Effects of Velocity-Based versus Percentage-Based Resistance Training on Explosive Neuromuscular Adaptations and Anaerobic Power in Sport-College Female Basketball Players

Mingyang Zhang, Duanying Li, Jiaxin He, Xingyue Liang, Dongyu Li, Wenfeng Song, Shicong Ding, Jie Shu, Sun Xiao-ning, Sun JianHealthcare 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigated whether velocity-based resistance training (VBRT) or traditional percentage-based resistance training (PBRT) is more effective for improving explosive power and anaerobic performance in female basketball players. VBRT showed superior gains in vertical jump power and peak power, while PBRT was more effective for sustained power output and total work.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Traditional resistance training (RT) programs are often prescribed based on a fixed percentage of an individual's one-repetition maximum (1RM). However, this "percentage-based resistance training" (PBRT) fails to account for daily fluctuations in an athlete's readiness due to factors like fatigue or stress. Velocity-based resistance training (VBRT) offers a more autoregulated approach, adjusting training intensity in real-time based on the speed of movement. While VBRT is gaining traction, there's a need for more direct comparisons between VBRT and PBRT, particularly concerning specific athletic performance metrics like explosive power and anaerobic capacity, which are crucial for sports like basketball. This paper aims to fill that gap by directly comparing these two training methodologies in a group of female basketball players.

Methods

The study employed a six-week resistance training intervention with 18 female basketball players randomly assigned to either a VBRT group (n=10) or a PBRT group (n=8). Both groups performed free-weight back squats twice a week, following a linear periodization model.

  • PBRT Group: Training loads were fixed based on pre-determined percentages of each participant's 1RM.
  • VBRT Group: Training loads were adjusted dynamically based on an individualized load-velocity profile (LVP). This involved using linear position transducers (LPTs) to measure the mean concentric velocity (MCV) of each repetition. If the MCV deviated from the target velocity zone (established from the LVP), the weight for subsequent sets was adjusted by 5-10% of the 1RM.

Key performance metrics were assessed at baseline and after the six-week intervention:

  • Wingate Anaerobic Power Test (WAnT): To measure peak power (PP), mean power (MP), and fatigue index (FI).
  • Jump and Sprint Testing: To assess relative peak power during a countermovement jump (RP-CMJ) and 30-meter sprint time (T-30m).
  • Body Composition: Measured using bioelectrical impedance analysis.

Datasets

Not applicable. This study involved a controlled experimental intervention with human participants.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Autoregulation Matters for Explosiveness: VBRT's ability to adjust loads based on real-time movement velocity appears to be particularly effective for enhancing explosive power, as evidenced by significant improvements in vertical jump performance (RP-CMJ) and peak power output.
  • PBRT's Strength in Endurance: While VBRT excels at explosive adaptations, PBRT demonstrated a greater capacity to improve sustained power output (mean power) and the ability to maintain power over time (total work) during anaerobic efforts.
  • Individualization is Key: The study highlights that different training methodologies may elicit different physiological adaptations. This suggests that the "best" approach might depend on the specific performance goals of the athlete.
  • Velocity as a Performance Indicator: The use of velocity feedback in VBRT not only guides training intensity but also appears to directly translate to improvements in movement speed and power, which are critical for basketball.

Key Results

  • VBRT Group: Showed very likely improvements in RP-CMJ (7.0%), maximal velocity (Vmax), peak power (PP), and fatigue index (FI).
  • PBRT Group: Showed very likely improvements in mean power (MP) and total work (TW).
  • Comparative Effects: VBRT demonstrated likely superior effects on RP-CMJ, PP, and Vmax compared to PBRT. Conversely, PBRT led to greater improvements in MP and TW.
  • Sprint Performance: No significant improvements were observed in 30-meter sprint times for either group, which the authors attribute to the lack of plyometric and specific sprint training within the intervention.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Sample Size and Demographics: The study involved a relatively small sample size (n=18) of female basketball players from a sport college. Future research with larger and more diverse populations would strengthen the findings.
  • Muscle Fiber Type: The study did not directly assess changes in muscle fiber type distribution, which could provide deeper insights into the mechanisms behind the observed adaptations.
  • Sprint Specificity: The lack of dedicated sprint training limits conclusions about the impact of VBRT/PBRT on sprint performance.
  • Future Directions: The authors suggest further research to explore the differences in force-velocity relationships between VBRT and PBRT, investigate long-term effects, and examine these training methods in different sports and populations. They also propose exploring the impact of varying velocity loss thresholds within VBRT.

Summary updated

Abstract

The purpose of this study was to compare the impact of velocity-based resistance training (VBRT) and percentage-based resistance training (PBRT) on anaerobic ability, sprint performance, and jumping ability. Eighteen female basketball players from a Sport College were randomly divided into two groups: VBRT (n = 10) and PBRT (n = 8). The six-week intervention consisted of two sessions per week of free-weight back squats with linear periodization from 65% to 95%1RM. In PBRT, the weights lifted were fixed based on 1RM percentage, while in VBRT, the weights were adjusted based on individualized velocity profiles. The T-30m sprint time, relative power of countermovement jump (RP-CMJ), and Wingate test were evaluated. The Wingate test assessed peak power (PP), mean power (MP), fatigue index (FI), maximal velocity (Vmax), and total work (TW). Results showed that VBRT produced a very likely improvement in RP-CMJ, Vmax, PP, and FI (Hedges' g = 0.55, 0.93, 0.68, 0.53, respectively, <i>p</i> < 0.01). On the other hand, PBRT produced a very likely improvement in MP (Hedges' g = 0.38) and TW (Hedges' g = 0.45). Although VBRT showed likely favorable effects in RP-CMJ, PP, and Vmax compared to PBRT (<i>p</i> < 0.05 for interaction effect), PBRT produced greater improvements in MP and TW (<i>p</i> < 0.05 for interaction effect). In conclusion, PBRT may be more effective in maintaining high-power velocity endurance, while VBRT has a greater impact on explosive power adaptations.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhang2023effects,
  author = {Mingyang Zhang and Duanying Li and Jiaxin He and Xingyue Liang and Dongyu Li and Wenfeng Song and Shicong Ding and Jie Shu and Sun Xiao-ning and Sun Jian},
  title = {{Effects of Velocity-Based versus Percentage-Based Resistance Training on Explosive Neuromuscular Adaptations and Anaerobic Power in Sport-College Female Basketball Players}},
  booktitle = {Healthcare},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3390/healthcare11040623},
}
Figure