Effects of Mixing Ratio and Lactic Acid Bacteria Preparation on the Quality of Whole-Plant Quinoa and Whole-Plant Corn or Stevia Powder Mixed Silage

Chao He, Qian Li, Huijie Xiao, Xuchun Sun, Z.q. Gao, Cai Yuan, Shengguo ZhaoMicroorganisms 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates how mixing whole-plant quinoa with corn or stevia, and adding lactic acid bacteria (LAB) preparations, affects silage quality and safety. The findings suggest that incorporating stevia powder into quinoa silage, alongside specific LAB, significantly enhances fermentation quality, reduces harmful microbes, and lowers mycotoxin levels, making it a more beneficial feed for livestock.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Quinoa is a highly nutritious crop with great potential for animal feed, but its use in silage is underexplored. Traditional silage methods often struggle with low carbohydrate content and high moisture in certain forages, leading to poor fermentation, nutrient loss, and the proliferation of harmful microbes and mycotoxins. This research aims to optimize quinoa silage by exploring its combination with common feed ingredients like corn and stevia, and by leveraging the power of lactic acid bacteria (LAB) to improve fermentation, reduce spoilage, and enhance overall feed safety and nutritional value.

Methods

The study employed a multi-stage experimental design. Test 1 involved creating mixed silages of whole-plant quinoa (WPQ) with either whole-plant corn (WPC) at various ratios (5:5 to 10:0) or with stevia powder (SP) at different supplementation levels (0.2% to 1.0%). Test 2 focused on improving the silage quality of WPQ and WPC mixtures by adding two commercial LAB preparations, Sila-Max (Max) and Sila-Mix (Mix), to selected mixing ratios.

Key analyses included:

  • Sensory evaluation: Assessing smell, color, and texture using a standardized scoring system.
  • Fermentation analysis: Measuring pH, crude protein (CP), ammonia nitrogen (NH3-N/TN), lactic acid (LA), and acetic acid (AA).
  • Microbial enumeration: Counting aerobic bacteria and molds.
  • Mycotoxin analysis: Quantifying levels of aflatoxin B1 (AFB1), zearalenone (ZEN), deoxynivalenol (DON), ochratoxin A (OTA), and T-2 toxin using ELISA.
  • Bacterial community analysis: Employing 16S rRNA gene sequencing to characterize the microbial composition and diversity.
  • Statistical analysis: Utilizing one-way and two-way ANOVA, Tukey's multiple comparison, and fuzzy mathematics (membership function analysis) for comprehensive evaluation.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study utilized fresh plant materials (quinoa and corn) and commercial silage additives.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Stevia's Sweet Advantage: Adding stevia powder to quinoa silage significantly improved its quality compared to mixing with corn. This is likely due to stevia's sweetness enhancing palatability and providing a better substrate for beneficial microbes.
  • LAB as Fermentation Champions: Both Sila-Max and Sila-Mix preparations effectively improved silage quality by rapidly lowering pH, increasing lactic acid production, and suppressing harmful bacteria and molds.
  • The Power of Mix: The Sila-Mix preparation demonstrated a more pronounced positive effect on reducing harmful microbes and increasing beneficial bacteria like Lactobacillus, particularly at higher quinoa inclusion rates.
  • Quinoa's Mycotoxin Shield: Quinoa-based silages, especially those with stevia, showed significantly lower levels of mycotoxins, particularly AFB1, compared to corn-based silages. This suggests quinoa itself may have some protective properties or that its inclusion alters the environment to inhibit mycotoxin-producing fungi.
  • Microbial Community Shift: LAB treatments and increased quinoa proportion significantly altered the bacterial community structure, favoring beneficial Firmicutes and Lactobacillus while reducing potentially harmful Proteobacteria and Enterobacteriaceae.

