Effects of Fertilization and Drip Irrigation on the Growth of Populus × canadensis ‘Zhongliao 1’ Plantation and on Soil Physicochemical Properties and Enzyme Activities

Yan Zhang, Nairui Wang, Lingyu Yang, Ning Liu, Rusheng Peng, Lei Yu, Fenfen Liu, Shiqi Wang, Chengcheng Gao, Jiabao Ji, Chenggong Liu, Dejun LiangForests 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigated how different levels of fertilization and drip irrigation affect the growth of Populus × canadensis ‘Zhongliao 1’ trees and soil health in arid regions. The findings suggest that high fertilization, particularly when combined with adequate irrigation, is the most crucial factor for promoting tree growth and improving soil conditions, even more so than water availability alone.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Poplar plantations are vital for timber production and ecological restoration in China, especially in arid and semi-arid regions. However, these areas often have poor soil fertility and limited water resources. Poplars, being water and nutrient-intensive, can deplete soil resources rapidly, leading to decreased productivity and soil degradation, especially under climate change scenarios that predict reduced rainfall. While fertilization and drip irrigation are common practices to boost growth, their optimal combination and impact on soil health, particularly in these challenging environments, are not fully understood. This paper aims to fill this knowledge gap by examining how various levels of fertilization and drip irrigation influence poplar growth and soil physicochemical properties and enzyme activities.

Methods

The researchers conducted a field experiment on a 10-year-old Populus × canadensis ‘Zhongliao 1’ plantation. They established 12 treatment combinations involving four levels of fertilization (ranging from 70% to 160% of baseline fertilization amount, BFA) and three levels of drip irrigation (60%, 70%, and 80% of field capacity). These treatments were applied as drip irrigation and fertilization (DIF), fertilization only, or drip irrigation only, alongside a control group with no management.

Key measurements included:

  • Growth Traits: Tree height, diameter at breast height (DBH), and trunk volume increment were measured.
  • Soil Physicochemical Properties: Soil pH, bulk density, total porosity, and capillary porosity were analyzed.
  • Soil Nutrient Content: Total nitrogen (TN), total phosphorus (TP), total potassium (TK), available nitrogen (AN), available potassium (AK), and soil organic matter (OM) were quantified.
  • Soil Enzyme Activities: Urease (UA), catalase (CaA), sucrase (SA), and cellulase (CeA) activities were measured.

Statistical analyses, including ANOVA and Duncan's multiple range tests, were used to determine significant differences between treatments. Correlation analysis was employed to understand the relationships between various traits, and a membership function was used for a comprehensive evaluation of treatment effects.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study utilized data collected from a field experiment conducted at the Heishan Experimental Base of the Poplar Research Institute in Liaoning Province, China.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Fertilization is King: The study strongly suggests that high levels of fertilization are the primary driver for improved poplar growth and soil health in this arid environment, even more so than water availability.
  • Synergy Matters, but with a Dominant Factor: While combining drip irrigation and fertilization (DIF) generally yielded better results than either alone, the highest fertilization rate (160% BFA) showed a significant positive impact even without irrigation, highlighting its dominant role.
  • Soil Health Responds Selectively: Soil capillary porosity and pH were found to be more sensitive to fertilization and irrigation treatments than soil bulk density.
  • Enzyme Activity is a Sensitive Indicator: Soil enzyme activities, particularly urease and sucrase, responded positively to appropriate fertilization and irrigation, indicating improved soil fertility. However, excessive or insufficient moisture and nutrients negatively impacted catalase and cellulase activities.
  • Growth and Soil Nutrients Aren't Directly Linked: Surprisingly, no significant direct correlation was found between poplar growth and soil nutrient content. Instead, growth was more strongly correlated with soil porosity and enzyme activities, suggesting that these factors mediate the nutrient's effect on the trees.

