Effects of Low‐Level Autonomic Stimulation on Prevention of Atrial Fibrillation Induced by Acute Electrical Remodeling

Yubi Lin, Ning Bian, Hairui Li, Jia Chen, Huijie Xing, Hongye Li, Dandan Huang, Xianwu Lan, Bojun Gong, Li Zhou, Ruijie Liu, Min Guan, Dongdong Zhang, Guo‐Qing Du, Zhengyi Huang, Xiaohong Chen, Tao Zhang, Jianyi Feng, Shaorong Wu, Liwei Wang, Aidong Zhang, Zicheng LiThe Scientific World JOURNAL 2013 · DOI

TL;DR

This study demonstrates that low-level vagosympathetic nerve stimulation (LLVNS) can effectively prevent and reverse the electrical and autonomic remodeling that leads to atrial fibrillation (AF) in dogs. By restoring a more uniform electrical substrate in the atria, LLVNS shows promise as a novel therapeutic strategy for AF.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Atrial fibrillation (AF) is a common and serious cardiac arrhythmia that significantly increases the risk of stroke and other complications. While AF is often triggered by specific events, its persistence is linked to changes in the heart's electrical properties and its autonomic nervous system (ANS) regulation, a phenomenon known as remodeling. Rapid atrial pacing (RAP) is a known method to induce this electrical and autonomic remodeling, creating an unstable electrical environment that facilitates AF. Current treatments, like catheter ablation of specific cardiac nerve clusters (ganglionated plexi or GPs), have shown some success but have limitations and debates regarding their long-term efficacy. This paper investigates whether a less invasive approach, low-level vagosympathetic nerve stimulation (LLVNS), can counteract the detrimental remodeling induced by RAP and prevent AF.

Methods

The researchers used a canine model to investigate the effects of LLVNS. Mongrel dogs were divided into two groups: one receiving RAP combined with LLVNS, and a control group receiving only RAP. Electrode catheters were implanted at various atrial sites to record electrical activity.

  • Rapid Atrial Pacing (RAP): Dogs in both groups underwent RAP for three hours to induce electrical and autonomic remodeling.
  • Low-Level Vagosympathetic Nerve Stimulation (LLVNS): In the experimental group, LLVNS was applied to the cervical vagosympathetic trunks. The stimulation voltage was carefully calibrated to be 50% below the threshold that would significantly slow the heart rate (by no more than 30 milliseconds). This ensured the stimulation was "low-level" and unlikely to cause significant adverse effects on heart rate.
  • Electrophysiological Measurements: Key parameters measured included:
  • Effective Refractory Period (ERP): The minimum time required for a cardiac cell to repolarize after a stimulus, making it unresponsive to another stimulus. Shorter ERPs can contribute to AF.
  • Window of Vulnerability (WOV): The period during the cardiac cycle when the heart is most susceptible to developing arrhythmias. A wider WOV increases AF risk.
  • ERP Dispersion: The variation in ERP across different atrial sites. High dispersion indicates an unstable electrical substrate.
  • Recovery Time (RT): The time it takes for the heart to return to a normal sinus rhythm after AF has been induced.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study utilized an in vivo animal model (mongrel dogs) for experimental purposes.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • LLVNS as an Anti-Arrhythmic Paradox: While strong vagal stimulation can promote AF, this study highlights that low-level stimulation has the opposite effect, acting as an antiarrhythmic. This suggests a nuanced role for the vagus nerve in cardiac electrophysiology.
  • Reversing Remodeling: The core finding is that LLVNS can effectively reverse the detrimental changes (decreased ERP, increased WOV, and dispersion) induced by RAP. This implies that LLVNS can "reset" the electrical environment of the atria.
  • Homogenizing the Electrical Substrate: A key mechanism proposed is that LLVNS abolishes the electrical gradients between different atrial regions, particularly around the ganglionated plexi (GPs). This creates a more uniform electrical substrate, making it less prone to developing AF.
  • Targeting Autonomic Imbalance: The study reinforces the critical role of the autonomic nervous system, especially the intrinsic cardiac nervous system (ganglionated plexi), in AF pathogenesis. LLVNS appears to modulate this system beneficially.