Key Results

  • Optimal Stevia Addition: The membership function analysis indicated that adding 0.6% stevia powder to whole-plant quinoa silage resulted in the best overall quality.
  • LAB Impact: LAB preparations significantly reduced pH (p < 0.01) and increased lactic acid (p < 0.01) in WPQ and WPC mixed silage. They also substantially decreased mold and aerobic bacteria counts.
  • Mycotoxin Reduction: AFB1 levels in WPQ and SP mixed silage were significantly lower than in WPQ and WPC silage. Mycotoxin content generally decreased with increasing quinoa proportion.
  • Microbial Dominance: In LAB-treated silages, Lactobacillus became the dominant genus, with relative abundance significantly higher than in control groups (p < 0.05).
  • Best Overall Combination: The study concluded that a mixed silage of WPQ (≥70%) and WPC, treated with Sila-Mix, provided the best silage quality and was most beneficial for animal health.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Mycotoxin Mechanisms: While LAB preparations reduced mycotoxin levels, the precise mechanisms (e.g., direct degradation, inhibition of fungal growth) require further exploration.
  • Long-Term Effects: The study focused on 60 days of silage. Further research could investigate the long-term stability and nutritional impact of these silages.
  • Animal Trials: While the study suggests benefits for animal health, direct feeding trials would be necessary to confirm these effects and optimize dietary inclusion rates.
  • Broader Applications: Investigating the efficacy of these silage strategies with other forage types and under different environmental conditions could expand their applicability.

Summary updated

Abstract

Quinoa is the only single plant that can meet all the nutritional needs of human, and its potential for feed utilization has been continuously explored, becoming a prosperous industry for poverty alleviation. In order to further tap the feeding value of whole quinoa, develop quinoa as a feed substitute for conventional crops such as corn, and improve its comprehensive utilization rate, this experiment analyzed the silage quality and mycotoxin content of mixed silage of whole-plant quinoa (WPQ) with whole-plant corn (WPC) or stevia powder(SP) in different proportions, and further improved the silage quality of mixed silage by using two lactic acid bacteria preparations (Sila-Max and Sila-Mix). The quality, microbial population, and mycotoxin levels of quinoa and corn silage, as well as that of the mixed silage of quinoa and stevia, were evaluated using single-factor analysis of variance. The impact of various lactic acid bacteria preparations on the quality of whole-quinoa and whole-corn mixed silage was investigated through two-factor analysis of variance. WPQ and WPC were mixed at the ratio of 5:5 (QB5), 6:4 (QB6), 7:3 (QB7), 8:2 (QB8), 9:1 (QB9) and 10:0 (QB10). SP was mixed with WPQ at the supplemental levels of 0.2% (QB10S2), 0.4% (QB10S4), 0.6% (QB10S6), 0.8% (QB10S8) and 1.0% (QB10S10). After 60 days of silage, the silage indexes, the number of harmful microorganisms, and the mycotoxin levels were measured, to explore the appropriate ratio of mixed silage. The membership function analysis showed that the quality of mixed silage of WPQ with SP was better, and the optimal addition amount of SP was 0.6%. The results of Max and Mix on the quality improvement test of WPQ with WPC mixed silage showed that the two lactic acid bacteria formulations increased CP and AA content, and reduced NH<sub>3</sub>-N/TN; pH was significantly lower than the control group (<i>p</i> < 0.01), and LA was significantly higher than the control group (<i>p</i> < 0.01). The microbial count results showed that the addition of lactic acid bacteria preparation significantly reduced the number of molds and aerobic bacteria, and the effect of Mix was better than that of Max. When the mixing ratio was between QB7 and QB10, mold was not detected in the lactic-acid-bacteria preparation groups. Max and Mix significantly reduced the levels of mycotoxins, both of which were far below the range of feed safety testing, and 16S rRNA sequencing revealed that the silage microbiota varied with different mixing ratios and whether lactic acid bacteria preparations were used. Max and Mix increased the relative abundance of Firmicutes, with Mix having a more significant effect, especially in the QB6 (65.05%) and QB7 (63.61%) groups. The relative abundance of <i>Lactobacillus</i> was significantly higher than that of the control group (<i>p</i> < 0.05). The relative abundance of <i>Enterobacteriaceae</i> and <i>Streptococcus</i> were negatively and positively correlated with the addition level of quinoa, respectively. Comprehensive analysis showed that adding 0.6% SP to the WPQ and using Mix in mixed silage of WPQ and WPC with the proportion of WPQ no less than 70% had the best silage effect, and was more beneficial to animal health.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{he2025effects,
  author = {Chao He and Qian Li and Huijie Xiao and Xuchun Sun and Z.Q. GAO and Cai Yuan and Shengguo Zhao},
  title = {{Effects of Mixing Ratio and Lactic Acid Bacteria Preparation on the Quality of Whole-Plant Quinoa and Whole-Plant Corn or Stevia Powder Mixed Silage}},
  booktitle = {Microorganisms},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.3390/microorganisms13010078},
}
Figure