Abstract
間欠的空気圧迫装置(IPC)と弾力ストッキング(ES)の組み合わせによる下肢静脈血流への影響を明らかにするために,duplex scanを用いて下肢血流速度を測定した.健常成人例で,duplex scan上異常を認めない6例12肢を対象とした.IPCは加圧カフが足部と下腿部からなるVen Assist model VA-1000(ACI Medical, USA),ESはストッキングタイプのComprinet Pro(TERUMO・BNS, Hamburg)を使用した.IPCにより,大腿および大伏在静脈の最大流速は有意に増加したが(p<0.01),ES単独では血流の変化は明らかではなかった.IPCとES併用では大伏在静脈,総大腿静脈の加圧波の最大流速は低下傾向を示し,加速度は低値となった(p<0.05).以上の結果,IPCとESの併用により,下肢の血流速度に対する有意の相乗効果は認められなかったが,深部静脈血栓症予防効果の判定にはさらに多面的な検討が必要と考えられた.
Introduction
Deep Vein Thrombosis (DVT), often colloquially linked to "economy class syndrome," is a serious condition where blood clots form in the deep veins of the legs. If these clots travel to the lungs, they can cause life-threatening pulmonary embolisms. To prevent this, hospitals commonly use two mechanical methods: Elastic Stockings (ES), which provide constant pressure to prevent venous pooling, and Intermittent Pneumatic Compression (IPC), which uses inflatable sleeves to periodically pump the legs. In clinical practice, these are often used together under the assumption that combined compression improves prophylaxis. However, there is limited data on how these forces interact hemodynamically. This study aims to evaluate the real-time blood flow changes when both methods are used simultaneously.
Methods
The researchers conducted a physiological study on 6 healthy volunteers (12 limbs total). Duplex scanning (ultrasound) was used to measure blood flow in the common femoral vein and the great saphenous vein under four conditions: Control (resting), ES Only (Comprinet Pro), IPC Only (Ven Assist VA-1000 at 80mmHg), and Combined (IPC + ES). The team measured peak venous velocity ($V_p$), mean velocity, and the acceleration of the blood flow wave.
Results
IPC alone was highly effective at moving blood, increasing peak velocity in the common femoral vein from a baseline of ~24 cm/s to ~103 cm/s ($p < 0.01$). In contrast, ES alone had almost no significant impact on flow velocity in healthy, resting subjects. Most notably, the combined application of IPC and ES did not result in higher blood flow. In the common femoral vein, the peak velocity actually showed a downward trend, dropping to ~88 cm/s.
Discussion: The Acceleration Paradox
A key finding of this study is the reduction in blood flow acceleration when stockings are added to the pneumatic pump. Acceleration measures how quickly blood reaches its top speed during a pump cycle. A "snappier" increase in blood flow (higher acceleration) is thought to be more effective at scouring vein walls and preventing the stagnation that leads to clots.
In the common femoral vein, acceleration dropped significantly from 431.2 cm/s² with IPC alone to 272.6 cm/s² in the combined group ($p < 0.05$). The authors suggest this "anti-synergy" occurs because the stocking reduces venous pooling, leaving less blood volume available for the pneumatic pump to mobilize. Consequently, the combined treatment may be mechanically less effective at preventing stagnation than IPC alone.
Conclusion
While combining ES and IPC is a standard clinical approach, this study demonstrates that it does not provide a synergistic effect on blood flow velocity and significantly reduces flow acceleration. These findings suggest that the mechanical efficacy of combined prophylaxis warrants further investigation. Future research should explore whether these hemodynamic changes translate to clinical outcomes in patient populations with existing venous insufficiency or post-surgical risks.
Summary updated