Effects of Prescribed Burning on Soil CO2 Emissions from Pinus yunnanensis Forestland in Central Yunnan, China

Bo Yang, Q. B. Chen, Shunqing Gong, Yue Zhao, Denghui Song, Jianqiang LiSustainability 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigated the impact of low-intensity, high-frequency prescribed burning on soil CO2 emissions in Pinus yunnanensis forests in China. The findings indicate that while prescribed burning did not alter annual carbon flux, it significantly influenced seasonal CO2 emissions and the relationship between soil moisture and CO2 release, suggesting it's a viable fire management strategy without long-term negative carbon cycle impacts.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Forest ecosystems play a critical role in the global carbon cycle, with soil respiration being a major contributor to atmospheric CO2. Understanding how disturbances like fire affect this process is crucial for climate change mitigation and sustainable forest management. Prescribed burning is a common practice for fire hazard reduction, but its long-term effects on soil CO2 emissions, particularly in specific forest types like Pinus yunnanensis in Central Yunnan, China, require detailed investigation. Previous research has yielded inconsistent results regarding fire's impact on soil respiration, often due to variations in fire intensity, frequency, and ecosystem type. This paper aims to fill this knowledge gap by examining the effects of a specific, low-intensity, high-frequency prescribed burning regime on soil CO2 flux and its relationship with soil hydrothermal factors over a two-year period.

Methods

The researchers established experimental plots in a Pinus yunnanensis forest, dividing them into two treatments: unburned (UB) and after prescribed burning (AB). Over two years (March 2019 to February 2021), they collected data on soil CO2 flux, soil temperature, and soil moisture.

  • Soil CO2 Flux Measurement: A Li-6400XT portable photosynthesis meter with a Li-6400-09 soil respiration chamber was used to measure CO2 flux. To minimize disturbance, polyethylene rings were installed in the soil 24 hours prior to measurements.
  • Soil Temperature and Moisture Measurement: A TRIME®-PICO 64/32 soil temperature and moisture meter was employed to simultaneously measure these parameters at a 10 cm depth.
  • Sampling Frequency: Measurements were taken twice per quarter, once in the morning (9:00-12:00) and once in the afternoon (14:00-17:00), at three sites within each plot (upper slope, mid-slope, lower slope).
  • Data Analysis: Statistical analyses included ANOVA to compare treatments and time points, and regression analysis to model the relationships between soil CO2 flux and hydrothermal factors. They specifically explored linear, quadratic, and exponential models to capture these relationships. Annual soil carbon flux was calculated by summing quarterly respiration rates.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study utilized field measurements collected over two years.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Seasonal Rhythm is Key: Soil CO2 emissions follow a distinct seasonal pattern, peaking in the rainy season (September) and declining in the dry season, regardless of burning treatment. This highlights the strong influence of moisture availability on soil respiration.
  • Burning's Subtle Impact: While prescribed burning didn't alter the annual total soil carbon flux, it did lead to lower peak CO2 emissions during the rainy season in the burned plots compared to unburned plots. This suggests a short-term dampening effect.
  • Moisture is the Master Regulator: Soil moisture emerged as the dominant factor controlling soil CO2 flux. The relationship between moisture and CO2 flux shifted significantly after burning: an inverted U-shape in unburned plots (suggesting an optimal moisture range) versus a positive correlation in burned plots (more moisture, more CO2).
  • Temperature Takes a Backseat: Interestingly, soil temperature showed no significant direct effect on soil CO2 flux in this Pinus yunnanensis forest, a finding that contrasts with some other forest types. This might be due to the specific hydrothermal regime or the nature of the disturbance.
  • Prescribed Burning as a Tool: The study provides evidence that low-intensity, high-frequency prescribed burning can be an effective tool for fire hazard reduction without causing a persistent, drastic increase in soil CO2 emissions, supporting its use in sustainable forest management.

