Effects of the Talent War on Urban Innovation in China: A Difference-in-Differences Analysis

Xiaoli Shi, Ying Chen, Menghan Xia, Yongli ZhangLand 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

China's "talent war," a policy race among cities to attract skilled individuals, has demonstrably boosted urban innovation, particularly in the creation of invention patents. The most effective policies focus on employment and entrepreneurship subsidies, though a concerning "siphon effect" is observed, where these policies may hinder innovation in neighboring regions.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In recent years, Chinese cities have engaged in an intense competition, dubbed the "talent war," to attract high-quality talent. This competition is driven by the understanding that talent is a crucial engine for innovation and economic development. However, the actual impact of these aggressive talent attraction policies on urban innovation remains a subject of debate. This paper aims to empirically assess whether these "talent war" policies truly foster innovation, identify which specific subsidy types are most effective, and explore the broader regional implications, including potential negative spillovers.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-period difference-in-differences (DiD) model to analyze the causal impact of the "talent war" policy on urban innovation. This econometric approach is well-suited for evaluating policy interventions when the timing of implementation varies across different regions.

Here's how it works:

  • Treatment vs. Control Groups: Cities that implemented "talent war" policies were designated as the "treatment group," while those that did not were the "control group."
  • Pre- and Post-Policy Periods: Data was collected for years before and after the policy implementation.
  • Parallel Trends Assumption: A crucial step was to ensure that the treatment and control groups exhibited similar trends in innovation before the policy was introduced. This was tested and confirmed using an event study method (Figure 2).
  • Interaction Term: The core of the DiD model is an interaction term between a dummy variable for being in the treatment group and a dummy variable for being in the post-policy period. The coefficient of this term estimates the policy's causal effect.
  • Subsidy Analysis: To understand the impact of different subsidy types, the model was extended to include interaction terms between the "talent war" policy and specific subsidy categories (settlement support, employment/entrepreneurship, housing, living services).
  • Siphon Effect Analysis: A separate regression was run using a "neighboring city" dummy variable to assess if cities implementing the policy negatively impacted innovation in adjacent regions.
  • Heterogeneity Analysis: The study also examined how the policy's impact varied based on geographical location (coastal vs. inland), urban business environment (low vs. high government intervention), and intellectual property protection levels.

Datasets

The study utilized panel data for 277 prefecture-level cities in China spanning the period from 2010 to 2019.

  • Urban Innovation Data: Primarily sourced from the Chinese Research Data Services (CNRDS) database, measuring innovation by the number of patents obtained (total, invention, utility model, and design patents).
  • Talent Policy Data: Information on when cities introduced "talent war" policies was gathered from local government websites.
  • Control Variables Data: Data for various control variables (industrial structure, human capital, openness, education expenditure, etc.) were obtained from the China Urban Statistical Yearbook, the Economy Prediction System (EPS) data platform, and the China Economic Net statistical database.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • "Talent War" is a Real Driver: The study provides strong empirical evidence that the "talent war" policies are not just rhetoric; they actively stimulate urban innovation.
  • Invention Patents Matter Most: The policy's impact is most pronounced on invention patents, which represent substantive, high-level innovation, rather than utility models or design patents.
  • Subsidies are Key, But Not All Equal: While various subsidies contribute, employment and entrepreneurship subsidies show the strongest positive effect, followed closely by housing subsidies.
  • Innovation Willingness and Agglomeration are Mechanisms: The talent policies work by increasing cities' willingness to innovate and by attracting talent, which in turn fuels innovation.
  • The Dark Side: Siphon Effect: Cities actively competing for talent may be draining innovation potential from their neighbors, leading to regional labor market segmentation.
  • Context is Crucial: The effectiveness of the "talent war" is not uniform. Coastal cities, those with better business environments, and those with stronger intellectual property protection benefit more significantly from these policies, especially for substantive innovation.

Key Results

  • Overall Impact: The "talent war" policy significantly increased the total number of patents by approximately 16.49%. Specifically, invention patents saw a 31.28% increase.
  • Subsidy Effectiveness:
    • Employment and entrepreneurship subsidies had the largest impact, increasing total patents by 27.79% and invention patents by 39.38%.
  • Talent housing subsidies increased total patents by 25.43%.
  • Settlement support increased total patents by 21.26%.
  • Living service subsidies increased total patents by 20.82%.
  • Mechanism Impact: The "talent war" policy increased innovation willingness by 20.81% and talent agglomeration by 40.20%.
  • Siphon Effect: The interaction coefficient for total patents in neighboring cities was -0.087, indicating a negative impact, suggesting a "siphon effect" that inhibits local innovation.
  • Heterogeneity:
    • Coastal cities saw a 46.05% increase in substantive innovation (invention patents) due to the policy.
  • Cities with a low degree of government intervention (good business environment) saw a 37.22% increase in substantive innovation.
  • Cities with a high degree of intellectual property protection also showed a significant positive impact on urban innovation.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Siphon Effect Dominance: The study found a "siphon effect" on neighboring cities, indicating that the current "talent war" may be leading to regional imbalances rather than widespread innovation. Future work could explore policy designs that mitigate this negative externality.
  • Focus on Substantive Innovation: While invention patents are a good proxy, future research could delve deeper into other measures of substantive innovation.
  • Talent Retention: The paper suggests that while attracting talent is important, cultivating and retaining existing talent is also crucial. Further research could explore the effectiveness of retention-focused policies.
  • Business Environment and IP Protection: The study highlights the importance of a good business environment and strong IP protection for maximizing the impact of talent policies. Future work could investigate how to improve these aspects to better leverage talent attraction.
  • Policy Design Recommendations: The authors recommend encouraging more cities to adopt talent policies, prioritizing employment/entrepreneurship and housing subsidies, and focusing on talent retention. They also emphasize the need for governments to foster a competitive market for innovation resources and strengthen business environments.

Summary updated

Abstract

Talent is an important strategic resource for regional economic development. Based on the background of “the talent war” that has broken out between various cities in recent years, this study empirically verified the influence of the talent policy on urban innovation in 277 prefecture-level cities in China from 2010 to 2019 using the multi-period difference-in-differences model. The results indicated that “the talent war” caused by the talent policy has positively influenced urban innovation, causing, for instance, a dramatic increase in the number of patents for inventions. Among the subsidy methods of “the talent war” policy, the employment and entrepreneurship subsidy had the greatest incentive effect on urban innovation, followed by the talent housing subsidy. Moreover, the “the talent war” policy exerted a positive impact on urban innovation by improving the innovation willingness of cities and the level of talent gathering. At present, “the talent war” cities have, to a certain extent, restrained the improvement of urban innovation in neighboring cities because of the siphon effect, resulting in the division of the regional labor market. A heterogeneity analysis showed that “the talent war” has significantly promoted substantive innovation and the development of coastal cities with a better business environment and a higher degree of intellectual property protection.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{shi2022effects,
  author = {Xiaoli Shi and Ying Chen and Menghan Xia and Yongli Zhang},
  title = {{Effects of the Talent War on Urban Innovation in China: A Difference-in-Differences Analysis}},
  booktitle = {Land},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3390/land11091485},
}
Figure