Abstract
Mental fatigue (MF) partly influences non-contact anterior cruciate ligament injury (NC-ACLI) biomechanics and increases risk in both maneuvers—more pronounced in stop-jump (SJ) than in single-leg landing (SL)—potentially due to MF's impact on central nervous system function, cognition, and attention. MF should be considered in NC-ACLI prevention strategies.
Introduction
Anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) injuries represent a significant burden for athletes, frequently resulting in long-term joint instability and early-onset osteoarthritis. Approximately 70% of these injuries are "non-contact," occurring during routine movements such as landing or pivoting. While physical exhaustion is a well-known risk factor, the role of mental fatigue (MF)—the cognitive drain resulting from prolonged high-intensity thinking—has been largely overlooked. This study investigates whether MF independently disrupts the neuromuscular control required for safe landings, potentially explaining why injuries often occur late in athletic competitions when players are mentally exhausted.
Methods and Materials
The study recruited 36 male college students to compare landing biomechanics before and after inducing mental fatigue.
Experimental Design
Mental fatigue was induced using a 45-minute Stroop task, a cognitive test requiring participants to name the color of a word while ignoring its semantic meaning. The presence of MF was confirmed using a Visual Analogue Scale (VAS-MF).
Data Collection and Tasks
Participants performed two high-risk maneuvers: the Stop-Jump (SJ) and the Single-Leg Landing (SL). Biomechanical data were captured using a 12-camera Vicon motion capture system for kinematics, AMTI force plates for kinetics, and surface electromyography (SEMG) for muscle activity.
Key Results and Insights
The study revealed that mental fatigue significantly alters landing mechanics, leading to a "stiffer" landing profile.
Biomechanical Alterations
- Stiff Landing Mechanics: Post-MF, participants showed reduced ankle dorsiflexion and knee flexion. This "locked" joint state prevents the body from effectively absorbing impact energy, transferring the force directly to the ACL.
- Increased Impact Forces: Peak vertical ground reaction force (vGRF) increased significantly across both maneuvers following the cognitive task.
- Knee Instability: In the stop-jump task, MF led to a significant increase in the knee abduction moment (p < 0.001). This inward collapse of the knee is a primary mechanism for ACL rupture.
Cognitive Bandwidth and Complexity
The negative effects of MF were more pronounced in the Stop-Jump than in the Single-Leg Landing. This suggests that as movement complexity increases, the brain's capacity to maintain safe mechanics under fatigue diminishes. Interestingly, muscle activation levels (RMS) remained stable, suggesting the issue lies within the Central Nervous System's (CNS) coordination rather than peripheral muscle fatigue.
Discussion and Future Directions
The findings indicate that mental fatigue is a critical, independent risk factor for ACL injuries. The "software" of the CNS appears to glitch under cognitive load, even when the muscular "hardware" is not physically exhausted.
Limitations
The study's reliance on self-reported fatigue (VAS-MF) and a male-only cohort are primary limitations. Given that female athletes are at higher risk for ACL injuries, future research must include diverse demographics and objective neurological markers like EEG.
Practical Applications
To mitigate these risks, the authors suggest implementing "cognitive-motor dual-task training." By practicing physical drills while simultaneously solving mental puzzles, athletes may better preserve safe biomechanics during the high-pressure, mentally taxing final minutes of a match.
Summary updated