Effects of frequency-modulated pump on stimulated Brillouin scattering in inhomogeneous plasmas

Y. Chen, Chunyang Zheng, Z J Liu, Linfeng Cao, C. Z. XiaoPlasma 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper investigates how modulating the frequency of a pump laser affects stimulated Brillouin scattering (SBS) in flowing, inhomogeneous plasmas. They found that specific frequency modulations can either significantly enhance SBS reflectivity by creating "multi-location autoresonance" or suppress it with broader bandwidths, offering a new way to control this critical instability in fusion experiments.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Inertial confinement fusion (ICF) relies on powerful lasers to compress fuel pellets. A significant challenge is the stimulated Brillouin scattering (SBS) instability, which can scatter a large portion of the laser energy away from the target, reducing the efficiency of the fusion process. While techniques like using broadband lasers exist to mitigate SBS, their effectiveness in flowing, inhomogeneous plasmas – common in ICF scenarios – is not fully understood. This paper aims to explore how frequency modulation of the pump laser can be used to control SBS in these complex plasma environments, offering a more nuanced approach than simply increasing bandwidth.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-pronged approach:

  • Theoretical Analysis: They developed a three-wave coupling model to describe the interaction between the pump laser, the scattered (seed) laser, and ion acoustic waves. This model allowed them to analyze how frequency modulation affects the "resonant points" where SBS is most likely to occur and how their velocity influences reflectivity.
  • Three-Wave Simulations: These simulations were used to numerically solve the theoretical model and observe the time evolution of SBS reflectivity under different frequency modulation parameters.
  • Kinetic Simulations (Vlasov-Maxwell and PIC): To account for nonlinear effects not captured by the three-wave model (like particle trapping and autoresonance), they used sophisticated one-dimensional Vlasov-Maxwell (Vlama) and Particle-In-Cell (PIC) codes. These simulations provide a more realistic picture of the plasma behavior.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on theoretical models and numerical simulations rather than experimental datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Resonant Point Dynamics: Frequency modulation causes the SBS resonant points to oscillate in space and time, rather than remaining fixed.
  • "Autoresonance" Enhancement: A specific frequency modulation parameter (η ≈ 1) can cause the resonant point velocity to match the seed laser's group velocity. This "autoresonance" significantly increases the effective interaction length and, consequently, the SBS reflectivity.
  • "Multi-Location Autoresonance": For narrow bandwidth modulations (η ≈ 1), the authors observed a novel phenomenon where autoresonance occurs at multiple locations within the plasma, further boosting SBS reflectivity.
  • Bandwidth Suppression: Conversely, increasing the bandwidth of the frequency modulation (η > 2.3) leads to a suppression of SBS reflectivity. This is because the resonant point velocities become too high, reducing the effective interaction length.
  • Experimental Relevance: The findings suggest that specific frequency modulation parameters can be chosen to either enhance or suppress SBS, offering a tunable knob for controlling this instability.

Key Results

  • η ≈ 1: Frequency modulation with η ≈ 1 leads to a substantial increase in SBS reflectivity, observed as multiple "bumps" in simulations, reaching an average reflectivity of 11.5% in three-wave simulations, significantly higher than the 3.42% for a monochromatic pump.
  • η > 2.3: Larger bandwidth modulations (η > 2.3) suppress SBS reflectivity, with average reflectivity dropping to 1% in three-wave simulations, even below the monochromatic case.
  • Kinetic Simulations Confirmation: Both Vlasov-Maxwell and PIC simulations confirmed the theoretical predictions, showing increased reflectivity for η ≈ 1 due to multi-location autoresonance and suppression for larger bandwidths. PIC simulations also visually demonstrated particle trapping and the movement of resonant points consistent with autoresonance.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Dimensionality: The kinetic simulations were performed in one dimension. The authors acknowledge that two-dimensional or three-dimensional effects could introduce further complexities.
  • Plasma Model: The study focuses on a specific plasma density profile and flow velocity. Real ICF plasmas are more complex.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that their findings provide a method for selecting laser bandwidth to inhibit SBS in inhomogeneous plasmas. Future work could explore the effects of different plasma profiles, flow velocities, and pump laser intensities on these phenomena. They also highlight the importance of avoiding η ≈ 1 type modulations if suppression is desired, and instead opting for larger bandwidth modulations.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract The effects of a frequency-modulated pump on stimulated Brillouin scattering (SBS) in a flowing plasma are investigated by theoretical analysis, three-wave simulations, and kinetic simulations. The resonance point of SBS oscillates in a certain spatial region with time when frequency modulations are applied. There exists a certain frequency modulation that causes the velocity of resonant points to be similar to the group velocity of the seed laser, which increases the SBS reflectivity. The SBS can also be suppressed by frequency modulation with larger bandwidth. In the kinetic simulations, the effects of the frequency-modulated pump on the reflectivity agree with our theoretical predictions. Multi-location autoresonance is also observed in the narrow-bandwidth frequency modulation case, which can also increase the SBS reflectivity. Our work provides a method for selecting the laser bandwidth to inhibit SBS in inhomogeneous plasmas.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{chen2023effects,
  author = {Y. Chen and Chunyang Zheng and Z J Liu and Linfeng Cao and C. Z. Xiao},
  title = {{Effects of frequency-modulated pump on stimulated Brillouin scattering in inhomogeneous plasmas}},
  booktitle = {Plasma},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.1088/1361-6587/ad02bd},
}
Figure