Effects of Investigational Moisturizers on the Skin Barrier and Microbiome following Exposure to Environmental Aggressors: A Randomized Clinical Trial and Ex Vivo Analysis

Danqi Wang, Zhiheng Li, Ruyi Zhang, Chao Yuan, Bo Yan, Philippe Humbert, Zhe‐Xue QuanJournal of Clinical Medicine 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigated how three different moisturizers affect skin barrier function and the skin microbiome when exposed to real-world environmental stressors. Moisturizer K, a water gel with kiwi-derived yeast extract, showed the most promising results, not only improving skin hydration and barrier function but also positively influencing the skin's microbial community and protecting against pollution-induced damage.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The skin acts as our primary defense against a barrage of environmental aggressors, from UV radiation and pollution to fluctuating temperatures and humidity. These external factors can compromise the skin's physical, chemical, and immunological barriers, leading to dryness, irritation, and potentially more serious skin conditions. While we understand that the skin's microbial community (microbiome) plays a crucial role in maintaining skin health, the complex interplay between environmental stressors, skincare products, and the microbiome is not fully understood. Specifically, there's a need to identify skincare interventions that can holistically support the skin's defenses against these daily assaults, particularly in urban environments where pollution is a significant concern.

Methods

The researchers conducted a multi-faceted study combining a randomized clinical trial with ex vivo skin explant analysis.

  • Randomized Clinical Trial: 110 participants with self-assessed dry facial skin were enrolled in an 8-week, triple-blind, placebo-controlled trial. They applied one of three investigational moisturizers (Moisturizer K: water gel with yeast extract; Moisturizer C: water gel; Moisturizer L: thick emulsion cream) to their faces daily. Skin hydration, barrier function (measured by transepidermal water loss - TEWL, and the TEWL/moisture ratio), and translucency were assessed at various time points. Skin microbiome samples were collected from the forehead (treated area) and upper chest (untreated control) at baseline, 4 weeks, and 8 weeks.
  • Ex Vivo Skin Explant Analysis: Skin biopsies from three Caucasian women were exposed to simulated urban summer environmental conditions (heat, humidity, UV, and air pollution). These explants were then treated with the three moisturizers, and their response was analyzed by measuring levels of key biomarkers related to skin barrier function (caspase 14), structural components (collagen I, elastin), and inflammation/pollution response (aryl hydrocarbon receptor - AHR, interleukin-6 - IL-6).

Datasets

  • Clinical Trial Data: Data collected from 110 participants over an 8-week period, including measurements of skin hydration, barrier function, and translucency.
  • Microbiome Data: 16S rRNA gene sequencing data from skin swabs of 97 participants, generating over 10 million bacterial reads and nearly 9 million fungal reads. This data was used to analyze microbial diversity and composition.
  • Ex Vivo Biomarker Data: Immunostaining and fluorescence intensity measurements from treated and untreated skin explants.
  • Environmental Data: Daily temperature, humidity, wind, UV, and air quality (PM2.5, PM10) data for Shanghai during the study period.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Holistic Barrier Support: The study highlights that effective skincare should not only focus on physical barrier repair but also consider the skin's microbiome and its interaction with environmental factors.
  • Postbiotic Power: The inclusion of a kiwi-derived yeast extract (postbiotic technology) in Moisturizer K appears to be a key differentiator, contributing to its superior performance.
  • Urban Environment Challenge: The research directly addresses the impact of common urban environmental aggressors on skin health and the microbiome.
  • Microbiome Resilience: Environmental stressors can negatively impact the skin's microbial diversity. Certain moisturizers, particularly Moisturizer K, can help maintain this diversity.
  • Pollution Defense: Moisturizers can offer protection against the detrimental effects of air pollutants, as evidenced by changes in AHR levels in the ex vivo study.

Key Results

  • Clinical Efficacy: All three moisturizers were well-tolerated and improved skin hydration and barrier function from baseline. Moisturizer K showed a more significant and sustained improvement in skin hydration and translucency compared to Moisturizer L.
  • Microbiome Maintenance: In the presence of environmental aggressors, untreated skin showed a decrease in bacterial and fungal richness. Moisturizer K prevented this decline, maintaining microbial diversity.
  • Beneficial Bacteria Boost: Moisturizer K treatment led to an increase in the relative abundance of beneficial commensal bacteria like Staphylococcus epidermidis and Ralstonia.
  • Ex Vivo Protection: Moisturizer K-treated skin explants showed:
  • Higher levels of caspase 14 (indicating improved barrier function).
  • Higher levels of collagen I and elastin (structural components).
  • Lower levels of AHR (implying reduced response to air pollutants).
  • Lower levels of IL-6 (indicating reduced inflammation).

Limitations and Future Work

  • Body Site Control: The study used the upper chest as a control site for the forehead, which might have inherent differences in microbiome composition and response to environmental factors. Future studies could use a split-face design or more controlled environmental chambers.
  • Ex Vivo Sample Size: The ex vivo study used skin explants from only three individuals. Larger and more diverse sample sets would strengthen these findings.
  • Mechanistic Exploration: While the study demonstrates the effects of moisturizers on the skin microbiome and biomarkers, further research is needed to fully elucidate the precise mechanisms by which these products interact with the skin's chemical and immune barriers against environmental aggressors.
  • Long-Term Effects: The study focused on an 8-week period. Investigating the long-term effects of these moisturizers and their impact on skin health and microbiome over extended periods would be valuable.

Summary updated

Abstract

The skin microbiota barrier participates in skin barrier function in addition to the physical, chemical, and immunological protective barriers, and is affected by environmental aggressors and skincare regimens. To better understand the exact effects of real-life environmental conditions on the skin and determine the protective methods, this study investigates the effects of three topical cosmetic moisturizers (water gel moisturizers with/without yeast extract (Moisturizers K and C) and a thick-emulsion cream moisturizer (Moisturizer L)) on clinical and skin microbiome endpoints in the presence of environmental aggressors during an 8-week, randomized controlled, triple-blind clinical trial with 110 participants, and molecular- as well as biomarker-level endpoints on ex vivo skin explants after exposure to simulate urban environmental conditions. The results show that all moisturizers are well-tolerated and improve skin barrier function and surface moisture content from the baseline, and the improvement is maintained at the last analysis point (3 days after trial completion). Compared with the untreated control areas (samples taken from the upper chest), treatment with Moisturizer K prevented a reduction in bacterial and fungal richness, and increased the change ratio of the relative abundance of commensal bacteria, such as <i>Staphylococcus epidermidis</i> and <i>Ralstonia</i>, at the treated sites (samples taken from the forehead). Moreover, Moisturizer K-treated ex vivo skin explants had higher levels of caspase 14 (a marker of skin barrier function), collagen I, and elastin (structure components), and lower levels of aryl hydrocarbon receptor (AHR; activated by air pollutants) and interleukin-6 (IL-6) than those in explants treated with other moisturizers and in the untreated areas of the skin. These results suggest that a skin postbiotic moisturizer with yeast extract supports the regulation of the skin's microbiome balance and may provide a holistic barrier (involving skin microbiome, physical, chemical, and immune barriers) to protect the skin against environmental aggressors.
BibTeX
@article{wang2023effects,
  author = {Danqi Wang and Zhiheng Li and Ruyi Zhang and Chao Yuan and Bo Yan and Philippe Humbert and Zhe‐Xue Quan},
  title = {{Effects of Investigational Moisturizers on the Skin Barrier and Microbiome following Exposure to Environmental Aggressors: A Randomized Clinical Trial and Ex Vivo Analysis}},
  journal = {Journal of Clinical Medicine},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3390/jcm12186078},
}
Figure