Abstract
Background: The German energy transition strategy calls for a reform of the German energy sector. As a result, the Germany Renewable Energy Sources Act (EEG) was passed in 2000 and is widely regarded as successful legislation for promoting bioenergy development. More than 1,000 biogas plants were constructed in Central Germany (CG) between 2000 and 2014. Despite this, few studies have been conducted for this period that systematically investigate how environmental, social and economic factors, as well as various EEG amendments have impacted biogas production and what the environmental consequence of biogas production development in CG have been. Methods: The impacts of environmental, social and economic factors and different EEG amendments on biogas production decisions in CG were quantified using multivariate linear regression model and the event study econometric technique. A GIS-based spatial analysis was also conducted to provide insight into the changes to agricultural land use that resulted from the development of biogas plants during the EEG period. Results: The main finding was that the income diversification effect resulting from biogas production was the most important factor in a farmer’s decision to adopt biogas production. In addition, all of the EEG amendments had a significant influence on the adoption of biogas production, however EEG III and IV, which tried to promote small-scale plants, were unable to reduce the average size of the plants constructed in these two amendment periods. From a landscape perspective, there was a striking increase in the cultivation of silage maize in CG from 2000 to 2014. Silage maize was intensively cultivated in regions with a high installed biogas plant capacity. Since the first EEG amendment, permanent grassland area slightly increased while arable land area declined in CG. Conclusions: The adoption of biogas production in CG was strongly driven by economic incentives for the farmers, more precisely, by the incentive to diversify their income sources. In addition to increase the subsidy, future EEG amendments should find new measures to encourage the adoption of small-scale biogas plants, which had been unsuccessful in EEG amendments III and IV.
Introduction
Germany’s Energiewende (energy transition) relies heavily on the Renewable Energy Sources Act (EEG) to pivot away from fossil fuels. Since its inception in 2000, the act has undergone several amendments to fine-tune subsidies and address environmental concerns. However, there is a lack of systematic research on how these specific policy shifts—intertwined with local social, economic, and environmental factors—actually influenced a farmer's decision to adopt biogas technology.
This study addresses two primary questions: What drives a farmer to build a biogas plant (environmental, economic, or political factors?), and how has this massive shift toward bioenergy reshaped agricultural land use in Central Germany?
Methods
The research employed a dual-track approach to quantify policy impacts and spatial changes.
- Econometric Event Study: A multivariate linear regression combined with an "event study" technique was used. This allowed each EEG amendment (2004, 2009, 2012) to be treated as a specific "event" to quantify its individual impact on plant adoption and size while controlling for other variables.
- GIS-Based Spatial Analysis: Using ArcGIS, biogas production density was mapped across 50 counties. Kernel Density estimation categorized regions into three "impact zones" (Low, Medium, and High density). This spatial data was then overlaid with land-use maps to track changes in crop patterns over 15 years.
The study utilized a comprehensive county-level panel dataset (2000–2014) for Saxony, Saxony-Anhalt, and Thuringia, incorporating data from the UFZ EE-Monitor and regional statistics.
Results and Discussion
The analysis revealed that the EEG successfully transformed Central Germany into a biogas powerhouse, though the drivers were primarily economic.
Biogas as an Economic Hedge
The single most important factor in adopting biogas was income diversification. Farmers view biogas plants as an alternative investment providing stable, guaranteed income, especially when traditional agricultural commodity prices are volatile.
Policy Shifts and the "Small-Scale" Challenge
Despite EEG amendments (III and IV) specifically designed to incentivize smaller, manure-based plants to reduce environmental footprints, the average size of newly constructed plants did not decrease. The "maize cap" and small-scale subsidies were largely offset by existing economies of scale. EEG III (2009) had the strongest influence, resulting in an average of 1.99 more biogas plants per county compared to the initial period.
Landscape "Maizification"
There is a direct spatial correlation between biogas density and the expansion of silage maize. In high-density zones, maize cultivation increased by nearly 60% compared to the pre-EEG era. From 1995 to 2014, silage maize and rapeseed areas increased by 57.85% and 76.49%, respectively, while traditional crops like rye declined. Interestingly, Central Germany saw a slight 0.1% increase in permanent grassland, likely due to synergies between livestock farming and biogas production supported by EU "greening" obligations.
Conclusions
The adoption of biogas production in Central Germany was strongly driven by economic incentives for income diversification. While the EEG successfully promoted bioenergy development, it also led to significant landscape changes, notably the intensive cultivation of silage maize. Future policy amendments should seek more effective measures to encourage small-scale biogas plants and mitigate the environmental impacts of monoculture expansion. Future research using farm-level data would provide deeper insights into individual decision-making processes.
Summary updated