Effects of resonance energy and nonplanar strain energy on the reliability of hyperhomodesmotic reactions for corannulene

Chenghua Sun, Di Yao, Gao Qing Lu, Hui–Ming ChengChemical 2006 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper investigates the reliability of hyperhomodesmotic reactions for calculating the heat of formation of corannulene, a complex polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbon. The authors find that the accuracy of these calculations is significantly influenced by both resonance energy and nonplanar strain energy, leading to a refined set of principles for selecting appropriate reference molecules to improve predictive power for similar molecules like fullerenes.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Calculating the standard heat of formation ($\Delta H_f^\circ$) for complex organic molecules is crucial for understanding their stability and reactivity. Hyperhomodesmotic reactions are a computational tool used for this purpose, but their reliability for polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs) and fullerenes has been questioned. Previous work suggested that these reactions should only involve aromatic species. However, recent studies have shown discrepancies even with this restriction, particularly for strained molecules like fullerenes. This paper aims to address this by exploring how resonance energy (RE) and nonplanar strain energy (Es) affect the accuracy of hyperhomodesmotic reactions, specifically using corannulene as a model system. The goal is to develop more robust guidelines for constructing these reactions to ensure reliable $\Delta H_f^\circ$ calculations for PAHs and fullerenes.

Methods

The researchers employed a computational approach to calculate the heat of formation of corannulene using 40 different hyperhomodesmotic reactions. They evaluated four distinct schemes for constructing these reactions, each with varying requirements regarding the balance of strain energy (ΔEs) and resonance energy (ARE) between reactants and products.

  • Hyperhomodesmotic Reactions: These are chemical reactions designed such that the types of bonds and their environments are conserved on both sides of the equation, minimizing computational errors.
  • Reference Molecules: The study utilized a set of 15 PAHs and two fullerenes (C60 and C70) as reference molecules.
  • Strain Energy (Es): This was calculated using established methods, accounting for deviations from ideal bond lengths and angles due to molecular strain.
  • Resonance Energy (RE): This was calculated using the Hückel computational method, quantifying the stabilization gained from electron delocalization in aromatic systems.
  • Scheme Comparison: The core of the methodology involved comparing the calculated $\Delta H_f^\circ$ values for corannulene against its experimental value under different reaction schemes. This allowed them to identify which schemes and which reference molecules yielded the most accurate results.

Datasets

The study utilized the following datasets:

  • Experimental $\Delta H_f^\circ$ for Corannulene: This served as the benchmark for evaluating the accuracy of the computational methods. The value of 110.2 kcal/mol was taken from the CRC Handbook.
  • Total Energies (ET): These were obtained from a previous study by Yu et al. [5].
  • Strain Energies (Es): These were calculated based on data from a previous work by Sun et al. [8].
  • Resonance Energies (RE): These were calculated using the Hückel method.
  • Structures and Properties of PAHs and Fullerenes: Data for 15 PAHs (labeled S1-S12, S28) and two fullerenes (C60, C70) were used as reference molecules.

No new benchmark datasets were introduced; rather, existing experimental and computational data were leveraged.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Beyond Aromaticity: The reliability of hyperhomodesmotic reactions is not solely determined by using only aromatic species. Both resonance energy (RE) and nonplanar strain energy (Es) play critical roles and must be considered.
  • Scheme Dependence: Different schemes for balancing RE and Es in hyperhomodesmotic reactions yield vastly different results. Scheme 2, which balances ΔEs and ARE, initially showed promise but faltered for more complex reactions involving strained molecules.
  • Structural Similarity Matters: Reference molecules that are structurally similar to the target molecule (corannulene) lead to more accurate calculations. This is because they better mimic the bonding and strain characteristics.
  • Simplicity is Key: Smaller, simpler reference molecules generally lead to better results and are computationally more efficient.
  • Corannulene as a Model: Corannulene's structure, being a basic motif in many fullerenes and possessing significant strain, makes it an excellent test case for evaluating these computational methods.

Key Results

  • The study found that for reactions involving simpler PAHs (R1-R25), Scheme 2 provided the most accurate $\Delta H_f^\circ$ for corannulene, with errors close to 0.01 kcal/mol in some cases.
  • However, for reactions involving more complex molecules like F5 (R26-R40), Scheme 1 (which approximates ARE=0) performed better, yielding errors around 11.49 kcal/mol. Scheme 2 showed significantly larger errors in these cases.
  • The authors demonstrated that using F3 as a reference molecule for corannulene (F13) in Scheme 2 yielded a very small error (0.01 kcal/mol), whereas using F5 resulted in a much larger error (11.74 kcal/mol), highlighting the importance of reference molecule selection.
  • The paper proposes two principles for selecting reference molecules: (i) structural similarity to the object molecule, and (ii) simplicity and small size.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Scheme 4 Limitations: While Scheme 4 aims to balance both ΔEs and ARE, the paper notes that constructing such reactions can be challenging and may not always lead to improved results, as seen with the errors of 11.49, 11.49, and 12.79 kcal/mol for three such reactions.
  • Overcounting Effects: The authors suggest that simultaneously satisfying ΔEs = 0 and ARE = 0 might lead to overcounting the effects of rehybridization, which is correlated with both strain and resonance.
  • Future Work: The findings suggest that for fullerenes, hyperhomodesmotic reactions should ideally involve only other fullerenes. The principles of structural similarity and simplicity for reference molecule selection should be applied analogously to PAHs and fullerenes, providing a valuable framework for future computational studies in this area.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{sun2006effects,
  author = {Chenghua Sun and Di Yao and Gao Qing Lu and Hui–Ming Cheng},
  title = {{Effects of resonance energy and nonplanar strain energy on the reliability of hyperhomodesmotic reactions for corannulene}},
  booktitle = {Chemical},
  year = {2006},
  doi = {10.1016/j.cplett.2006.11.105},
}

Loading related content...

Figure