TL;DR
This study investigates how lexical stress and speech rate affect vowel sounds in Spanish and Catalan. Researchers found that while both languages show vowel centralization (making sounds "mushier") under faster speech, Spanish vowels are more affected by stress, becoming more open and posterior when unstressed, suggesting a more complex relationship than just duration.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
The paper tackles the question of how stress and speech rate influence the acoustic properties of vowels, specifically vowel quality, in two Romance languages: Iberian Spanish and Central Catalan. While it's generally understood that stress can lead to "vowel reduction" (making vowels less distinct), the exact mechanisms and cross-linguistic variations are not fully clear. Some theories, like the Hyperarticulation Hypothesis (HH), suggest stressed vowels are produced with more distinct articulatory gestures, leading to more peripheral acoustic qualities. Conversely, the Sonority Expansion Hypothesis (SEH) posits that stress increases sonority, requiring a more open vocal tract. This study aims to test these hypotheses by examining how stress and speech rate interact to affect vowel formants (F1 and F2, which relate to vowel height and backness, respectively) in Spanish and Catalan, noting that Catalan has a more drastic phonological vowel reduction system than Spanish.
Methods
The researchers recorded 3 native speakers of Iberian Spanish and 3 native speakers of Central Catalan. Participants read disyllabic words embedded in a carrier phrase, twice under two conditions: normal speech rate and fast speech rate. For Spanish, words were designed to have stress on either the first or second syllable. For Catalan, the focus was on the contrast between stressed and unstressed vowels, with a specific set of vowels appearing in unstressed positions.
Acoustic analysis involved manually segmenting vowels and extracting their first two formants (F1 and F2) using the Praat software. To account for speaker-specific variations, the formant values were z-normalized. The core of the analysis employed linear mixed-effects regression models to examine the effects of stress, speech rate, and their interactions on F1 and F2. ANOVA was used to assess the significance of these effects.
Datasets
The study utilized a newly recorded dataset of spoken Spanish and Catalan. The Spanish materials consisted of disyllabic words of the form pVpe, allowing for the manipulation of stress placement. The Catalan materials used words of the form pVpet, with a specific set of vowels appearing in stressed and unstressed positions. A total of 100 vowels were analyzed per speaker, after discarding some tokens due to errors or disfluencies.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Vowel Space Shrinks with Faster Speech: Both Spanish and Catalan speakers exhibit a "shrunken vowel space" when speaking faster. This means vowels become more centralized and less distinct acoustically, moving towards the center of the vowel chart.
- Stress's Complex Role in Spanish: Unlike Catalan, where stress primarily affects vowel quality through centralization (similar to fast speech), Spanish vowels show a more nuanced response to stress. Unstressed Spanish vowels tend to have lower F1 (meaning a higher tongue position) and are more posterior (lower F2) compared to stressed vowels. This suggests that stress in Spanish might involve more than just articulatory economy due to duration.
- Sonority Expansion Hypothesis Supported in Spanish: The finding that Spanish vowels become more open (higher F1) when stressed aligns with the Sonority Expansion Hypothesis, which suggests stressed vowels require a more open vocal tract to increase sonority.
- Catalan's Centralization: In Catalan, unstressed vowels, particularly /i/, become more centralized (higher F1 and lower F2) compared to their stressed counterparts, supporting the Hyperarticulation Hypothesis's prediction of peripheral stressed vowels.
- Duration vs. Stress: The study suggests that while duration plays a role in vowel reduction (as seen with faster speech), the effects of stress on vowel quality in Spanish are not solely attributable to differences in vowel duration.
Key Results
- Speech Rate: For both Spanish and Catalan, faster speech rate consistently led to a more centralized vowel space.
- Spanish Stress: Stressed Spanish vowels generally had higher F1 (more open) than unstressed vowels, except for /u/. For /a/ and /o/, unstressed vowels also had lower F2 (more posterior).
- Catalan Stress: Unstressed Catalan vowel /i/ was significantly more centralized (higher F1, lower F2) than stressed /i/. Vowel /u/ did not show significant differences in F1 or F2 between stressed and unstressed positions.
- Formant Differences: Across both languages, speech rate significantly affected F2 for all vowels, indicating changes in backness. F1 was also affected, but less consistently across all vowels.
Limitations and Future Work
The authors acknowledge that the study is based on a small number of speakers and that further research is needed to confirm findings, particularly regarding the insensitivity of Catalan /u/ to stress. They also suggest that more investigation is required to fully understand the distinct strategies Spanish and Catalan speakers employ to signal stress. Future work could explore a wider range of phonetic contexts and a larger speaker pool to solidify these preliminary findings.
Summary updated