Effects of Visual Perception of Building Materials on Human Emotional States and Cognitive Functioning in a Physical Learning Environment

Yufeng Zhou, Xiaochen Zhao, Y. T. Feng, Changzheng Xuan, C. T. Yang, Xiaohu JiaBuildings 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

This study explores how the visual perception of building materials (wood, red brick, concrete, white paint) in virtual learning environments impacts human emotional states and cognitive functions. The findings suggest that natural materials like wood and red brick promote relaxation and creativity, while minimalist materials like concrete and white paint enhance focus and emotional stability, offering crucial insights for designing effective learning spaces.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The physical environment of educational spaces significantly influences student learning outcomes, affecting everything from motivation to academic performance. While factors like spatial layout and lighting are well-studied, the specific impact of architectural materials on students' emotional and cognitive states remains underexplored. This research aims to bridge this gap by investigating how the visual characteristics of common building materials can shape psychological and physiological responses within a learning context.

Methods

The researchers employed a virtual reality (VR) simulation to create four distinct learning environments, each featuring one of four architectural materials: red brick, wood, concrete, and white paint. Forty-six participants experienced these environments while their physiological responses were monitored using multimodal techniques. This included:

  • Electroencephalography (EEG): To measure brain activity, specifically alpha and beta waves, and calculate the Frontal Asymmetry Activity Index (FAA) to assess emotional states.
  • Physiological Recorders: To capture skin conductance level (SCL), skin temperature (ST), heart rate (HR), and heart rate variability (HRV).
  • Eye Tracking: To record metrics like time to first fixation (TTFF) and pupil diameter (PD), reflecting visual attention and cognitive processing.

Participants also completed subjective questionnaires to report their emotional climate ratings (ECRV) and perceptions of material characteristics (MCV). Statistical analyses, including repeated-measures ANOVA, were used to compare the effects of the different material environments.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study generated its own experimental data through VR simulations and physiological measurements.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Material Dichotomy: A clear distinction emerged: natural/warm materials (wood, red brick) tend to foster positive emotions, relaxation, and creativity, while minimalist/cool materials (concrete, white paint) enhance focus, emotional stability, and rational thinking.
  • Beyond Aesthetics: The study moves beyond purely aesthetic considerations, demonstrating that material perception has measurable physiological and psychological consequences relevant to learning.
  • VR as a Tool: Virtual reality proved effective in simulating controlled environments and eliciting realistic emotional and cognitive responses, offering a powerful methodology for this type of research.
  • Subjective vs. Objective: The research highlights the interplay between subjective feelings and objective physiological responses, noting instances where physiological changes occurred without a corresponding conscious emotional report, suggesting a complex relationship.

Key Results

  • Emotional Enhancement: Wood and red brick environments significantly increased SCL and ST, indicating heightened emotional arousal. Wood environments showed the highest FAA (2.68 µV), suggesting strong positive emotional activation and relaxation.
  • Cognitive Boost: Concrete and white paint environments led to increased HR, HRV (SDNN), and HRV (RMSSD), indicative of enhanced alertness, attention, and concentration. Beta waves were also higher in concrete environments, suggesting high concentration.
  • Visual Attention: Red brick and wood environments, with their more intricate textures, led to longer fixation times (FT), suggesting they captured visual attention more effectively, though this could also imply a higher cognitive load.
  • Subjective Perceptions: Participants perceived red brick and wood as warm and textured, while concrete and white paint were seen as cold, smooth, and glossy. Red brick and wood were associated with positive emotions, while concrete and white paint evoked more stress.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Sample Demographics: The participant pool was primarily aged 21-26, limiting generalizability to broader age groups. Future research should include a wider age range and diverse cultural backgrounds.
  • Material Isolation: The study focused on single material variations. Future work should investigate the independent effects of specific visual characteristics (color, gloss, texture) and how their combinations and spatial arrangements influence outcomes.
  • VR Realism: While VR offers control, it may not fully replicate real-world complexities. Future studies could benefit from field research or long-term tracking to validate findings in actual environments.
  • Material Combinations: The study did not explore how combining materials might create more nuanced or balanced environments. Future research should investigate optimal material combinations for specific learning activities.

Summary updated

Abstract

The influence of building materials on the physical aspects of educational spaces is significant, shaping both functionality and aesthetic appeal while directly affecting the emotional and cognitive states of students. Despite its significance, this area has not been extensively explored. This study investigated the effects of the visual perception of architectural materials on emotional states and cognitive functions in learning environments. Four materials, namely, red brick, concrete, wood, and white paint, were selected for a material substitution experiment conducted via VR simulations with 46 participants. To assess these effects, eye movement data and bioelectrical responses were methodically recorded, along with the participants’ self-reported emotional states through structured questionnaires. The results indicated that settings featuring wood and red bricks significantly enhanced emotional states, fostering relaxation and positive experiences that contributed to increased creativity. Conversely, settings with concrete and white paint improved cognitive functioning and promoted emotional stability and rational thinking, which enhanced focus and educational efficiency. These findings suggest the impact of visual perception of building materials on emotional and cognitive states, emphasizing the importance of material selection in creating learning spaces that balance cognitive demands with emotional activation. This study provides valuable insights for designing conducive physical learning environments and exploring the psychological and physiological effects of architectural materials.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhou2025effects,
  author = {Yufeng Zhou and Xiaochen Zhao and Y. T. Feng and Changzheng Xuan and C. T. Yang and Xiaohu Jia},
  title = {{Effects of Visual Perception of Building Materials on Human Emotional States and Cognitive Functioning in a Physical Learning Environment}},
  booktitle = {Buildings},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.3390/buildings15071163},
}
Figure