleeding (e.g., post-surgery or with low platelet counts), systemic heparin is dangerous. This leaves clinicians with two main alternatives:

  1. Regional Citrate Anticoagulation (RCA): This "tricks" the blood into not clotting only while it is inside the machine by binding calcium, then restores calcium before the blood returns to the patient. It is effective but complex to manage.
  2. Argatroban: A synthetic thrombin inhibitor. While it acts systemically (throughout the whole body), low doses are thought to be safer than heparin.

The authors sought to determine which of these two strategies provides the best balance of filter efficacy and patient safety.

Methods

The researchers conducted a retrospective observational cohort study at the Suzhou Municipal Hospital, analyzing data from 207 critically ill patients treated between 2020 and 2021.

  • The RCA Group (n=103): Received 4% sodium citrate at the "arterial" end of the circuit, with calcium replaced at the "venous" end.
  • The Argatroban Group (n=104): Received low-dose Argatroban (0.1–0.3 µg/kg·min) infused into the circuit.

The team tracked filter life span, the "grade" of clotting events (using a 0–III scale), bleeding complications, and biochemical markers like electrolyte levels and coagulation times (PT, INR, APTT).

Datasets

The study utilized a clinical dataset of 207 patients and a total of 883 CRRT cycles.

  • RCA Group: 427 cycles.
  • Argatroban Group: 456 cycles. The data included demographic information, comorbidities (hypertension, diabetes, etc.), and reason for ICU admission (septic shock, AKI, etc.). No new public benchmarks or external datasets were introduced.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Regional" Advantage: RCA lived up to its name. Because it only anticoagulates the blood inside the machine, it didn't significantly alter the patients' systemic coagulation tests (PT/INR). In contrast, even low-dose Argatroban had a systemic effect, prolonging clotting times throughout the patient's body.
  • The Metabolic Tax: The efficacy of RCA comes at a cost. Because citrate affects calcium and acid-base balance, the RCA group saw significantly higher rates of metabolic complications (alkalosis and electrolyte imbalances).
  • Filter Longevity vs. Safety: RCA is the superior "plumber"—it keeps the filters clear for longer. However, Argatroban is the "safer" drug for the patient's overall internal chemistry, resulting in roughly half the rate of total adverse reactions compared to RCA.

Key Results

  • Filter Life: RCA filters lasted significantly longer than Argatroban filters (42.1 hours vs. 41.2 hours, p=0.009). While the numerical difference seems small, it represents a statistically significant improvement in circuit stability.
  • Clotting Events: RCA was better at preventing severe (Grade III) clotting events compared to Argatroban (p=0.012).
  • Adverse Reactions: The total incidence of adverse reactions was nearly double in the RCA group (19.42%) compared to the Argatroban group (9.62%), driven largely by metabolic issues.
  • Mortality: There was no significant difference in 42-day mortality between the two groups (~49% for RCA vs. ~44% for Argatroban).
  • Bleeding: Interestingly, despite Argatroban's systemic effect, there was no statistically significant difference in actual bleeding events between the two groups.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  1. Retrospective Design: As an observational study rather than a randomized controlled trial (RCT), there may be unmeasured biases in how patients were assigned to each group.
  2. Data Gaps: The study only recorded the first 4–5 CRRT cycles for patients requiring long-term treatment, which might not capture the full picture of long-term anticoagulation.
  3. Timing: Some laboratory data were not collected immediately after CRRT, potentially missing transient fluctuations in blood chemistry.

Future Work: The authors suggest that while RCA is the ideal choice for efficacy, Argatroban is a potent and safer alternative when RCA is contraindicated or when metabolic stability is the primary concern. Larger, prospective RCTs are needed to confirm these findings.

Summary updated

Abstract

<title>Abstract</title> The study was designed to evaluate the efficacy and safety of RCA versus low-dose argatroban in CRRT of critically ill patients with high risk of bleeding, so as to provide a theoretical basis for optimizing the anticoagulation mode of CRRT in critically ill patients with high risk of bleeding. 207 patients were divided into RCA group (n = 103) and Argatroban group (n = 104). After treatment, the prothrombin time, international standardized ratio, and activated partial thromboplastin time of Argatroban group were prolonged when compared with those of RCA group (P &lt; 0.05). Compared with Argatroban group, RCA group had significantly longer filter life span (42.1 (40.9, 46.5) h vs 41.2 (38.95, 43.2) h, P = 0.009). However, there was no significant difference between the two groups in 42-day all-cause mortality (51/103 vs 46/104, P &gt; 0.05). The cycles of filter clotting events (GRADE 0 and GRADE Ⅲ) had significant difference between the two groups(P &lt; 0.05). Compared with argatroban group, RCA group had slightly more bleeding complications (14/103 [13.59%] vs 8/104 [7.69%], P = 0.146). Although blood transfusion volume had no significant difference, the incidence of total adverse reactions in RCA group was significantly`higher than that in argatroban group (9.62% vs 19.42%, P = 0.045). The results showed that RCA treatment improves clinical outcome of patients at high risk of bleeding after CRRT, effectively prolongs the filter life and avoids filter clotting events. Argatroban has systemic anticoagulant effect, which has a certain impact on coagulation function, but it has better safety advantages.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{lan2024efficacy,
  author = {李兰 Li Lan and Lingling Gu and Yao Zhang and Zhiwei Zhuang and Yanxia Yu and Qian Zhang and Jinhui Xu and Xiaowen Xu and Lian Tang},
  title = {{Efficacy and Safety of Sodium Citrate and Argatroban in Continuous Renal Replacement Therapy of Patients with High Risk of Bleeding}},
  booktitle = {Research Square},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.21203/rs.3.rs-4575172/v1},
}
Figure