Effects of irrigation-fertilization-tillage on nutrient loading and crop yield in Ulansuhai watershed based on improved SWAT model

Weigang Wang, Haibin Shi, Xianyue Li, Yanan Sun, Zhang Wen-cong, Hui ZhouJournal of Lake Sciences 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

Researchers have developed an enhanced version of the SWAT (Soil and Water Assessment Tool) model specifically tailored for arid irrigation districts to tackle the growing crisis of agricultural pollution in China's Lake Ulansuhai. By optimizing irrigation, fertilization, and tillage practices, the study demonstrates that it is possible to significantly reduce nutrient runoff while simultaneously boosting crop yields by up to 36%.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Lake Ulansuhai, a vital ecological barrier in northern China, is suffering from severe eutrophication and ecological degradation. The primary culprit is "non-point source pollution"—excess nitrogen and phosphorus from the surrounding Hetao Irrigation District leaching into the water.

Standard hydrological models often struggle to accurately simulate these environments because arid regions with shallow groundwater have unique dynamics, such as salt stress on crops and significant upward capillary action from the water table. The authors sought to bridge this gap by refining the SWAT model to better reflect these local realities, providing a tool that can predict how different farming "scenarios" affect both the environment and the farmer's bottom line.

Methods

The authors modified the SWAT 2012 source code to create a more robust version for arid, salt-affected regions. Key technical improvements include:

  • Soil Water & Solute Balance: Added subroutines to calculate the upward capillary rise of water and salt from shallow groundwater into the soil layers.
  • Salt Stress Module: Introduced a salt stress factor ($stress_{sw}$) that limits plant transpiration and growth based on soil salinity.
  • Groundwater Dynamics: Improved the groundwater balance equations to better account for the interaction between irrigation, deep percolation, and the shallow water table.
  • Scenario Modeling: They simulated 18 irrigation levels, 12 fertilization levels, and 4 tillage methods (No-tillage, Reduced tillage, Conventional tillage, and Template plowing) across three major crops: corn, sunflowers, and wheat.

Datasets

The model was calibrated and validated using a comprehensive 10-year dataset (2009–2018) from the Ulansuhai watershed:

  • Hydrological/Chemical Data: Monthly runoff, nitrate nitrogen (NN), and total phosphorus (TP) from the Hongge’erbu pumping station.
  • Geospatial Data: 30m resolution Digital Elevation Models (DEM), soil type maps (1:1,000,000), and Land Use/Cover data.
  • Agricultural Data: Field-level data on crop yields, irrigation schedules, and fertilization rates for corn, sunflowers, and wheat.
  • Meteorological Data: Daily precipitation, temperature, solar radiation, and wind speed from local weather stations.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Less is More" Irrigation Paradox: Surprisingly, reducing summer irrigation by 5% actually increased yields for all three crops. This suggests that current practices may be over-irrigating, leading to oxygen stress in roots or excessive nutrient leaching.
  • The Fertilization "Sweet Spot": Nutrient loading decreases linearly as fertilizer use drops, but crop yields follow a parabolic curve. There is a clear threshold—20% reduction for corn/wheat and 25% for sunflowers—beyond which yields begin to decline sharply.
  • Tillage is Crop-Specific: Increasing tillage depth and efficiency (e.g., moving from no-till to template plowing) reduced nutrient loading across the board. However, while corn and sunflowers yielded better with more intensive tillage, wheat performed best under no-tillage conditions.
  • Autumn Watering Matters: Reducing "autumn irrigation" (a common practice in the region to leach salts before winter) by 10% was the most effective single lever for reducing total nitrogen and phosphorus loads.

Key Results

  • Corn: The "Golden Combo" (5% less summer irrigation + 20% less fertilizer + template plowing) increased yields by 36.5%.
  • Sunflowers: The best environmental scenario (10% less autumn irrigation + 25% less fertilizer + template plowing) slashed nitrate nitrogen loading by 42.1%.
  • Wheat: A combination of 5% less summer irrigation, 20% less fertilizer, and no-tillage increased yields by 29.1%.
  • Model Accuracy: The improved SWAT model achieved high Nash-Sutcliffe Efficiency ($E_{ns}$) values (0.55 to 0.93) and high $R^2$ values (0.63 to 0.94) across runoff, nutrient, and yield simulations, proving its reliability for the region.

Limitations and Future Work

While the improved SWAT model is a significant step forward, the authors note a few areas for improvement:

  • Groundwater Complexity: The model still relies on simplified HRU (Hydrologic Response Unit) calculations for groundwater. Future work could involve coupling the model with MODFLOW for more precise 3D groundwater flow modeling.
  • Spatial Resolution: The study uses a 30m resolution for land use, but agricultural management often happens at a much finer, individual-plot scale.
  • Socio-Economic Factors: The study focuses on biophysical yields and pollution; future research should integrate the economic costs of changing tillage equipment or fertilizer types to ensure these "optimal" scenarios are actually feasible for local farmers.

