Effects of irrigation regimes on soil NO3--N, electrical conductivity and crop yield in plastic greenhouse

Tingting Chang, Yujie Zhang, Zhanyu Zhang, Xiaohou Shao, Weina Wang, Jie Zhang, Xu Yang, Hui-lian XuInternational Journal of Agricultural and Biological Engineering 2019 · DOI

TL;DR

Researchers have identified a "Goldilocks" irrigation strategy for greenhouse tomatoes that balances high yields with water conservation and soil health. By using subsurface drainage and applying smaller amounts of water more frequently, farmers can effectively flush out harmful salts and nitrates while maintaining fruit quality and water-use efficiency.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Greenhouse cultivation is a powerhouse of modern agriculture, but it comes with a hidden cost: secondary soil salinization. Because greenhouses are protected from natural rainfall, salts and nitrates (from fertilizers) accumulate in the topsoil rather than being washed away. This buildup eventually poisons the soil, reduces crop yields, and can lead to groundwater pollution.

In Eastern China, where water is scarce and greenhouse farming is intensive, finding an irrigation regime that saves water while managing soil salinity is a critical challenge. The authors sought to determine the optimal "dosage" and "frequency" of drip irrigation to keep soil healthy without sacrificing the bottom line.

Methods

The researchers conducted a field study in a plastic greenhouse in Nanjing, China, using a combination of drip irrigation and a subsurface drainage system (corrugated plastic pipes buried 0.7m deep).

They tested six different irrigation treatments (T1–T6) plus a control (CK) across one growing season. The variables were:

  • Total Irrigation Amount: Low (310 mm), Average (360 mm), and High (410 mm).
  • Frequency: 7 times vs. 11 times during the growth cycle.
  • Drainage: The control (CK) used the average water amount (360 mm) but without the subsurface drainage system.

The team monitored soil volumetric moisture, electrical conductivity (EC) to measure salinity, and nitrate-nitrogen ($NO_3^-$-N) levels, alongside tomato yield and fruit quality metrics like Vitamin C and sugar content.

Datasets

As a field experiment, the study generated its own primary data. Key data points included:

  • Soil Properties: Baseline pH, density, and nutrient levels of the experimental site.
  • Elution Rates: Calculations of how effectively salts and nitrates were "washed" out of the soil profile.
  • Crop Metrics: Per-fruit weight, total yield ($kg/hm^2$), and chemical composition of the tomatoes.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The EC-Nitrate Proxy: The study found a strong positive correlation ($R^2 = 0.864$) between soil nitrate levels and electrical conductivity (EC). This suggests that farmers could potentially use simple EC sensors as a real-time proxy to estimate nitrate accumulation in the soil.
  • Frequency is a Force Multiplier: For the same total amount of water, increasing the frequency of irrigation (from 7 to 11 times) significantly improved both fruit yield and Irrigation Water Use Efficiency (IWUE). Smaller, more frequent "sips" are better for the plant than occasional "gulps."
  • The Quality-Quantity Trade-off: While more water led to higher total yields and larger fruit, it negatively impacted fruit quality. Tomatoes grown with less water had higher concentrations of Vitamin C and soluble sugars. This confirms that a bit of "water stress" can actually make a tomato taste better.
  • Drainage is Non-Negotiable: The subsurface drainage system was vital. Even with the same irrigation amount, the plots with drainage (T3) had significantly lower soil salinity and higher nitrate elution than the control plot without drainage (CK).

Key Results

  • Highest Yield: Treatment T6 (410 mm, 11 times) produced the highest yield at 51,154 kg/hm².
  • Optimal Efficiency: The researchers recommended a regime of 310 mm total water applied over 11 intervals (noted as T2 in the data tables, though the conclusion text contains a minor typo labeling this as T4) as the best compromise for balancing salinity control, water saving, and yield.
  • Salinity Reduction: Higher irrigation amounts significantly increased the elution rate of salts. For example, the high-water treatments (T5, T6) achieved EC elution rates of over 43%, compared to only 18.9% for the low-water treatment (T1).

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge a few constraints:

  • Temporal Scope: The study only covered one growing season (2014). Long-term effects of these regimes over multiple years remain to be seen.
  • Geographic Specificity: The results are specific to the Alfisoils of Eastern China. Different soil textures (like sandy or heavy clay soils) would likely respond differently to these drainage and irrigation parameters.
  • Environmental Variables: The study did not deeply explore the impact of varying external climate conditions or different water qualities (e.g., using brackish water for irrigation).

Future research could focus on automating these irrigation regimes using the EC-Nitrate correlation to create "smart" greenhouse systems that respond dynamically to soil health.

Summary updated

Abstract

Developing water-saving irrigation regimes has important practical significance not only in alleviating the crucial water shortage, but also in controlling soil salinization for the protected cultivation in eastern China. A field study with six treatments was conducted to evaluate the effects of different irrigation regimes with subdrainage systems on the soil nitrate nitrogen, salinity and moisture, also evaluate the effects on tomato growth, fruit yield and irrigation water use efficiency (IWUE). The treatments were distinguished by three different irrigation amounts of 310 mm, 360 mm and 410 mm, and two irrigation frequencies of 7 and 11 times. Results showed that the irrigation amount had significant effects on the soil NO3--N and electric conductivity (EC). A positive correlation was detected between soil NO3--N (x) and EC (y) at 0-20 m depth after harvest, with a linear equation of y = 0.063x – 0.670. Soil volumetric moisture at 0.10 m and 0.20 m depth was increased as the irrigation amount increased. Moreover, a higher amount of irrigation increased the fruit yield but reduced the IWUE of tomato. It was also found that smaller irrigation amounts combined with frequent intervals could increase fruit yield and IWUE. However, the fruit quality of tomato had a significant (p<0.05) negative correlation with irrigation amount. Therefore, the parameters of irrigation regime including the irrigation amount and intervals should be considered comprehensively in order to find a compromise between salinity control and irrigation water use efficiency improvement. Keywords: irrigation regimes, greenhouse, tomato, soil nitrate nitrogen, soil electric conductivity, soil salinity, water use efficiency DOI: 10.25165/j.ijabe.20191201.3022 Citation: Chang T T, Zhang Y J, Zhang Z Y, Shao X H, Wang W N, Zhang J, et al. Effects of irrigation regimes on soil NO3--N, electrical conductivity and crop yield in plastic greenhouse. Int J Agric & Biol Eng, 2019; 12(1): 109–115.
BibTeX
@article{chang2019effects,
  author = {Tingting Chang and Yujie Zhang and Zhanyu Zhang and Xiaohou Shao and Weina Wang and Jie Zhang and Xu Yang and Hui-lian Xu},
  title = {{Effects of irrigation regimes on soil NO3--N, electrical conductivity and crop yield in plastic greenhouse}},
  journal = {International Journal of Agricultural and Biological Engineering},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.25165/j.ijabe.20191201.3022},
}
Figure