Effects of Prone Ventilation on Oxygenation, Inflammation, and Lung Infiltrates in COVID-19 Related Acute Respiratory Distress Syndrome: A Retrospective Cohort Study

Rohit Khullar, Shrey Shah, Gagandeep Singh, Joseph Bae, Rishabh Gattu, Shubham Jain, Jeremy Green, Thiruvengadam Anandarangam, Marc Cohen, Nikhil Madan, Prateek PrasannaJournal of Clinical Medicine 2020 · DOI

TL;DR

This retrospective study investigated the impact of prone ventilation on COVID-19 patients with severe ARDS. While prone ventilation improved oxygenation in both survivors and non-survivors, chest X-ray findings of lung infiltrates before proning were more predictive of survival than oxygenation levels, suggesting CXRs could help select patients who will benefit most.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The COVID-19 pandemic led to a surge in patients with severe acute respiratory distress syndrome (ARDS), often referred to as CARDS in this context. These patients frequently require mechanical ventilation, and their mortality rates are alarmingly high (76-98% in some reports). Prone ventilation (turning patients onto their stomachs) is a known intervention that can improve oxygenation in ARDS patients, but its effectiveness and predictive factors for success in the specific context of COVID-19 were still being elucidated. This paper aims to understand how prone ventilation affects oxygenation, lung inflammation (as seen on chest X-rays), and systemic inflammation in CARDS patients, and crucially, to identify baseline characteristics that predict survival after this intervention.

Methods

This was a retrospective cohort study involving 23 patients with moderate-to-severe CARDS who received at least 16 hours of prone ventilation daily. The researchers collected data on arterial blood gases (PaO2/FiO2), ventilatory parameters, and chest X-rays (CXRs) before, immediately after, and 48 hours after prone ventilation. They also measured serological markers of inflammation. A key methodological contribution was the development of a CXR scoring system to quantify lung infiltrate severity, focusing on gravity-dependent lung zones. Statistical analyses included Wilcoxon signed-rank tests for paired comparisons and Mann-Whitney U tests and chi-squared tests for comparing subgroups (living vs. deceased) and categorical variables.

Datasets

The study utilized data from 23 patients admitted to Newark Beth Israel Medical Center between March and May 2020 who met the criteria for moderate-to-severe CARDS and received prone ventilation. This represents a real-world clinical dataset. No new benchmark datasets were introduced.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • CXR as a Prognostic Tool: The most striking insight is the potential of chest X-rays, specifically the severity and pattern of lung infiltrates in the lower lung zones before prone ventilation, to predict patient outcomes. This is a novel application of CXR interpretation in this context.
  • Oxygenation vs. Infiltrates for Survival: While prone ventilation significantly improved oxygenation (PaO2/FiO2) in both survivors and non-survivors, the degree of improvement was actually greater in the deceased group. This suggests that simply looking at oxygenation alone might be misleading for predicting survival. In contrast, changes in lung infiltrates, particularly in gravity-dependent areas, showed a more promising correlation with survival.
  • Confluent Infiltrates as a Good Sign: Patients with confluent infiltrates in their lower lung zones before proning had a much higher survival rate (80%) compared to those with ground-glass opacities (GGOs) (8%). This suggests that the type of lung pathology visible on CXR is a critical factor.
  • Early Proning Advantage: Patients who were proned earlier (within 2 days of intubation) were twice as likely to show sustained improvement in oxygenation 48 hours after proning, although this did not reach statistical significance in this small cohort. This hints at the importance of timely intervention.
  • Systemic Inflammation Reduction: Prone ventilation was associated with significant reductions in inflammatory markers like LDH, CRP, and ferritin, as well as improvements in SOFA and SAPS scores, indicating a broader beneficial effect beyond just oxygenation.