Summary updated

Abstract

不合理的灌溉、施肥和耕作是导致乌梁素海流域农业面源污染的主要根源,乌梁素海作为我国北方地区重要的生态安全屏障,多年来面临着湖泊水环境污染、水生态退化等问题,科学开展湖泊水环境综合治理首先要解决流域内农业面源污染问题. 研究通过修改土壤水平衡、溶质平衡、地下水平衡和作物生长等模块对SWAT 2012原始版本进行改进,并采用改进的SWAT模型构建了乌梁素海流域分布式水文模型,利用实测径流、硝态氮与总磷排放量、地下水埋深以及作物产量校正和验证模型. 基于现状情景,以玉米、葵花和小麦3种主要作物为研究对象,设置了削减灌水量、施肥量及调整耕作方式3种农田管理情景. 基于改进SWAT模型不同情景的模拟结果,计算分析各管理情景下的硝态氮与总磷负荷及对各作物产量的影响. 结果表明,改进SWAT模型具有良好的模拟效果. 不同作物削减5%夏灌水量增产最多达8.41%~10.32%,削减10%秋浇水量均明显减少硝态氮和总磷负荷. 不同作物营养物负荷均随着氮磷施肥削减比例的增大呈现逐渐降低的趋势,但下降曲线逐渐趋于平缓; 各作物产量随氮磷施肥削减比例的增加呈先增加后减少的趋势,其中玉米、小麦氮磷施肥削减比例达20%时产量开始下降,葵花氮磷施肥削减比例达25%时产量开始下降. 不同作物营养物负荷与小麦产量均随耕作方式混合深度与混合效率参数的增大逐渐减小,而玉米和葵花产量则随耕作参数增大逐渐增加. 综合分析,削减5%夏灌水量+削减20%氮磷施肥比例+模板犁耕作组合玉米产量增幅最大达36.5%;削减10%秋浇水量+削减25%氮磷施肥比例+模板犁耕作组合葵花硝态氮负荷降幅最大达42.1%;削减5%夏灌水量+削减20%氮磷施肥比例+免耕组合小麦产量增幅最大达29.1%;而削减5%秋浇水量+削减20%氮磷施肥比例+常规春耕组合小麦硝态氮负荷减少最大达27.2%,总磷负荷减少最大达18.5%. 本研究可为降低流域内面源污染、提高作物产量及减少乌梁素海营养物入湖负荷农业管理措施的实施提供理论依据.;Irrational irrigation, fertilization and farming are the main causes of agricultural non-point source pollution in Ulansuhai watershed. As an important ecological security barrier in northern China, Lake Ulansuhai has been facing problems, such as lake water environment pollution and water ecological degradation. To achieve the integrated management of lake water environment, agricultural non-point source pollution in the watershed must be controlled. The study improved the original version of SWAT 2012 by modifying the modules of soil water balance, solute balance, groundwater balance, and plant growth. A distributed hydrological model of Ulansuhai watershed was constructed with the improved SWAT model, which was calibrated and validated with measured runoff, nitrate nitrogen (NN), total phosphorus (TP) emissions, groundwater depth and crop yield. Three scenarios including reduced amount of irrigation, fertilization, and adjusted farming mode based on the current situation were applied on three main crops (corn, sunflower and wheat). NN and TP loadings and their effects on the crop yields under different management scenarios were simulated using the improved SWAT model. The results showed that the improved SWAT model has a good simulation fitting. For different crops, reducing the irrigation amount by 5% in summer can increase production by up to 8.41%-10.32%, and reducing 10% irrigation in autumn will significantly reduce the NN and TP loadings. The nutrient load of different crops showed a decreasing trend with an increasing reduction ratio of nitrogen and phosphorus fertilization (NPF), but the declining rate gradually became smaller. The yields of different crops increased first and then decreased with the ratio of NPF increase. When the ratio of NPF reduction reached 20%, the yield of corn and wheat began to decline, and when it reached 25% the yield of sunflower began to decline. The nutrient loads and wheat yield of different crops gradually decreased with an increase of the mixing depth and efficiency of the tillage mode, while the yield of corn and sunflower gradually increased with the tillage parameters. If combining cutting 5% of summer irrigation, reducing 20% NPF amount, and the template plowing combination, corn yield could increase by 36.5%. If cutting 10% of autumn watering, reducing 25% NPF, the template plowing combination, sunflower nitrate nitrogen load could reduce by 42.1%. If cutting 5% of summer irrigation, 20% reduction NPF, and no-tillage combination, wheat yield could increase by 29.1%. However, cutting 5% of autumn watering, 20% reduction NPF and conventional spring ploughing combination, NN loading of wheat farming could reduce by up to 27.2%, and TP loading could reduce by up to 18.5%. This research can provide a scientific basis for the implementation of agricultural management measures to reduce non-point source pollution, increase crop yields in Ulansuhai watershed and reduce the nutrients loads in Lake Ulansuhai.
BibTeX
@article{wang2022effects,
  author = {Weigang Wang and Haibin Shi and Xianyue Li and Yanan Sun and Zhang Wen-cong and Hui Zhou},
  title = {{Effects of irrigation-fertilization-tillage on nutrient loading and crop yield in Ulansuhai watershed based on improved SWAT model}},
  journal = {Journal of Lake Sciences},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.18307/2022.0508},
}
Figure