Effects of Social Robotics in Promoting Physical Activity in the Shared Workspace

Xipei Ren, Zhifan Guo, Aobo Huang, Yuying Li, Xinyi Xu, Xiaoyu ZhangSustainability 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces the "Anti-Sedentary Robot," a social robot designed to combat prolonged sitting in shared workspaces by initiating voluntary "item return" tasks that incorporate light physical exercises. A study found that the robot-guided intervention led to higher intrinsic motivation and acute mental benefits compared to a human-guided approach, suggesting social robots can effectively promote office vitality.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The modern knowledge-based economy, with its emphasis on flexible work and shared workspaces, has inadvertently led to increased sedentary lifestyles among workers. This prolonged sitting poses significant risks to both physical and psychological well-being. Existing challenges in promoting physical activity in these environments include spatial limitations that hinder exercise and social norms that discourage breaks. While social elements in human-computer interaction (HCI) have shown promise, there's a need to explore how social robotics can specifically address sedentary behavior and encourage physical activity in shared office settings.

Methods

The researchers developed a "Wizard-of-Oz" prototype of the Anti-Sedentary Robot. This approach allowed for rapid testing of the design concept without full technical implementation. The robot, a trolley-like device, was designed to:

  1. Detect Sedentary Workers: Using smart seat cushions with pressure sensors and location marks to monitor sitting duration.
  2. Initiate Voluntary Tasks: Navigate to a sedentary worker and invite them to participate in a "voluntary item return" task (e.g., returning books, cups).
  3. Provide Exercise Guidance: Accompany the user during the task and offer light-intensity exercise guidance (e.g., stretching, squats) via its interface.

A within-subject study was conducted with 18 university students in a library setting. Participants experienced two conditions:

  • Robot-Guided Intervention (RGI): The Anti-Sedentary Robot facilitated the item return and exercise.
  • Human-Guided Intervention (HGI): A colleague facilitated the same task and exercises.

The study measured intrinsic motivation (using the Intrinsic Motivation Inventory - IMI) and psychological benefits (using the Self-Assessment Manikin - SAM and mental arithmetic tests) before and after each intervention. Qualitative data was collected through semi-structured interviews.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Reciprocity as a Motivator: The core idea of a reciprocal task (returning an item for the robot) combined with exercise guidance appears to be a powerful motivator, fostering a sense of mutual benefit.
  • Social Robot as a "Pleasant Interrupter": The robot's role as an initiator of breaks, framed as a helpful service rather than a direct command, seems to reduce the social awkwardness often associated with taking breaks in shared workspaces.
  • Intrinsic Motivation Boost: The RGI condition significantly enhanced enjoyment and perceived choice in physical activity, suggesting that the robot's presence and interaction style are key to fostering intrinsic motivation.
  • Reduced "Effort" Perception: Participants perceived the robot-guided intervention as less demanding, which could lower the barrier to entry for physical activity.
  • Acute Mental Benefits: The RGI led to a significant improvement in test completion time for mental arithmetic tasks, indicating a positive impact on cognitive function after the intervention.

Key Results

Quantitative Findings: * Intrinsic Motivation: Participants rated "interest/enjoyment" significantly higher in the RGI (M=5.25) than HGI (M=4.80). "Perceived choice" was also significantly higher in RGI (M=5.18) than HGI (M=4.47). * Effort/Importance: The HGI was perceived as significantly more demanding (M=3.52) than the RGI (M=2.83). * Affective State (SAM): Pleasure increased significantly after both interventions. Arousal showed a greater increase for the RGI. However, no significant differences were found in the improvement of pleasure, arousal, or dominance between RGI and HGI. * Arithmetic Tests: Correction rate showed slight improvement after RGI but no significant difference between conditions. Test completion time significantly improved after RGI (Z=2.22, p<0.05), but not significantly after HGI.

Qualitative Findings: * Preference for RGI: A majority of participants (15/18) preferred the robot-guided intervention. * Psychological Benefits: Participants found the robot "interesting" and novel, and wished for long-term use. * Motivation Maintenance: The robot was seen as a considerate reminder to stand up and relax, helping maintain motivation for a healthier lifestyle. * Reduced Embarrassment: The robot's presence helped participants avoid feeling self-conscious about exercising in a public space, as others might assume they are simply returning an item. * Reciprocal Relationship: Participants felt they were building a reciprocal relationship with the robot and contributing to the shared environment by returning items.

Limitations and Future Work

Limitations: * Small Sample Size: The study involved only 18 participants, limiting generalizability. * Short Study Period: The interventions were brief, making it difficult to assess long-term effects. * Wizard-of-Oz Prototype: The robot was not fully implemented, meaning the study tested a simulated experience. * Specific Setup: The study was conducted in a controlled library environment, which may not reflect diverse co-working settings.

Future Work: * Longitudinal Studies: Conduct studies over longer periods to assess sustained behavioral changes. * Real-World Deployment: Implement the design in actual everyday work routines in shared workspaces. * Technical Advancement: Focus on fully implementing the technical feasibility of the Anti-Sedentary Robot. * Diverse User Groups: Include a wider range of users and shared workspace types. * Enhanced HRI: Explore more playful interactions, game-like elements, and clearer exercise guidance. * Incentive Systems: Investigate mechanisms like accumulating bonus points or integrating with workplace services to strengthen reciprocity and user engagement.

Summary updated

Abstract

This paper presents a design study exploring the effects of a social robot in facilitating people to participate in light-intensity exercises after a long duration of sitting in a shared workspace. A smart system based on a trolley-like robot, called the Anti-Sedentary Robot, was developed to realize the health intervention as follows. To start, the robot could navigate to the location of a sedentary worker to invite them to participate in a temporal voluntary service of returning items. Upon the invitation being accepted, the robot would then move with the worker to return the item and simultaneously provide guidance for physical exercises. Based on the Anti-Sedentary Robot, a within-subject study (n = 18) was carried out to examine exercise motivations and psychological benefits of our design by making comparisons between a robot-guided intervention and a human-guided intervention. Quantitative results showed that the health intervention based on the Anti-Sedentary Robot increased intrinsic motivations and provided acute mental benefits compared to the human-guided intervention. Qualitative findings suggested that the Anti-sedentary Robot could combat work-related sedentary behaviors due to the pleasant system interactivity and the provision of reciprocal voluntary tasks. We discuss implications for the future development of social robots for office vitality based on our research findings.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{ren2022effects,
  author = {Xipei Ren and Zhifan Guo and Aobo Huang and Yuying Li and Xinyi Xu and Xiaoyu Zhang},
  title = {{Effects of Social Robotics in Promoting Physical Activity in the Shared Workspace}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3390/su14074006},
}
Figure