Key Results

  • Seasonal CO2 Flux: Both unburned (UB) and after prescribed burning (AB) plots showed a significant unimodal seasonal trend in soil CO2 flux. In 2020, peak CO2 fluxes in September were 7.08 µmol CO2·m⁻²·s⁻¹ (morning) and 7.63 µmol CO2·m⁻²·s⁻¹ (afternoon) in the AB treatment, which were significantly lower than in the UB treatment (p < 0.05).
  • Annual CO2 Flux: There were no significant differences in annual soil carbon flux between the UB and AB treatments (p > 0.05).
  • Soil Moisture-CO2 Relationship: The relationship between soil CO2 flux and moisture was best described by a quadratic function (R² between 0.435 and 0.753). In UB plots, this relationship was an inverted U-shape (p < 0.05), while in AB plots, it was a positive correlation (p < 0.05).
  • Factor Importance: Soil moisture was identified as the key factor affecting soil CO2 flux (p < 0.05), whereas soil temperature showed no significant effect (p > 0.05).

Limitations and Future Work

  • Study Duration: While two years of data were collected, longer-term monitoring would provide a more comprehensive understanding of the sustained impacts of prescribed burning.
  • Single Ecosystem Type: The study focused on Pinus yunnanensis forests. Further research across different forest types and under varying burning regimes is needed to generalize the findings.
  • Laboratory vs. Field: The authors acknowledge that field conditions involve complex interactions. They suggest future laboratory experiments to isolate the effect of soil moisture on soil CO2 flux by controlling other environmental factors. This would help to further elucidate the mechanisms behind the observed relationships.
  • Generalizability of Temperature Effect: The lack of a significant temperature effect on CO2 flux in this specific study warrants further investigation in similar ecosystems to confirm if this is a consistent pattern or specific to the conditions encountered.

Summary updated

Abstract

The effects of low-intensity and high-frequency prescribed burning on the soil CO2 emissions from Pinus yunnanensis forestland should be explored to achieve sustainable operation and management under fire disturbance. A Li-6400XT portable photosynthesis meter (equipped with a Li-6400-09 soil respiration chamber) and a TRIME®-PICO 64/32 soil temperature and moisture meter were used to measure the soil CO2 flux, soil temperature, and soil moisture at fixed observation sites in two treatments (i.e., unburned (UB) and after prescribed burning (AB)) in a Pinus yunnanensis forest of Zhaobi Mountain, Xinping County, Yunnan, China from March 2019 to February 2021. We also determined the relationships between the soil CO2 flux and soil hydrothermal factors. The results showed that (1) the soil CO2 flux in both UB and AB plots exhibited a significant unimodal trend of seasonal variations. In 2020, the highest soil CO2 fluxes occurred in September; they were 7.08 μmol CO2·m−2·s−1 in the morning and 7.63 μmol CO2·m−2·s−1 in the afternoon in the AB treatment, which was significantly lower than those in the UB treatment (p &lt; 0.05). The AB and the UB treatment showed no significant differences in annual soil carbon flux (p &gt; 0.05). (2) The relationship between the soil CO2 flux and moisture in the AB and UB plots was best fitted by a quadratic function, with a degree of fitting between 0.435 and 0.753. The soil CO2 flux and soil moisture showed an inverted U-shaped correlation in the UB plot (p &lt; 0.05) but a positive correlation in the AB plot (p &lt; 0.05). Soil moisture was the key factor affecting the soil CO2 flux (p &lt; 0.05), while soil temperature showed no significant effect on soil CO2 flux in this area (p &gt; 0.05). Therefore, the application of low-intensity prescribed burning for fire hazard reduction in this region achieved the objective without causing a persistent and drastic increase in the soil CO2 emissions. The results could provide important theoretical support for scientific implementation of prescribed burning, as well as scientific evaluation of ecological and environmental effects after prescribed burning.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{yang2022effects,
  author = {Bo Yang and Q. B. Chen and Shunqing Gong and Yue Zhao and Denghui Song and Jianqiang Li},
  title = {{Effects of Prescribed Burning on Soil CO2 Emissions from Pinus yunnanensis Forestland in Central Yunnan, China}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3390/su14095375},
}
Figure