Effects of Sizing Agents and Resin-Formulated Matrices with Varying Stiffness–Toughness Ratios on the Properties of Carbon Fiber Epoxy Resin Composites

Pengfei Song, Qin Fang, Wen Liu, Xinyue Ma, Qingchao Li, Mehraj‐ud‐din Naik, Mudasir Ahmad, Guoqing Huang, Chuncai YangPolymers 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates how different epoxy resin formulations and surface sizing agents affect the mechanical properties of carbon fiber-reinforced polymer (CFRP) composites. By optimizing the blend of a high-performance epoxy (AG-80) with a low-cost epoxy (E-1NT) and employing specific sizing agents, researchers achieved significant improvements in interlaminar shear strength (ILSS) and compressive strength, identifying a promising formulation for advanced composite applications.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Carbon fiber-reinforced polymers (CFRPs) are highly sought after for their exceptional strength-to-weight ratio, making them ideal for aerospace, automotive, and energy sectors. However, their performance hinges critically on the interface between the carbon fibers and the epoxy resin matrix. This interface is influenced by both the inherent properties of the resin (like stiffness and toughness) and the surface treatment of the carbon fibers (sizing agents). Existing research has explored these factors individually, but a comprehensive understanding of their synergistic effects on key mechanical properties like interlaminar shear strength (ILSS) and compressive strength, particularly when balancing stiffness and toughness in the resin matrix, remains an area needing further investigation. This paper aims to bridge this gap by systematically evaluating various combinations of resin formulations and sizing agents to optimize CFRP performance.

Methods

The researchers employed a systematic experimental approach to evaluate the effects of resin formulation and sizing agents on CFRP properties.

  • Resin Formulation: Three epoxy resins were used: AG-80 (high-performance, good wetting), E-1NT (low-cost, low viscosity, poor mechanicals), and EPN (novolac epoxy). AG-80 and E-1NT were mixed in various mass ratios to create formulated resin matrices with varying stiffness-toughness characteristics. The curing agent used for all epoxy formulations was DDS (4,4′-diaminodiphenyl sulfone).
  • Sizing Agents: Three types of ionic sizing agents were investigated: cationic (S1), non-ionic (S2), and anionic (S3). These were used to treat the carbon fibers.
  • Composite Preparation: Unidirectional carbon fiber/epoxy (CF/EP) composite specimens were prepared using a two-stage curing process (135°C followed by 180°C) to ensure proper fiber wetting and matrix penetration. The carbon fiber volume fraction was maintained at approximately 65%.
  • Mechanical Testing:
    • Interlaminar Shear Strength (ILSS): Tested using a universal testing machine (AGS-X10KN) according to GB/T 30969-2014.
  • Compressive Strength: Tested using a universal testing machine (Instron-5869) according to GB/T 5258-2008.
  • Microstructural Analysis: Scanning Electron Microscopy (SEM) was used to examine the fracture surfaces of the composites, providing insights into interfacial adhesion and failure mechanisms.
  • Viscosity Measurement: The viscosity of the formulated epoxy resins was measured over time at 135°C to understand their processing behavior and gel times.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on experimental data generated from prepared composite specimens.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Synergistic Effect of Resin Blending: Mixing AG-80 and E-1NT epoxy resins proved to be more effective than using either alone. The optimal blend (60% AG-80/40% E-1NT) achieved a superior balance of properties.
  • Cationic Sizing Agent Dominance: The cationic sizing agent (S1) consistently led to higher ILSS and compressive strength across different resin formulations. This is attributed to its tertiary amino groups forming strong positive-negative charge interactions with the carboxyl groups on the carbon fiber surface, enhancing interfacial adhesion.
  • Viscosity and Gel Time Matter for Processing: The viscosity and gel time of the resin matrix are crucial for effective fiber wetting and impregnation. Lower viscosity during the initial curing stage (135°C) facilitated better penetration, as observed with the AG-80/E-1NT mixtures.
  • Crosslinking Density Influence: The crosslinking density of the resin matrix, influenced by the AG-80 content, directly impacts compressive strength. Higher AG-80 content generally increased crosslinking density and compressive strength up to an optimal point.
  • Fracture Mode as an Indicator: SEM analysis revealed distinct fracture modes (interface shear, layered, pull-out) that correlated with the mechanical performance, providing visual evidence of interfacial integrity.

