Effects of Septum Resection for Secondary Infertility on Subsequent Reproductive Outcomes of in vitro Fertilization–Intracytoplasmic Sperm Injection

Huixiao Chen, Ping Sun, Na Zhang, Shangge Lv, Yongzhi Cao, Lei YanFrontiers in Medicine 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This retrospective cohort study demonstrates that hysteroscopic septum resection significantly improves cumulative pregnancy rates and frozen embryo transfer (FET) outcomes for women with secondary infertility. The findings suggest that surgically correcting this congenital uterine anomaly before starting IVF/ICSI cycles can lead to better reproductive success, particularly in delivery rates during frozen cycles.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

A uterine septum is a common congenital malformation where a wedge of tissue divides the uterine cavity. While it is strongly linked to recurrent miscarriage, its role in secondary infertility—where a woman has previously been pregnant but is now unable to conceive—is less clear.

Clinicians have long debated whether "fixing" the septum via surgery (hysteroscopic metroplasty) actually improves the chances of a successful live birth during Assisted Reproductive Technology (ART) like IVF or ICSI. Because assigning patients to a "no treatment" group in a randomized trial is often considered unethical (given the known risks of miscarriage), there is a lack of high-quality evidence specifically targeting the secondary infertility population. This paper seeks to fill that gap by comparing reproductive outcomes between women who underwent surgery and those who did not.

Methods

The researchers conducted a retrospective cohort study at the Reproductive Hospital affiliated with Shandong University, analyzing data from 269 patients treated between 2009 and 2019.

  • Surgical Group (n=169): Patients with secondary infertility and a uterine septum who underwent hysteroscopic resection before starting IVF/ICSI.
  • Control Group (n=100): Patients with the same diagnosis who chose to proceed directly to embryo transfer without surgery.

The study tracked cumulative pregnancy rates and cumulative live birth rates over one complete ART cycle (including both fresh and frozen-thawed embryo transfers). Statistical analysis involved t-tests for continuous data and chi-square tests for categorical outcomes.

Datasets

The study utilized a clinical dataset of medical records from 269 patients, resulting in a total of 430 embryo-transfer (ET) cycles (252 in the surgery group and 178 in the control group). No external benchmarks or public datasets were used, as this is a primary clinical observation study.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "FET Advantage": One of the most striking findings was that the benefits of surgery were most statistically significant during Frozen Embryo Transfer (FET) cycles rather than fresh cycles. This suggests that a surgically corrected uterus may provide a more receptive environment for thawed embryos.
  • Cumulative Success Matters: By looking at the cumulative rate (the result of all transfers from a single egg retrieval), the authors provide a more realistic picture of a patient's total chance of success compared to looking at a single transfer in isolation.
  • Surgical Justification: The study provides empirical support for performing septum resection in secondary infertile patients, moving beyond the traditional indication of only treating those with a history of miscarriage.

Key Results

The surgical group outperformed the control group across several primary and secondary metrics:

  • Cumulative Pregnancy Rate: Significantly higher in the surgery group (71.0% vs. 59.0%, $P = 0.044$).
  • FET Clinical Pregnancy Rate: Surgery led to a significant jump (52.7% vs. 38.2%, $P = 0.028$).
  • FET Delivery Rate: The most clinically meaningful result showed a nearly 16% increase in deliveries for the surgery group (38.2% vs. 22.5%, $P = 0.011$).
  • Fresh ET Cycles: While the surgery group trended higher (54.9% vs 40.6%), the difference did not reach statistical significance ($P = 0.061$), suggesting that the uterine environment's recovery or the specific conditions of FET might be where the surgery shines most.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  1. Retrospective Design: As an observational study, it cannot definitively prove causality in the same way a Randomized Controlled Trial (RCT) could.
  2. Sample Size: The final number of participants was lower than the researchers' theoretical ideal, partly due to patients dropping out or vague initial diagnoses.
  3. Septum Metrics: The study did not have enough data to correlate the size (thickness or depth) of the septum with the degree of improvement after surgery.
  4. Inconsistency: Surgeries were performed by different clinicians, which may introduce technical variability.

Future Work: The authors call for a large-scale, prospective randomized controlled trial to confirm these findings and to investigate whether the specific dimensions of the septum influence the surgical outcome.

Summary updated

Abstract

The reproductive outcomes of IVF/ICSI after septum resection in patients with secondary infertility were better than that in the untreated group, suggesting that uterine septum resection can be performed in patients with uterine septum combined with infertility to improve their reproductive outcomes.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{chen2022effects,
  author = {Huixiao Chen and Ping Sun and Na Zhang and Shangge Lv and Yongzhi Cao and Lei Yan},
  title = {{Effects of Septum Resection for Secondary Infertility on Subsequent Reproductive Outcomes of in vitro Fertilization–Intracytoplasmic Sperm Injection}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Medicine},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3389/fmed.2022.765827},
}
Figure