Effects of Sucrose, Trehalose, and Fructose on Whole Ovarian Cryopreservation in a Rat Model

Lingyun Xie, Yan Ding, Ping Xu, Keqin Hua, Xuyin ZhangClinical 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This study identifies trehalose as the superior non-permeable cryoprotectant for whole-ovary cryopreservation in a rat model. While both sucrose and trehalose effectively maintain the physical structure of the ovary during deep-freezing, trehalose significantly outperforms sucrose and fructose in preventing programmed cell death (apoptosis), making it a prime candidate for future fertility preservation techniques.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

For young women undergoing aggressive chemotherapy or radiotherapy, ovarian failure and infertility are devastating side effects. While freezing "strips" of ovarian tissue (cortical transplantation) is currently practiced, it has limitations: many eggs are lost during the process, and it takes time for blood vessels to regrow after transplantation, leading to further tissue death.

The "holy grail" of fertility preservation is Whole Ovary Cryopreservation and Transplantation (WOCP&TP). By freezing the entire organ with its vascular pedicle intact, surgeons can theoretically reconnect the blood supply immediately upon thawing. However, the technical hurdle is massive. You must get cryoprotective agents (CPAs) deep into the organ's complex architecture to prevent ice crystals from shredding the cells, all while minimizing the chemical toxicity of those same agents. This paper compares three different sugars—sucrose, trehalose, and fructose—to see which best protects the delicate ovarian microenvironment during this process.

Methods

The researchers used 20 adult Lewis female rats, dividing their intact ovaries into four experimental groups: a non-frozen control, and three groups treated with a combination of DMSO (a permeable CPA) and one of three sugars (sucrose, trehalose, or fructose).

Key technical aspects included:

  • Vascular Perfusion: Instead of just soaking the tissue, the team used a specialized perfusion device to pump the CPA solution directly through the ovary’s blood vessels, ensuring even distribution.
  • Stepped Exposure: To minimize osmotic shock, the concentration of CPAs was increased linearly over 20 minutes.
  • Slow Freezing: Ovaries were cooled gradually to –120 °C before being plunged into liquid nitrogen.
  • Multi-Level Analysis: The team didn't just look at whether the ovary "looked" okay. They used light microscopy for follicle counts, electron microscopy to check the health of mitochondria and membranes (ultrastructure), and molecular assays (BAX and TUNEL) to detect early signs of cellular "suicide" (apoptosis).

Datasets

As an experimental biological study, the "dataset" consists of the primary data collected from the 20 rats (5 ovaries per group). The study provides quantitative benchmarks for:

  • Follicle Counts: Categorized by stage (primordial, primary, secondary, and antral).
  • Stromal Cell Density: Measuring the health of the supporting tissue.
  • Apoptotic Percentages: Quantitative results from BAX and TUNEL staining.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Disaccharides > Monosaccharides: While some previous research suggested fructose (a monosaccharide) might be effective, this study found it was significantly worse at preserving ovarian histology and ultrastructure compared to the larger sugar molecules.
  • The Trehalose Advantage: Trehalose is a "non-reducing" sugar known for stabilizing membranes and proteins under extreme stress. The study found that while sucrose and trehalose were equally good at preserving the shape of the follicles, trehalose was much better at keeping the cells alive at a molecular level.
  • Apoptosis is the Silent Killer: Even when a follicle looks normal under a standard microscope, it might already be on a path to death. The use of BAX and TUNEL assays revealed that sucrose-treated ovaries had significantly higher rates of programmed cell death than those treated with trehalose.

Key Results

  • Follicle Survival: The total follicle count in the trehalose group (~119.6) and sucrose group (~118.2) were statistically similar, though both were lower than the fresh control (~151.4). The fructose group lagged behind at ~100.4.
  • Apoptosis Reduction: This was the clincher. The percentage of TUNEL-positive (apoptotic) cells in the trehalose group was significantly lower than in the sucrose group (p < 0.01).
  • Ultrastructure: Electron microscopy showed that trehalose-treated ovaries maintained better mitochondrial integrity and clearer nuclear membranes compared to the fructose group, which showed significant "vacuolization" (bubble-like holes in the cell) and mitochondrial swelling.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge a few key hurdles before this hits the clinic:

  • No "Vitrification" Comparison: This study focused on slow freezing. Vitrification (ultra-rapid freezing into a glass-like state) is another popular method that wasn't compared here.
  • Lack of Functional Data: While the cells looked healthy, the study did not perform actual transplants to see if the ovaries could still produce hormones or successful pregnancies.
  • The Scale Problem: A rat ovary is tiny. Scaling vascular perfusion and uniform freezing to the size of a human ovary presents significantly more complex fluid dynamics and thermal challenges.

Future research will likely focus on "living" tests—transplanting these trehalose-preserved ovaries back into models to confirm long-term endocrine and reproductive function.

Summary updated

Abstract

Background: Recently, the utilization of sugar as a cryoprotectant has garnered significant attention. Sucrose and trehalose, as non-permeable cryoprotectants, can effectively regulate the osmotic pressure inside and outside cells while maintaining cell membrane stability during cryopreservation. Furthermore, it has been observed that monosaccharides sugars, particularly fructose, exhibit superior efficacy in preserving the quality of frozen substances as compared to disaccharides and trisaccharides sugars. Nevertheless, there is currently limited research assessing the cryopreservation effects of sucrose, trehalose, and fructose. The objective of this experiment is to identify the best cryoprotectant between sucrose, trehalose, and fructose for intact rat ovaries. Methods: Intact ovaries with blood vessels were obtained from 20 adult Lewis female rats and divided accordingly into four groups: control (non-vitrified), sucrose, fructose, and trehalose. The ovarian samples were subjected to a stepped cryoprotectant exposure and subsequently follicular histological analysis using light and electron microscopy. Ovarian cell apoptosis was evaluated by BCL2-Associated X (BAX) immunohistochemistry and Terminal Deoxynucleotidyl Transferase-Mediated Deoxyuridine Triphosphate nick End-Labeling (TUNEL) analyses. Results: The sucrose and the trehalose groups preserved the ovarian histological structure better than the fructose group. Additionally, there was no statistical difference in the total follicle number between the sucrose and trehalose groups, but the percentage of apoptotic cells in the trehalose group was significantly lower than that of the sucrose group (p &lt; 0.01). Conclusions: Sucrose and trehalose perfusion protocols preserved the ovarian histology. However, the least apoptotic changes were observed in the trehalose group. The study suggested that trehalose would be a well-applied cryoprotectant in the cryopreservation of intact rat ovaries.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{xie2024effects,
  author = {Lingyun Xie and Yan Ding and Ping Xu and Keqin Hua and Xuyin Zhang},
  title = {{Effects of Sucrose, Trehalose, and Fructose on Whole Ovarian Cryopreservation in a Rat Model}},
  booktitle = {Clinical},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.31083/j.ceog5104090},
}
Figure