Key Results

  • Oxygenation Improvement: Immediately after prone ventilation, PaO2/FiO2 improved by 108% in the living and 150% in the deceased. This improvement was sustained to some extent at 48 hours.
  • Lung Infiltrate Changes: The 48-hour change in lung infiltrate severity in gravity-dependent zones was significantly better for the living than for the deceased (p < 0.02). The living showed improvement, while the deceased showed worsening infiltrates.
  • CXR Predictors: 80% of patients with confluent infiltrates in lower lung zones survived, compared to only 8% of patients with GGOs.
  • Early Proning: Patients proned <2 days after intubation were more likely to have sustained oxygenation improvement (61.5% vs. 30.0%), though this was not statistically significant (p < 0.14).
  • Inflammatory Markers: Mean LDH decreased by 14.8%, CRP by 38.4%, and ferritin by 28.5% after prone ventilation.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Small Sample Size: The study included only 23 patients, with a disproportionately small number of survivors (n=6). This limits the statistical power and generalizability of the findings.
  • Retrospective Design: As a retrospective study, it's subject to the inherent biases and limitations of data collection from electronic medical records.
  • Lack of a Control Group: All eligible patients received prone ventilation, so a direct comparison to a control group receiving only standard mechanical ventilation was not possible. This prevents definitive conclusions about the mortality benefit of prone ventilation in this specific cohort.
  • Short Proning Duration: Most patients were proned for only one day, which is shorter than recommended in some guidelines.
  • Single Center: The study was conducted at a single medical center, which may limit the applicability of findings to other healthcare settings.

Future work suggested includes:

  • Larger Cohorts and Multivariable Analysis: To overcome the limitations of sample size and identify a broader range of predictive factors.
  • Incorporating CXR Scores into Predictive Models: Developing machine learning algorithms that combine CXR-derived lung severity scores with other clinical and inflammatory markers to better select patients who will benefit from prone ventilation.
  • Investigating Early Proning: Further research into the optimal timing of prone ventilation, particularly in the early stages of mechanical ventilation.
  • Understanding Systemic Inflammation: Exploring the role of prone positioning in reducing systemic inflammation and its potential impact on survival.

Summary updated

Abstract

Patients receiving mechanical ventilation for coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) related, moderate-to-severe acute respiratory distress syndrome (CARDS) have mortality rates between 76-98%. The objective of this retrospective cohort study was to identify differences in prone ventilation effects on oxygenation, pulmonary infiltrates (as observed on chest X-ray (CXR)), and systemic inflammation in CARDS patients by survivorship and to identify baseline characteristics associated with survival after prone ventilation. The study cohort included 23 patients with moderate-to-severe CARDS who received prone ventilation for ≥16 h/day and was segmented by living status: living (<i>n</i> = 6) and deceased (<i>n</i> = 17). Immediately after prone ventilation, PaO<sub>2</sub>/FiO<sub>2</sub> improved by 108% (<i>p</i> < 0.03) for the living and 150% (<i>p</i> < 3 × 10<sup>-4</sup>) for the deceased. However, the 48 h change in lung infiltrate severity in gravity-dependent lung zones was significantly better for the living than for the deceased (<i>p</i> < 0.02). In CXRs of the lower lungs before prone ventilation, we observed 5 patients with confluent infiltrates bilaterally, 12 patients with ground-glass opacities (GGOs) bilaterally, and 6 patients with mixed infiltrate patterns; 80% of patients with confluent infiltrates were alive vs. 8% of patients with GGOs. In conclusion, our small study indicates that CXRs may offer clinical utility in selecting patients with moderate-to-severe CARDS who will benefit from prone ventilation. Additionally, our study suggests that lung infiltrate severity may be a better indicator of patient disposition after prone ventilation than PaO<sub>2</sub>/FiO<sub>2</sub>.
BibTeX
@article{khullar2020effects,
  author = {Rohit Khullar and Shrey Shah and Gagandeep Singh and Joseph Bae and Rishabh Gattu and Shubham Jain and Jeremy Green and Thiruvengadam Anandarangam and Marc Cohen and Nikhil Madan and Prateek Prasanna},
  title = {{Effects of Prone Ventilation on Oxygenation, Inflammation, and Lung Infiltrates in COVID-19 Related Acute Respiratory Distress Syndrome: A Retrospective Cohort Study}},
  journal = {Journal of Clinical Medicine},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.3390/jcm9124129},
}
Figure