Effects of the length ratio between the contractile element and the series elastic element on an explosive muscular performance

Akinori Nagano, Taku Komura, Senshi FukashiroJournal of Electromyography and Kinesiology 2003 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper investigates how the relative lengths of a muscle's contractile and elastic components affect explosive performance using a computer simulation. They found that for light loads, a longer series elastic element (tendon) is beneficial, while for heavy loads, a shorter one is optimal, suggesting a trade-off in muscle design for different tasks.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The human musculoskeletal system is incredibly complex, and understanding how its components interact to produce movement is a fundamental challenge in biomechanics. Muscles are often modeled as a "Hill-type" system, comprising a contractile element (CE) and a series elastic element (SEE), representing the muscle fibers and tendon, respectively. While the importance of fascicle length (related to CE) and tendon length (related to SEE) for muscle function is recognized, the ratio between the lengths of the CE and SEE, and its specific impact on explosive performance (like jumping), has not been thoroughly explored. This paper aims to fill this gap by quantitatively investigating how varying this length ratio influences the performance of a muscle-tendon complex during a stretch-shortening cycle, a key mechanism for generating powerful movements.

Methods

The researchers employed a computer simulation model of a Hill-type muscle-tendon complex. This model includes a contractile element (CE), a series elastic element (SEE), and a parallel elastic element (PEE). They used standard force-length and force-velocity relationships for the CE, a quadratic elastic property for the SEE, and a passive elastic force model for the PEE.

The core of their methodology involved systematically varying three key parameters:

  1. Length ratio of SEE to CE (Lslack/LCEopt): This was the primary variable, explored across a wide range (0.5 to 16.0).
  2. Mass factor: Representing the load on the muscle-tendon complex, ranging from 0.05 to 0.40 times the maximal isometric force of the CE.
  3. Initial length of the CE (LCE): Set at 60%, 100%, or 140% of its optimal length (LCEopt).

The simulation mimicked a stretch-shortening cycle: the muscle-tendon complex was initially held at a fixed length with the CE activated, causing the SEE to stretch. Then, the system was released, allowing the stored elastic energy to propel a mass upwards. The "gain in height" achieved by the mass was used as the primary metric for explosive performance. They also analyzed the work output of each element (CE, SEE, PEE).

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on a computer simulation model with parameter values derived from existing literature (specifically referencing Delp [8] for muscle tendon complex parameters and Hoy et al. [16] for human lower extremity data).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Load-dependent optimal SEE length: The most striking finding is that the ideal length of the series elastic element (tendon) for maximizing explosive performance depends heavily on the load. A longer tendon is better for light loads, while a shorter tendon is better for heavy loads. This suggests that muscles are not universally optimized for all tasks but rather adapted to specific functional demands.
  • Tendon as an energy reservoir: The study reinforces the idea that the SEE (tendon) acts as a crucial energy storage and release mechanism during stretch-shortening cycles. As the SEE length increases, its work output significantly increases, especially under lighter loads.
  • CE vs. SEE trade-off: There's a clear trade-off between the work output of the CE and the SEE. As the SEE gets longer (and thus more compliant/spring-like), the CE's work output tends to decrease, and vice-versa. The overall performance is a result of how these contributions combine.
  • Implications for muscle morphology: The findings offer a potential explanation for the observed variations in muscle and tendon lengths across different muscles in the human body. Muscles that typically handle heavier loads (e.g., hip/knee extensors) might benefit from shorter tendons, while those involved in lighter, faster movements (e.g., ankle muscles) might benefit from longer tendons.

Key Results

  • Gain in height: The achieved gain in height varied significantly, from 0 to 0.390 m.
  • Mass effect: Generally, smaller masses resulted in larger gains in height, and larger masses resulted in smaller gains.
  • SEE length and performance:
    • For small masses (mass factor = 0.05), a longer SEE (higher Lslack/LCEopt ratio) led to a greater gain in height. The maximum gain of 0.390 m was achieved with LCE = 1.4 × LCEopt and Lslack/LCEopt = 16.0.
  • For large masses (mass factor = 0.40), a shorter SEE (lower Lslack/LCEopt ratio) led to a greater gain in height.
  • CE length: A longer initial CE length generally resulted in a larger gain in height, suggesting that maximizing the CE's potential excursion is beneficial.
  • Work output:
    • The work output of the SEE generally increased with its length.
  • The work output of the CE and PEE generally decreased as the SEE length increased.
  • For light loads, the SEE's work output could be significantly larger than the CE's.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Simulation-based: The study is based on a computer simulation, and while it uses established models, it doesn't directly measure biological systems. The accuracy of the results depends on the fidelity of the model and the parameter values used.
  • Simplified model: The model simplifies complex biological interactions. For instance, it doesn't explicitly account for fatigue, neural control strategies beyond CE activation, or the complex interplay of multiple muscles in real-world movements.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that their findings align with observed morphological differences in human muscles and could be further investigated by comparing simulation results with experimental data from various muscle groups and activities. They also highlight the need to understand how these morphological characteristics contribute to work transfer and efficiency in more complex movements.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{nagano2003effects,
  author = {Akinori Nagano and Taku Komura and Senshi Fukashiro},
  title = {{Effects of the length ratio between the contractile element and the series elastic element on an explosive muscular performance}},
  journal = {Journal of Electromyography and Kinesiology},
  year = {2003},
  doi = {10.1016/s1050-6411(03)00085-3},
}
Figure