Effects of Gap Resonance on the Hydrodynamics and Dynamics of a Multi-Module Floating System with Narrow Gaps

Mingsheng Chen, Hongrui Guo, Rong Wang, Ran Tao, Ning ChengJournal of Marine Science and Engineering 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper investigates the complex hydrodynamic interactions and "gap resonance" phenomena in multi-module floating systems with narrow gaps. By introducing artificial damping into a potential flow model, the researchers significantly improve the accuracy of both frequency and time-domain simulations, leading to more reliable predictions of system dynamics and connector loads.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

As ocean space utilization grows, multi-module floating systems (like floating airports or mobile offshore bases) are becoming increasingly common. These systems, composed of multiple floating bodies placed very close together, experience significant hydrodynamic interactions. A key challenge is "gap resonance," where waves trapped in the narrow spaces between modules can lead to amplified motions and forces, especially at specific frequencies. Traditional potential flow models, which ignore fluid viscosity, struggle to accurately capture these resonant phenomena, often overestimating wave elevations and leading to unrealistic damping in simulations. This inaccuracy can compromise the reliability of dynamic analyses and the design of connectors between modules.

Methods

The study employs ANSYS-AQWA, a well-established hydrodynamics software package, to model the multi-module floating system. The core of their approach involves:

  • Potential Flow Theory: This forms the basis of the hydrodynamic analysis, treating the fluid as inviscid and irrotational.
  • Frequency-Domain Simulations: Used to calculate hydrodynamic coefficients (added mass and damping) and wave excitation forces.
  • Time-Domain Simulations (Cummins Equation): This hybrid approach allows for the analysis of nonlinear dynamics, crucial for systems with mooring and connector elements.
  • Artificial Damping Lid Method: This is the key innovation. By introducing an artificial damping term on the free surface within the gaps, the model simulates viscous effects and suppresses unrealistic resonant phenomena that arise from the potential flow assumption. This method is applied in both frequency and time-domain analyses.
  • Rigid-Module-Flexible-Connector (RMFC) Model: A simplified model is used to represent the connections between modules, allowing for the analysis of cable and fender forces.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on numerical simulations based on defined parameters for the floating modules and environmental conditions.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Gap Resonance is a Major Factor: The narrow gaps between modules are critical, leading to amplified responses and distinct resonance frequencies that differ from single-body behavior.
  • Potential Flow Limitations: Without accounting for viscosity, potential flow models can produce highly exaggerated resonant peaks in hydrodynamic coefficients and impulse response functions, leading to unstable time-domain simulations.
  • Artificial Damping is Crucial: Introducing artificial damping effectively "damps" these unrealistic resonances, making the hydrodynamic coefficients more moderate and the impulse response functions decay more rapidly.
  • Improved Time-Domain Accuracy: The artificial damping method is essential for achieving converged and accurate time-domain simulations, especially near resonant frequencies. It bridges the gap between frequency-domain predictions and realistic dynamic behavior.
  • Shielding Effects: Modules positioned further back in a series arrangement experience reduced hydrodynamic interactions due to the shielding effect of preceding modules.

Key Results

  • Resonance Frequency Prediction: The study accurately predicts resonance frequencies for narrow gaps, showing good agreement between a modified theoretical equation and numerical results.
  • Hydrodynamic Coefficients: The introduction of artificial damping significantly reduces the extreme peaks in added damping coefficients (by up to 70% at resonance) and moderates the added mass coefficients.
  • Time-Domain Convergence: Without artificial damping, time-domain simulations become unstable and diverge, particularly near resonant frequencies. With artificial damping, these simulations converge and become more accurate.
  • Motion Reduction: For an artificial damping ratio of 0.2, relative heave and pitch motions were reduced by 33% and 50%, respectively.
  • Connector Load Reduction: Maximum cable and fender forces were reduced by approximately 50% with artificial damping compared to the uncorrected case.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Preliminary Analysis of Damping Value: The study presents a preliminary analysis of artificial damping. The authors recommend that the optimal artificial damping value should be determined through more rigorous CFD or physical model tests for more accurate simulations.
  • Generalizability of Damping Value: While the study shows that the variation of the artificial damping ratio has a limited impact on connector loads and relative motions, further investigation is needed to confirm this across a wider range of conditions.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest future studies should focus on in-depth analysis to determine the optimal artificial damping values and explore the application of this method to more complex multi-module floating systems and irregular wave conditions.

Summary updated

Abstract

Multi-module floating system has attracted much attention in recent years as ocean space utilization becomes more demanding. This type of structural system has potential applications in the design and construction of floating piers, floating airports and Mobile Offshore Bases (MOBs) generally consists of multiple modules with narrow gaps in which hydrodynamic interactions play a non-neglected role. This study considers a numerical model consisting of several rectangular modules to study the hydrodynamics and dynamics of the multi-module floating system subjected to the waves. Based on ANSYS-AQWA, both frequency-domain and time-domain simulations are performed to analyze the complex multi-body hydrodynamic interactions by introducing artificial damping on the gap surfaces. Parametric studies are carried out to investigate the effects of the gap width, shielding effects of the multi-body system, artificial damping ratio on the gap surface, and the dependency of the hydrodynamic interaction effect on wave headings is clarified. Based on the results, it is found that the numerical analysis based on the potential flow theory with artificial damping introduced can produce accurate results for the normal wave period range. In addition, the effects of artificial damping on the dynamics and connector loads are investigated by using a simplified RMFC model. For the case of adding an artificial damping ratio of 0.2, the relative heave and pitch motions are found to be reduced by 33% and 50%, respectively. In addition, the maximum cable and fender forces are found to be reduced by 50%, compared with the case without viscosity correction.
BibTeX
@article{chen2021effects,
  author = {Mingsheng Chen and Hongrui Guo and Rong Wang and Ran Tao and Ning Cheng},
  title = {{Effects of Gap Resonance on the Hydrodynamics and Dynamics of a Multi-Module Floating System with Narrow Gaps}},
  journal = {Journal of Marine Science and Engineering},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.3390/jmse9111256},
}
Figure