Key Results

  • Growth Promotion: The H4 treatment (160% BFA + 80% FC) resulted in the most significant increases in tree height, DBH, and volume increment.
  • Soil pH and Porosity: While treatments had little effect on soil bulk density, they significantly impacted soil capillary porosity and pH. High fertilization levels (F4) were particularly effective in improving these soil properties.
  • Soil Nutrients: Fertilization treatments, especially F2 and F4, significantly increased total nitrogen (TN). High fertilization (F4) and high irrigation (S3) boosted available nitrogen (AN), while F1 and F4 increased available potassium (AK). Organic matter was highest in F2 and F4.
  • Enzyme Activity: Soil urease activity increased with higher fertilization and irrigation levels. Sucrase activity was significantly enhanced by H4 and F3 treatments. However, excessive fertilization or irrigation negatively impacted catalase and cellulase activities.
  • Comprehensive Evaluation: The highest comprehensive scores for plant and soil traits were achieved with high fertilization levels (F4), followed by the combined high fertilization and irrigation treatment (H4).

Limitations and Future Work

  • Short-Term Study: The study was conducted over a single growing season. The authors acknowledge that the long-term growth of forest trees is a slow process, and short-term experiments may not fully capture the dynamic responses to environmental changes. Future work should involve long-term monitoring to understand legacy effects and dynamic changes.
  • Limited Scope of Indicators: While the study covered key growth traits, soil properties, and enzyme activities, the authors suggest monitoring additional indicators like elemental content, stoichiometric characteristics, photosynthetic traits, and soil microbial communities in future research.
  • Environmental Context: The findings are specific to the Populus × canadensis ‘Zhongliao 1’ variety in the studied arid region. Generalizability to other poplar species or different environmental conditions may require further investigation.
  • Optimal Combination: While high fertilization (F4) emerged as the most beneficial single factor, the optimal combination of fertilization and irrigation for long-term sustainability and maximizing both growth and soil health warrants continued exploration.

Summary updated

Abstract

Poplars are crucial for timber supply and ecological protection in China. Enhancing the growth of poplar plantations and improving soil fertility in arid, and semi-arid poor soil regions are key aspects of sustainable forest management. Fertilization (FTL) and drip irrigation (DI) are among the most widely used methods globally for increasing yield and soil productivity. This study conducted field experiments on FTL and DI in a 10-year-old Populus × canadensis ‘Zhongliao 1’ (cultivation varieties of P. canadensis in northern China) plantation. DI limits were set according to soil moisture at 60% (S1), 70% (S2), and 80% (S3) of field capacity; nitrogen FTL rates were set at 100% of the baseline fertilization amount (100% BFA, N 643.20 g·year−1, P 473.37 g·year−1, and K 492.29 g·year−1) (F1), 70% BFA (F2), 130% BFA (F3), and 160% BFA (F4). The treatments of drip irrigation and fertigation (DIF) were H1 (100% BFA, 60% FC), H2 (100% BFA, 80% FC), H3 (160% BFA, 60% FC), and H4 (160% BFA, 80% FC), along with a control group (CK) without any management, totaling 12 experimental combinations. The results showed that the H4 had the most significant promoting effect on the height, DBH, and volume increments. All treatments had little effect on the soil bulk density of the plantation but significantly impacted soil capillary porosity and pH. Compared to DI, soil nutrient and organic matter content were more sensitive to FTL. Appropriate FTL and DI can increase soil sucrase activity. Soil urease activity tended to increase with higher FTL rates, and higher DI levels also positively influenced urease activity. Excessive or insufficient soil moisture and nutrients negatively impacted soil cellulase and catalase activities. Correlation analysis revealed no significant correlation between the growth of P. × canadensis ‘Zhongliao 1’ and soil nutrient content, but significant or highly significant correlations existed between growth and soil porosity and related enzyme activities. Comprehensive evaluation using a membership function indicated that high FTL levels (F4) were more conducive to the simultaneous improvement of the growth and soil fertility of the plantation, followed by H4 and F1, suggesting that high FTL is the key factor affecting the growth of 10-year-old P. × canadensis ‘Zhongliao 1’ plantations and the restoration of stand productivity, with moisture being secondary.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhang2024effects,
  author = {Yan Zhang and Nairui Wang and Lingyu Yang and Ning Liu and Rusheng Peng and Lei Yu and Fenfen Liu and Shiqi Wang and Chengcheng Gao and Jiabao Ji and Chenggong Liu and Dejun Liang},
  title = {{Effects of Fertilization and Drip Irrigation on the Growth of Populus × canadensis ‘Zhongliao 1’ Plantation and on Soil Physicochemical Properties and Enzyme Activities}},
  booktitle = {Forests},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.3390/f15091651},
}
Figure