Key Results

  • ILSS: The ILSS of the composite increased with AG-80 content, reaching a maximum of 96.09 MPa at 80% AG-80. However, further increases in AG-80 did not significantly enhance ILSS. The best overall ILSS was achieved with the AG-80/DDS formulation.
  • Compressive Strength: The maximum compressive strength was recorded for the 60% AG-80/40% E-1NT/DDS/CF composite with the cationic sizing agent (S1), reaching 748.52 MPa. This was a significant improvement (14-18%) compared to composites using non-ionic (S2) and anionic (S3) sizing agents.
  • Optimal Formulation: The 60% AG-80/40% E-1NT/DDS/CF formulation, when combined with the cationic sizing agent (S1), demonstrated the best overall balance of ILSS and compressive strength.
  • EPN Performance: While not the focus of the resin blending study, the EPN/DDS/CF composite with the anionic sizing agent (S3) showed the highest compressive strength (665.75 MPa) among the EPN-based formulations.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limited Resin Types: The study focused on AG-80 and E-1NT for blending, with EPN used as a separate comparison. Further exploration of other high-performance epoxies or different blending strategies could yield additional insights.
  • Proprietary Sizing Agent Compositions: The exact chemical compositions of the sizing agents were proprietary, limiting a deeper understanding of the specific chemical interactions responsible for the observed effects.
  • Future Work Suggestions: The authors implicitly suggest that further optimization of sizing agent chemistry and resin formulations, potentially exploring novel additives or processing techniques, could lead to even greater improvements in CFRP performance. Investigating the long-term durability and environmental resistance of these optimized composites would also be valuable.

Summary updated

Abstract

Interlaminar shear strength (ILSS) and compressive strength are two of the most critical properties of carbon fiber-reinforced polymer (CFRP). In this report, three types of epoxy resins-4,4'-diaminodiphenylmethane epoxy resin (AG-80), bisphenol A epoxy resin (E-1NT), and novolac epoxy (EPN)-were studied. E-1NT is characterized by low viscosity and low cost but exhibits poor mechanical properties, while AG-80 offers better wetting with carbon fiber. These two epoxy resins were mixed in various mass ratios. The study revealed that as the AG-80 content increased, the ILSS of the composite also increased, reaching a maximum of 94.04 MPa when the AG-80 content reached 60%. Beyond this point, further increases in AG-80 did not enhance the ILSS. Conversely, the compressive strength initially increased but then declined sharply as the AG-80 ratio increased. The maximum compressive strength was recorded at 748.52 MPa when the AG-80 content reached 60%, which was 21% higher than pure AG-80 and 32% higher than pure E-1NT. Additionally, the study examined three different types of ionic sizing agents and four different resin matrices (E-1NT/DDS, AG-80/DDS, AG-80/E-1NT/DDS, EPN/DDS). Among them, the 60% AG-80/40% E-1NT/DDS/CF formulation demonstrated the best balance in both ILSS and compressive strength.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{song2024effects,
  author = {Pengfei Song and Qin Fang and Wen Liu and Xinyue Ma and Qingchao Li and Mehraj‐ud‐din Naik and Mudasir Ahmad and Guoqing Huang and Chuncai Yang},
  title = {{Effects of Sizing Agents and Resin-Formulated Matrices with Varying Stiffness–Toughness Ratios on the Properties of Carbon Fiber Epoxy Resin Composites}},
  booktitle = {Polymers},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.3390/polym16233447},
}
Figure