Effects of full problem based learning of dental students on self-directed learning, communication, and problem solving abilities

Kangwook Lee, Jin-Sil Hong, Kee-Wan ChangJournal of Korean Academy of Oral Health 2016 · DOI

Abstract

This study evaluates the impact of a "full" Problem-Based Learning (PBL) curriculum on dental students' core competencies: self-directed learning (SDL), communication, and problem-solving abilities. Comparing 39 students in an experimental PBL group with 68 students in a traditional lecture-based control group over three semesters, the study found that while PBL initially boosts SDL and problem-solving skills, these benefits tend to peak at the one-year mark. Notably, communication abilities decreased across both groups over time. The findings suggest that while PBL has significant educational benefits, a hybrid model combining PBL with expert-led lectures may be more sustainable for long-term dental education.

Introduction

Traditional dental education has long relied on didactic, lecture-based "block" learning. While effective for transmitting vast amounts of clinical knowledge, this approach often fails to foster the "soft skills" essential for modern clinicians: self-directed learning (SDL), effective communication, and adaptive problem-solving. Problem-Based Learning (PBL) was designed to bridge this gap by placing students in active, collaborative roles. However, most existing research on PBL is short-term, often limited to a single course. This study addresses the lack of longitudinal data by comparing a "full" PBL curriculum—where 16 major dental subjects are integrated into a single framework without traditional lectures—against a traditional curriculum over an 18-month period.

Methods

The researchers conducted a prospective cohort study comparing two groups:

  • Experimental Group (n=39): Students at "School A," which implemented a "full" PBL curriculum.
  • Control Group (n=68): Students at "School B," which maintained a traditional, lecture-based curriculum.

Measurement tools included standardized life-skills assessments developed by the Korean Educational Development Institute (KEDI) to quantify SDL, communication ability, and problem-solving ability. Data was collected at four intervals: immediately upon entrance, and after the first, second, and third semesters.

Results

The "One-Year Peak" in Self-Directed Learning

A primary finding was the non-linear progression of skills in the PBL group. Self-directed learning scores followed an inverted U-shape curve, peaking after two semesters (one year) before declining. Specifically, the PBL group saw a significant increase in SDL scores after the first semester (from a mean of 62.97 to 65.56), but this dropped back to 63.76 by the end of the third semester. This suggests a potential "PBL fatigue" effect or a plateau where the novelty of the method no longer drives incremental gains.

Changes in self-directed learning ability over three semesters.

The Communication Paradox

Counter-intuitively, communication scores trended downward in both groups over the three semesters. Scores for the PBL group started at 48.69 and ended at 47.61. The authors hypothesize that the rigid, high-pressure environment of dental school—regardless of the teaching method—may stifle social and communicative growth as students become increasingly focused on technical mastery and exam survival.

Decline in communication ability across both experimental and control groups.

Problem-Solving Trajectories

Similar to SDL, the PBL group’s problem-solving ability improved significantly in the first year (peaking at 60.38) but showed no further improvement (and a slight decline) in the third semester. In contrast, the control group’s skills initially dipped—perhaps due to the initial volume of dental school—and then began to recover by the end of the study period.

Conclusion

The study concludes that problem-based learning has a positive educational effect compared to didactic-based learning within the first year. However, the plateau observed after two semesters suggests that the optimal duration for a pure PBL curriculum may be limited. The authors recommend that dental education in Korea should consider a "hybrid" model, combining the benefits of PBL with brief, expert-led lectures to maintain long-term competency growth.

Summary updated

Abstract

Objectives: The purpose of this study was to examine the effect of problem-based learning (PBL) on dental education to dental students. The following were investigated in this study: 1. Does PBL improve the ability of self-directed learning? 2. Does PBL change communication ability? 3. Does PBL change the strategy of problem solving? Methods: The participants of this study were 39 students in the experimental group and 68 students in the control group. The measurement tools of this study were self-directed learning, communication, and problem solving abilities tests designed by the Korean Educational Development Institute. The data was analyzed by the two-way ANOVA and ANOVA with repeated measures. Results: In self-directed learning ability during 3 semesters, the experimental group showed a U-shape change but the control group showed a reverse U-shape change. In the experimental group, the selfdirected learning ability was decreased after one year (after the first and second semester). The level of communication ability decreased every day during the three semesters monitored in both the control and experimental groups. The level of communication ability in the experimental group continuously decreased during the three semesters, with the exception of one semester. Finally, for the problem solving ability during the three semesters, the experimental group showed a reverse U-shape change while the control group showed a U-shape change. In the experimental group, there was no change after two semesters. Conclusions: On the basis of the findings in this study, the following conclusions can be made. First, problem-based learning has a positive educational effect compared to didactic-based learning within one year. Second, the appropriate length of PBL is two semesters, or one year. It could be recommended that dental education in Korea should be combined or hybridized with PBL; for example, PBL could be used in combination with brief lectures or block lectures by teachers.
BibTeX
@article{lee2016effects,
  author = {Kangwook Lee and Jin-Sil Hong and Kee-Wan Chang},
  title = {{Effects of full problem based learning of dental students on self-directed learning, communication, and problem solving abilities}},
  journal = {Journal of Korean Academy of Oral Health},
  year = {2016},
  doi = {10.11149/jkaoh.2016.40.4.277},
}
Figure