Effects of Subsurface Pipe Drainage Spacing on Soil Salinity Movement in Jiangsu Coastal Reclamation Area

Danni Han, Chao Chen, Fan Wang, Wenping Li, Hao Peng, Qiu Jin, Bo Bi, Hiba Shaghaleh, Yousef Alhaj HamoudSustainability 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates how the spacing of subsurface drainage pipes affects soil salinity in Jiangsu's coastal reclamation areas. They found that closer pipe spacing (6m) significantly reduces soil salinity, especially in the upper soil layers, and leads to higher crop yields compared to wider spacing or no drainage. The research recommends a 6m pipe spacing and a 40cm outlet burial depth for effective salt control.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Coastal reclamation areas, particularly in Jiangsu Province, face significant challenges for agricultural development due to high soil salinity and inadequate irrigation and drainage infrastructure. This salinity hinders crop growth and limits the potential of these lands for food production. While subsurface drainage is a known solution, optimizing its design parameters, specifically the spacing of drainage pipes, is crucial for maximizing its effectiveness in reducing soil salinity and improving agricultural productivity. This paper aims to provide data-driven recommendations for optimal subsurface drainage layout in such environments.

Methods

The study employed a field experiment with 12 different treatments. These treatments involved four subsurface drainage pipe spacings (6m, 11m, 15m, and a control with no subsurface drainage) and three observation well distances from the drainage outlet (5m, 25m, 45m). Soil salinity was monitored using sensors at various depths (0-20 cm, 20-40 cm, 40-60 cm, and 60-80 cm) over several months. The experiment also included irrigation leaching and crop yield measurements (using Sesbania, a salt-tolerant plant) to assess the overall impact of the drainage systems. Statistical analysis, including ANOVA, was used to evaluate the significance of the findings.

Datasets

The study utilized field data collected from an experimental site in Jianggang Town, Dongtai City, Jiangsu Province. This data included:

  • Soil salinity measurements: Recorded by sensors at multiple depths and locations over time.
  • Precipitation data: Monthly precipitation records for the study area.
  • Crop yield data: Measured for Sesbania planted across different experimental zones.
  • Basic soil parameters: Including water content, bulk density, electrical conductivity, total salt content, organic matter, and mechanical composition.
  • Initial salt ion content: Measured for different soil depths.

No new benchmark datasets were introduced; the study relies on in-situ data collection.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Spacing is Key: The most impactful finding is that reducing subsurface drainage pipe spacing directly correlates with improved salt reduction. This suggests that a denser network is more efficient at managing soil salinity.
  • Depth Matters for Salt Movement: While closer spacing and shallower outlet depths (40cm) are effective for surface salt reduction, they can lead to increased salt accumulation in deeper soil layers (60-80 cm). This highlights a trade-off that needs careful consideration.
  • Distance from Drain is Critical: Soil salinity consistently increases with the distance from the drainage outlet. This emphasizes the importance of uniform drainage coverage.
  • Crop Yield Response: Subsurface drainage significantly boosts crop yield compared to natural drainage, but the differences in yield between various drainage spacings were not statistically significant in this study, despite a trend towards higher yields with closer spacing.

Key Results

  • All subsurface pipe spacing treatments significantly reduced soil salinity compared to the control (no drainage).
  • A smaller pipe spacing (6m) resulted in better salt-reducing effects than wider spacings (11m, 15m).
  • Soil salinity increased with greater distance from the drainage outlet.
  • The 0-60 cm soil layer showed higher salinization rates with decreased outlet burial depth and decreased pipe spacing, while the 60-80 cm layer experienced more severe salt accumulation.
  • The recommended optimal design parameters are a subsurface drainage pipe spacing of 6 m and an outlet burial depth of 40 cm for effective salt control.
  • Crop yields in the experimental areas with subsurface drainage were significantly higher (over 10%) than the control group.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Construction Cost: The paper acknowledges that future research should consider construction costs when determining appropriate buried depths for subsurface drainage pipes.
  • Nutrient Loss: While rapid drainage is beneficial for salt removal, it can also lead to nutrient loss. The paper briefly mentions the need for controlled drainage systems to manage nutrient loss, suggesting this as an area for further investigation.
  • Generalizability: The study was conducted in a specific coastal reclamation area in Jiangsu. While the findings provide valuable insights, further research may be needed to confirm their applicability to other saline-alkali land types and geographical regions.
  • Yield Differences: The lack of statistically significant differences in crop yield between various drainage spacings, despite trends, suggests that other factors might be influencing yield, or that the differences were too small to be detected with the current experimental setup. Further investigation into the yield response across a wider range of spacings or under different crop types could be beneficial.

Summary updated

Abstract

The agricultural development of reclaimed coastal areas in Jiangsu Province is significantly hindered by high soil salinity and an inadequate irrigation and drainage infrastructure. Optimizing the layout of subsurface drainage systems has been identified as an effective means of reducing soil salinity, with the proper designation of engineering parameters being crucial. This study applied 12 treatments (T1–T12) consisting of four different spacings of subsurface drainage pipes (6 m, 11 m, 15 m, and no subsurface drainage pipes) and three observation wells at varying distances from the drainage outlet (5 m, 25 m, and 45 m). Results showed that all three subsurface pipe spacing treatments significantly reduced soil salinity compared to natural drainage, with a smaller subsurface pipe spacing treatment leading to better salt-reducing effects. The farther the distance from the measuring point to the drain, the higher the salinity. As the burial depth of the outlet decreased and spacing between the subsurface drainage pipes decreased, the salinization rate of the 0–60 cm soil layer was higher, while the salt accumulation in the 60–80 cm soil layer was more severe. Therefore, a subsurface drainage pipe spacing of 6 m and an outlet burial depth of 40 cm are recommended as more suitable choices to effectively control salt concentration in the soil. The research aimed to provide scientific reference data and technical support for the optimized design of subsurface drainage engineering parameters while promoting efficient desalination of saline-alkali areas worldwide.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{han2023effects,
  author = {Danni Han and Chao Chen and Fan Wang and Wenping Li and Hao Peng and Qiu Jin and Bo Bi and Hiba Shaghaleh and Yousef Alhaj Hamoud},
  title = {{Effects of Subsurface Pipe Drainage Spacing on Soil Salinity Movement in Jiangsu Coastal Reclamation Area}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3390/su151813932},
}
Figure