Effects of NO 2 and C 3 H 6 on the heterogeneous oxidation of SO 2 on TiO 2 in the presence or absence of UV–Vis irradiation

Biwu Chu, Yali Wang, Weiwei Yang, Jinzhu Ma, Qingxin Ma, Peng Zhang, Yongchun Liu, Hong HeAtmospheric 2019 · DOI

Abstract

The heterogeneous reactions of $SO_2$ in the presence of $NO_2$ and $C_3H_6$ on $TiO_2$ were investigated using in situ diffuse reflectance infrared fourier transform spectroscopy (DRIFTS) and ion chromatography (IC). Under dark conditions, $SO_2$ reacting alone resulted in sulfite formation, while $NO_2$ promoted its oxidation to sulfate. Conversely, UV–Vis irradiation significantly enhanced $SO_2$ oxidation, but the coexistence of $NO_2$ and/or $C_3H_6$ suppressed sulfate formation. These findings highlight the competitive interactions for reactive oxygen species (ROS) and surface active sites, emphasizing the need to consider coexisting pollutants in atmospheric oxidation kinetics.

Introduction

Sulfate is a critical component of fine particulate matter ($PM_{2.5}$), significantly impacting air quality, visibility, and human health. While the oxidation of sulfur dioxide ($SO_2$) on mineral dust is a known pathway for sulfate formation, current atmospheric models often struggle to replicate observed sulfate levels during severe haze events. A primary reason for this discrepancy is the complexity of the real-world atmosphere, where $SO_2$ does not exist in isolation but alongside nitrogen oxides ($NO_x$) and volatile organic compounds (VOCs).

This study investigates the heterogeneous oxidation of $SO_2$ on Titanium Dioxide ($TiO_2$), a common photo-active component of mineral dust, exploring how $NO_2$ and propene ($C_3H_6$) influence reaction kinetics under both dark and sunlit (UV-Vis) conditions.

Experimental Methods

The researchers utilized $TiO_2$ (Degussa P25) as a model for mineral dust. The experimental setup involved exposing the powder samples to environmentally relevant concentrations (200 ppb) of $SO_2$, $NO_2$, and $C_3H_6$.

Two primary analytical techniques were employed:

  1. In situ DRIFTS: This technique allowed for the real-time monitoring of surface species and chemical bond transformations.
  2. Ion Chromatography (IC): This was used to quantify the total sulfate mass produced at the end of each experiment.

Experiments were conducted at a controlled temperature of 303 K with relative humidity (RH) kept below 1% to isolate gas-surface interactions from the influence of aqueous phase chemistry.

In situ DRIFTS spectra showing the evolution of surface species (sulfites, sulfates, nitrates) under different gas mixtures and light conditions.

Key Insights and Mechanisms

The Dark Reaction: $NO_2$ as a Promoter

Under dark conditions, the reaction of $SO_2$ alone on $TiO_2$ primarily leads to the formation of adsorbed sulfite species. However, the introduction of $NO_2$ facilitates the oxidation of these sulfites into sulfate. In this context, $NO_2$ acts as an effective oxidant, bridging the gap between $SO_2$ adsorption and stable sulfate formation.

The Sunlight Paradox: Suppression by Co-pollutants

While UV-Vis irradiation dramatically boosts the production of sulfate from $SO_2$ alone—driven by the generation of Reactive Oxygen Species (ROS) like hydroxyl radicals—the presence of $NO_2$ or $C_3H_6$ leads to a surprising inhibitory effect.

  • Propene ($C_3H_6$) as an ROS Competitor: Propene acts as an "ROS sponge." While it does not significantly block surface active sites, it effectively consumes the ROS generated by the photocatalytic activity of $TiO_2$, thereby starving the $SO_2$ oxidation pathway.
  • $NO_2$ as a Dual Threat: $NO_2$ competes with $SO_2$ on two fronts. It physically occupies active sites on the $TiO_2$ surface (forming nitrates) and also competes for available ROS.

Results and Discussion

The quantitative results from Ion Chromatography and integrated DRIFTS areas confirm these trends. As shown in the figure below, the presence of co-pollutants drastically alters the sulfate yield depending on the light conditions.

Integrated area of sulfate (1198–1135 cm⁻¹) over time, comparing dark experiments (a) where NO2 promotes formation, and UV-Vis experiments (b) where co-pollutants suppress formation.

In UV-Vis experiments, the coexistence of $NO_2$ and $C_3H_6$ together resulted in the lowest sulfate formation, reducing the yield by more than 70% compared to $SO_2$ reacting alone. This synergistic suppression suggests that in complex urban "pollution cocktails," individual oxidation pathways may be significantly slower than predicted by single-gas studies.

Conclusion

This research demonstrates that the heterogeneous oxidation of $SO_2$ is highly sensitive to the presence of other atmospheric trace gases. While $NO_2$ promotes sulfate formation in the dark, both $NO_2$ and VOCs like propene inhibit it under sunlight due to competition for surface sites and reactive oxygen species. To improve the accuracy of air quality models and haze predictions, it is essential to incorporate these multi-component competitive kinetics, moving beyond simplified single-pollutant frameworks.

Summary updated

Abstract

The heterogeneous reactions of SO2 in the presence of NO2 and C3H6 on TiO2 were investigated with the aid of in situ diffuse reflectance infrared fourier transform spectroscopy (DRIFTS) under dark conditions or with UV–Vis irradiation. Sulfate formation with or without the coexistence of NO2 and/or C3H6 was analyzed with ion chromatography (IC). Under dark conditions, SO2 reacting alone resulted in sulfite formation on TiO2, while the presence of parts per billion (ppb) levels of NO2 promoted the oxidation of SO2 to sulfate. The presence of C3H6 had little effect on sulfate formation in the heterogeneous reaction of SO2 but suppressed sulfate formation in the heterogeneous reaction of SO2 and NO2. UV–Vis irradiation could significantly enhance the heterogeneous oxidation of SO2 on TiO2, leading to copious generation of sulfate, while the coexistence of NO2 and/or C3H6 significantly suppressed sulfate formation in experiments with UV–Vis lights. Step-by-step exposure experiments indicated that C3H6 mainly competes for reactive oxygen species (ROS), while NO2 competes with SO2 for both surface active sites and ROS. Meanwhile, the coexistence of NO2 with C3H6 further resulted in less sulfate formation compared to introducing either one of them separately to the SO2–TiO2 reaction system. The results of this study highlighted the complex heterogeneous reaction processes that take place due to the ubiquitous interactions between organic and inorganic species and the need to consider the influence of coexisting volatile organic compounds (VOCs) and other inorganic gases in the heterogeneous oxidation kinetics of SO2.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{chu2019effects,
  author = {Biwu Chu and Yali Wang and Weiwei Yang and Jinzhu Ma and Qingxin Ma and Peng Zhang and Yongchun Liu and Hong He},
  title = {{Effects of NO <sub>2</sub> and C <sub>3</sub> H <sub>6</sub> on the heterogeneous oxidation of SO <sub>2</sub> on TiO <sub>2</sub> in the presence or absence of UV–Vis irradiation}},
  booktitle = {Atmospheric},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.5194/acp-19-14777-2019},
}
Figure