Effects of Flight on Gene Expression and Aging in the Honey Bee Brain and Flight Muscle

Joseph W. Margotta, Georgina Mancinelli, Azucena A. Benito, Andrew D. Ammons, Stephen Roberts, Michelle M. ElekonichInsects 2012 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates how flight and age impact gene expression in honey bee brains and flight muscles. They found that the transition to foraging, not just the amount of flight, significantly alters gene expression, with the brain showing more plasticity than flight muscle. This suggests a complex interplay of behavior, age, and epigenetics in honey bee aging.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Aging is a complex process influenced by various factors, including genetics, environment, and behavior. In many organisms, aging is a linear progression. However, honey bees exhibit a unique form of aging tied to their behavioral state, particularly their transition from in-hive tasks (like nursing) to outside foraging. Foraging involves intense metabolic activity and flight, which can lead to oxidative stress and potentially accelerate aging. Conversely, foragers can revert to nursing, showing a reversal of some age-related physiological changes. This study aims to understand the molecular basis of this behavioral plasticity and its impact on aging by examining gene expression patterns in the brain and flight muscle during these transitions. Specifically, it questions whether the effects of flight on gene expression are permanent or reversible, and how age and behavior interact to influence these patterns.

Methods

The researchers employed a combination of molecular techniques to investigate gene expression:

  • Whole-Genome Microarrays: This high-throughput method allowed them to simultaneously measure the expression levels of thousands of genes in different bee groups. They used a "round-robin" design to compare various behavioral groups (nurses, foragers, reverted nurses) across different ages and flight experiences.
  • Quantitative Real-Time PCR (qRT-PCR): This technique was used to validate and quantify the expression of specific genes identified as significant from the microarray data, particularly those related to immunity and aging.
  • Behavioral Manipulation: They created specific experimental groups by manipulating honey bee colonies. This included inducing "reversion" in foragers back to nurse bees through confinement and queen pheromone manipulation, and using single-cohort colonies (SCCs) with skewed age demographics to create bees with different flight histories at similar ages.

Datasets

The study utilized data generated from their own experimental manipulations. They collected RNA from various behavioral groups of honey bees (nurses, foragers, reverted nurses) at different ages and with varying flight histories. The microarray data was submitted to the NCBI Gene Expression Omnibus database under accession number GSE40650.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Flight Transition, Not Just Flight, Matters: The most striking finding is that the act of transitioning from nursing to foraging, rather than the cumulative amount of flight time, has the most significant impact on gene expression. This suggests that the physiological and metabolic shifts associated with becoming a forager are key drivers of molecular change.
  • Tissue-Specific Responses: Brain tissue and flight muscle respond differently to flight and age. The brain's gene expression patterns reflect both age and behavior, indicating higher plasticity. In contrast, flight muscle gene expression is primarily dictated by age.
  • Reversion is Partial, Not Complete: When foragers revert to nursing, there's a partial reversal of gene expression patterns. However, some forager-specific gene expression, particularly related to immune function, persists even after reversion. This suggests that while some molecular changes are reversible, others may be more permanent or take longer to revert.
  • Age vs. Behavior: While age is a factor, behavioral state (nurse vs. forager) and the transition between them appear to have a stronger influence on gene expression, especially in the brain.
  • Epigenetic Regulation Hypothesis: The study proposes that epigenetic mechanisms might play a role in regulating gene expression and energy balance, contributing to honey bee senescence. The upregulation of genes like sirt2 in the brain during the transition to foraging supports this idea.

Key Results

  • Differential Gene Expression: Thousands of differentially expressed transcripts were identified between various age and behavioral groups.
  • Brain Plasticity: Gene expression patterns in the brain were less similar between young nurses and foragers compared to older nurses and foragers, indicating greater age- and behavior-driven changes in the brain.
  • Flight Muscle Age-Dominance: In flight muscle, gene expression patterns were more closely related to age, with reverted nurses showing patterns similar to older nurses.
  • Immune Gene Persistence: Several immune-related transcripts showed persistent forager-like expression in reverted nurses, suggesting incomplete reversion of immune function.
  • Longevity Gene Expression: Genes like indy, sirt2, and pgc1alpha, known to be involved in aging and metabolism, showed distinct expression patterns in brain and flight muscle, with sirt2 upregulation in the brain during foraging and pgc1alpha showing age-related changes in flight muscle.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Reversion Time: The reverted nurse bees were collected only 3 days post-reversion. The authors acknowledge that some effects of reversion might take longer than 3 days to become detectable, and their current method might have missed these.
  • Confinement Stress: The method used to induce reversion involved confining bees, which could have induced a stress response that influenced gene expression. They suggest that this stress response might also be present in other reversion techniques.
  • Acute vs. Chronic Effects: While the study addresses behavioral transitions, separating acute effects of flight from chronic effects of foraging behavior remains challenging. Future studies are planned to investigate foragers restricted from flying.
  • Mechanisms of Reversion: The cellular and genomic mechanisms underlying the partial genomic reversion observed are still unclear and warrant further investigation.
  • Mitochondrial Lesions: The authors suggest that impaired metabolic and flight capacity in aged bees might be due to structural lesions in mitochondria and the flight muscle apparatus, which they are currently investigating.

Summary updated

Abstract

Honey bees move through a series of in-hive tasks (e.g., "nursing") to outside tasks (e.g., "foraging") that are coincident with physiological changes and higher levels of metabolic activity. Social context can cause worker bees to speed up or slow down this process, and foragers may revert back to their earlier in-hive tasks accompanied by reversion to earlier physiological states. To investigate the effects of flight, behavioral state and age on gene expression, we used whole-genome microarrays and real-time PCR. Brain tissue and flight muscle exhibited different patterns of expression during behavioral transitions, with expression patterns in the brain reflecting both age and behavior, and expression patterns in flight muscle being primarily determined by age. Our data suggest that the transition from behaviors requiring little to no flight (nursing) to those requiring prolonged flight bouts (foraging), rather than the amount of previous flight per se, has a major effect on gene expression. Following behavioral reversion there was a partial reversion in gene expression but some aspects of forager expression patterns, such as those for genes involved in immune function, remained. Combined with our real-time PCR data, these data suggest an epigenetic control and energy balance role in honey bee functional senescence.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{margotta2012effects,
  author = {Joseph W. Margotta and Georgina Mancinelli and Azucena A. Benito and Andrew D. Ammons and Stephen Roberts and Michelle M. Elekonich},
  title = {{Effects of Flight on Gene Expression and Aging in the Honey Bee Brain and Flight Muscle}},
  booktitle = {Insects},
  year = {2012},
  doi = {10.3390/insects4010009},
}
Figure