Effects of simulated multi-sensory stimulation integration on physiological and psychological restoration in virtual urban green space environment

Chen Song, Saixin Cao, Hao Luo, Yinghui Huang, Siwei Jiang, Baimeng Guo, Nian Li, Kai Li, Ping Zhang, Chunyan Zhu, Erkang Fu, Mingyan Jiang, Xi LiFrontiers in Psychology 2024 · DOI

Abstract

Virtual urban green environment images and audio stimuli have been proven to have restorative effects on physical and mental health. However, research has predominantly focused on visual, auditory, and olfactory aspects, leaving tactile and gustatory senses minimally explored. This study employed a simulated sensory stimulation approach with 240 participants across eight experimental groups (VA, VAO, VAT, VAG, VAOT, VAOG, VATG, and VAOTG) to explore differences in physiological and psychological recovery. Results indicated that all groups showed significant blood pressure recovery, with the five-sense (VAOTG) group performing best. Tactile stimulation was identified as a key factor for physiological recovery, while the interaction of olfactory and gustatory stimuli was most critical for psychological restoration. The VAOG group showed the best psychological recovery. This study confirms the potential of multi-sensory virtual environments for health restoration and provides theoretical support for their application.

Introduction

While the restorative benefits of "green exercise" and nature exposure are well-documented, physical access to nature is often restricted for the elderly, hospital patients, or residents of high-density urban areas. Virtual Urban Green Spaces (UGSs) offer a promising alternative. Historically, research in this field has concentrated on visual and auditory stimuli. While some studies have incorporated olfactory elements, the roles of tactile and gustatory senses remain largely under-investigated. This paper addresses whether a synergistic effect exists when all five senses are engaged in a virtual environment and identifies the optimal sensory combinations for physical and mental recovery.

Methodology

The study involved 240 participants divided into eight groups of 30. To establish a baseline of stress, participants underwent a five-minute "pre-test" consisting of loud noise and mathematical calculations.

Sensory Stimuli

The experimental groups were exposed to various combinations of five simulated stimuli:

  1. Visual (V): 25 high-quality photographs of urban green spaces in Chengdu, China.
  2. Auditory (A): Synchronized natural sounds (birdsong, water, wind) at 55 dB.
  3. Olfactory (O): Fragrance from Gardenia jasminoides branches.
  4. Tactile (T): Spontaneous touching of a potted Pachira glabra Pasq. (Money Tree).
  5. Gustatory (G): Spontaneous consumption of cherry tomatoes.
Example of visual stimulation used in the study.
Experimental setup for multi-sensory stimulation.

Measurement

Physiological recovery was assessed via systolic/diastolic blood pressure (SBP/DBP) and pulse. Psychological recovery was measured using the 40-adjective Profile of Mood States (POMS) scale, tracking dimensions such as tension, depression, and vigor.

Results

Physiological Recovery

All eight experimental groups exhibited significant decreases in SBP post-exposure, confirming the restorative potential of virtual UGSs. The VAOTG (all five senses) group showed the most significant blood pressure recovery ($p < 0.05$). Tactile stimulation emerged as a critical factor; interactions between olfactory-tactile or tactile-gustatory stimuli significantly enhanced physiological outcomes, emphasizing the importance of touch in physical relaxation.

Psychological Recovery

The VAOG (Visual-Auditory-Olfactory-Gustatory) group achieved the highest improvement in positive mood and the greatest reduction in total mood disturbance ($p < 0.05$), followed by the VAOTG group. The interaction between olfactory and gustatory senses was identified as the primary trigger for psychological restoration. Interestingly, while more senses generally led to better results, the addition of touch to the VAOG group (creating VAOTG) slightly lowered psychological scores, suggesting a potential minor distraction from mental "flow."

Discussion and Conclusion

This research highlights the importance of multi-sensory integration beyond simple audio-visual experiences. Tactile stimulation appears particularly effective for physical relaxation, possibly due to the regulation of oxytocin through C-tactile afferents. Gustatory and olfactory stimuli are key for mood restoration, with their interaction acting as a powerful psychological trigger.

Limitations and Future Work

The study's ecological validity is limited by its laboratory setting and use of static photos. Future research should utilize more immersive technologies like VR headsets or 360-degree video. Additionally, the participant pool was limited to university students; further studies are needed to generalize these findings to broader demographics, such as the elderly or clinical populations. Ultimately, these findings provide a roadmap for designing "healing rooms" in urban or clinical settings, suggesting that incorporating tactile and gustatory elements—like touchable plants and fresh fruit—can significantly enhance the restorative power of virtual nature.

Summary updated

Abstract

Virtual urban green environment images and audio stimuli had been proven to have restorative effects on subjects' physical and mental health. In this area, researchers predominantly focused on visual, auditory and olfactory aspects, while tactile and gustatory senses have been minimally explored. However, the optimal combination of sensory stimuli for promoting physical and mental recovery remains unclear. Therefore, a simulated sensory stimulation approach involving 240 participants was employed, with 30 individuals included in each of the eight experimental groups: the visual-auditory (VA), visual-auditory-olfactory (VAO), visual-auditory-tactile (VAT), visual-auditory-gustatory(VAG), visual-auditory-olfactory-tactile (VAOT), visual-auditory-olfactory-gustatory (VAOG), visual-auditory-tactile-gustatory (VATG), and visual-auditory-olfactory-tactile-gustatory (VAOTG) groups. This study aimed to explore the differences in participants' physiological and psychological health recovery after exposure to different combinations of simulated sensory stimuli in virtual UGSs. The results indicated that the following: (1) In terms of physiological recovery, the blood pressure of the 8 experimental groups decreased significantly after the experiment, indicating that the virtual urban green space environment has a certain recovery effect on physiological state. The combination of VAOTG stimuli in the multisensory group resulted in the best blood pressure recovery (<i>p</i> < 0.05). Tactile is an important sense to enhance the physiological recovery effect. Olfactory-tactile or tactile-gustatory stimuli interactions significantly enhance physiological recovery, emphasizing the importance of tactile stimulation in improving physiological recovery. (2) In terms of psychological recovery, the common trigger of olfactory-gustatory is the most key element to enhance psychological recovery through multi-sensory stimulation of virtual urban green space environment. VAOG stimulation had the best effect on psychological recovery (<i>p</i> < 0.05), followed by VAOTG stimulation (<i>p</i> < 0.05). Gustatory is an important sense to enhance the psychological recovery effect, and both the tactile-gustatory interaction and the olfactory-gustatory interaction significantly enhance the recovery effect. At the same time, the psychological recovery effect obtained by four or more sensory combinations was higher than that obtained by two or three sensory stimulation groups. This study confirms more possibilities for ways to restore physical and mental health through virtual natural environments. It expands the research on the benefits of virtual nature experience and provides theoretical support for the application of this method.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{song2024effects,
  author = {Chen Song and Saixin Cao and Hao Luo and Yinghui Huang and Siwei Jiang and Baimeng Guo and Nian Li and Kai Li and Ping Zhang and Chunyan Zhu and Erkang Fu and Mingyan Jiang and Xi Li},
  title = {{Effects of simulated multi-sensory stimulation integration on physiological and psychological restoration in virtual urban green space environment}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Psychology},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.3389/fpsyg.2024.1382143},
}
Figure