Effects of Non‐Pharmacological Interventions on the Swallowing Function of Patients With Post‐Stroke Dysphagia: A Systematic Review and Network Meta‐Analysis

Bohan Zhang, Ka Po Wong, Cai Guo, Shu‐Cheng Chen, Shuojin Fu, Ruifu Kang, Qian Xiao, Jing QinJournal of Oral Rehabilitation 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This systematic review and network meta-analysis compared various non-pharmacological interventions for post-stroke dysphagia, finding acupuncture to be the most effective for improving swallowing function. However, considering cost and feasibility, chin tuck against resistance (CTAR) exercise is recommended as a practical rehabilitation measure.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Stroke survivors frequently experience dysphagia, or difficulty swallowing, which can lead to serious complications like aspiration pneumonia, malnutrition, and even death. While various rehabilitation methods exist, there's no clear consensus on which is the most effective. This paper aims to address this by systematically comparing a range of non-pharmacological interventions to identify the best approaches for improving swallowing, feeding, and daily functions in post-stroke dysphagia patients.

Methods

The researchers conducted a systematic review and network meta-analysis. They searched seven databases for randomized controlled trials (RCTs) published up to September 1, 2022, focusing on interventions for post-stroke dysphagia. A network meta-analysis was chosen because it allows for the comparison of multiple interventions simultaneously, including indirect comparisons, which is more comprehensive than traditional pairwise meta-analyses. The analysis involved assessing the effectiveness of interventions based on swallowing function, and feeding and daily function outcomes. The ranking of interventions was determined using the surface under the cumulative ranking curve (SUCRA) values.

Datasets

This paper does not use datasets in the traditional machine learning sense. Instead, it synthesizes data from 33 previously published randomized controlled trials (RCTs) involving 1,341 patients with post-stroke dysphagia.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Acupuncture Reigns Supreme (for efficacy): Acupuncture emerged as the most effective intervention for improving swallowing function, demonstrating a significant positive effect.
  • CTAR: The Practical Powerhouse: While acupuncture showed the highest efficacy, the chin tuck against resistance (CTAR) exercise was identified as a highly feasible and low-cost option, making it a strong contender for practical clinical application.
  • Multifaceted Benefits: The study not only looked at swallowing function but also considered improvements in feeding and daily activities, providing a more holistic view of intervention effectiveness.
  • Heterogeneity in Interventions: The study categorized interventions into peripheral and central stimulation methods, muscle strength exercises, and traditional Chinese medicine, highlighting the diverse approaches available.
  • Safety is Generally Good, but Underreported: While most interventions were found to be safe, with adverse effects being transient, a significant portion of the included studies did not report on safety outcomes, suggesting a need for more consistent safety reporting in future research.

Key Results

  • Swallowing Function: Acupuncture was ranked as the most effective intervention for improving swallowing function (SUCRA: 99.0%), followed by CTAR (SUCRA: 89.9%) and shaker exercise (SUCRA: 80.5%).
  • Feeding and Daily Function: Acupuncture also ranked highest for improving feeding and daily function (SUCRA: 88.4%), followed by iTBS (SUCRA: 76.0%), tDCS (SUCRA: 69.1%), and CTAR (SUCRA: 64.0%).
  • Combined Effects: When considering both swallowing function and feeding/daily function, acupuncture was the most effective, followed by CTAR and shaker.
  • Cost-Effectiveness Consideration: Despite acupuncture's high efficacy, CTAR is recommended due to its low cost and high feasibility.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Intervention Duration Variability: The duration of interventions varied significantly across studies, and the long-term benefits were not analyzed.
  • Assessment Scale Heterogeneity: Different studies used various scales to assess swallowing function, necessitating the use of standardized mean differences (SMD), which can have limitations.
  • Risk of Bias: A notable number of included studies were rated as having a high risk of bias, with issues in randomization methodology, allocation concealment, and blinding.
  • Underreporting of Safety: A significant percentage of studies did not report adverse events, making it difficult to fully assess the safety profile of all interventions.

Future research should prioritize:

  • Blinding and Allocation Concealment: Implementing robust blinding and allocation concealment in RCTs to reduce selection bias and improve reliability.
  • Standardized Outcome Measures: Using consistent and validated outcome measures for swallowing function.
  • Long-Term Follow-up: Investigating the long-term effects of different interventions.
  • Comprehensive Safety Reporting: Ensuring detailed reporting of adverse events to better understand the safety of various rehabilitation strategies.

Summary updated

Abstract

The results showed that acupuncture was the most effective in the rehabilitation of patients with post-stroke dysphagia, followed by CTAR. Considering that CTAR is a low-cost and highly feasible intervention, we suggest that CTAR should be selected as a rehabilitation measure for patients with post-stroke dysphagia to improve their swallowing function.
BibTeX
@article{zhang2024effects,
  author = {Bohan Zhang and Ka Po Wong and Cai Guo and Shu‐Cheng Chen and Shuojin Fu and Ruifu Kang and Qian Xiao and Jing Qin},
  title = {{Effects of Non‐Pharmacological Interventions on the Swallowing Function of Patients With Post‐Stroke Dysphagia: A Systematic Review and Network Meta‐Analysis}},
  journal = {Journal of Oral Rehabilitation},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1111/joor.13901},
}
Figure