Key Results

  • RAP Induces Heterogeneity: RAP significantly decreased ERP and increased WOV across various atrial sites, leading to significant ERP dispersion and gradients, particularly around the ganglionated plexi (GPs). This created an unstable electrical substrate.
  • LLVNS Reverses RAP Effects: In the LLVNS+RAP group, these detrimental changes were reversed. ERP and WOV returned to baseline levels, and ERP dispersion and gradients were abolished, indicating a more homogeneous electrical substrate.
  • Reduced AF Recurrence: The recovery time from AF was significantly prolonged in the RAP-only group, indicating a greater propensity for sustained AF. In contrast, the LLVNS+RAP group showed no significant difference in recovery time from baseline, suggesting LLVNS prevented sustained AF.
  • Threshold Voltage Matters: The study emphasized the importance of using LLVNS at a voltage significantly below the threshold for slowing sinus rate, demonstrating that this approach did not induce AF and indeed had antiarrhythmic effects.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Acute Model: The study used an acute model of electrical remodeling induced by RAP. The long-term effects of LLVNS on chronic AF models were not investigated.
  • Direct Neural Firing Evidence: The study did not provide direct evidence of LLVNS inhibiting neuronal firing within the ganglionated plexi (GPs) and the ligament of Marshall (MSL).
  • Optimal Parameters: Future research is needed to determine the optimal parameters (voltage, frequency, duration) and sites for LLVNS to achieve maximum AF inhibition with minimal side effects.
  • Chronic AF Treatment: The authors hope to devise future treatment methods for chronic AF using autonomic nerve stimulators, potentially through non-invasive methods.
  • Mechanism Elucidation: Further studies are required to integrate and explain the various proposed mechanisms of LLVNS action, including its effects on nitric oxide pathways, neuropeptides, and autonomic receptors.

Summary updated

Abstract

Mongrel dogs were divided into (LLVNS+RAP) and RAP groups. Electrode catheters were sutured to multiple atrial sites, and LLVNS was applied to cervical vagosympathetic trunks with voltage 50% below the threshold slowing sinus rate by ≤ 30 msec. RAP induced a significant decrease in effective refractory period (ERP) and increase in the window of vulnerability at all sites, characterized by descending and elevated gradient differences towards the ganglionic plexi (GP) sites, respectively. The ERP dispersion was obviously enlarged by RAP and more significant when the ERP of GP-related sites was considered. Recovery time from AF was also prolonged significantly as a result of RAP. LLVNS could reverse all these changes induced by RAP and recover the heterogeneous substrate to baseline. Conclusions. LLVNS can reverse the electrical and autonomic remodeling and abolish the GP-central gradient differences induced by RAP, and thus it can recover the homogeneous substrate, which may be the underlying mechanism of its antiarrhythmic effect.
BibTeX
@article{lin2013effects,
  author = {Yubi Lin and Ning Bian and Hairui Li and Jia Chen and Huijie Xing and Hongye Li and Dandan Huang and Xianwu Lan and Bojun Gong and Li Zhou and Ruijie Liu and Min Guan and Dongdong Zhang and Guo‐Qing Du and Zhengyi Huang and Xiaohong Chen and Tao Zhang and Jianyi Feng and Shaorong Wu and Liwei Wang and Aidong Zhang and Zicheng Li},
  title = {{Effects of Low‐Level Autonomic Stimulation on Prevention of Atrial Fibrillation Induced by Acute Electrical Remodeling}},
  journal = {The Scientific World JOURNAL},
  year = {2013},
  doi = {10.1155/2013/781084},
}

Loading related content...

Figure