Effects of External Stimulation on Psychedelic State Neurodynamics

Pedro A. M. Mediano, Fernando E. Rosas, Christopher Timmermann, Leor Roseman, David Nutt, Amanda Feilding, Mendel Kaelen, Morten L. Kringelbach, Adam B. Barrett, Anil K. Seth, Suresh Muthukumaraswamy, Daniel Bor, Robin Carhart‐HarrisACS 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This study reveals that the environment (setting) significantly influences the brain's response to psychedelics, specifically how LSD increases neural entropy. The findings suggest that a quiet, eyes-closed setting maximizes the psychedelic effect on brain entropy and its correlation with subjective experience, highlighting the importance of controlled environments for psychedelic therapy.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Psychedelics like LSD are known to increase "brain entropy," a measure of neural signal diversity, which is linked to altered states of consciousness and positive psychological outcomes. This phenomenon is particularly interesting because a decrease in brain entropy is associated with loss of consciousness. While the entropy-enhancing effect of psychedelics is well-documented, how external factors – the "setting" – influence this effect and its connection to subjective experience remains largely unexplored. This is a critical gap, as psychedelic-assisted therapy often emphasizes specific environmental conditions (e.g., eyes closed, music). This paper aims to quantitatively investigate how different environmental conditions modulate brain entropy during a psychedelic experience and how these modulations relate to subjective reports.

Methods

The researchers employed magnetoencephalography (MEG) to measure brain activity in 20 healthy participants who underwent two sessions: one with intravenous LSD (75 µg) and one with saline placebo. Data was collected under four conditions:

  • Eyes closed, no stimulus (Resting state)
  • Eyes closed, listening to instrumental ambient music
  • Eyes open, focusing on a fixation dot
  • Watching a silent nature documentary video

The primary analytical tool was Lempel-Ziv (LZ) complexity, a measure of signal complexity or diversity. This metric was applied to source-reconstructed MEG data. Statistical modeling involved linear mixed-effects (LME) models to disentangle the effects of drug, stimulus, and eye-opening, including interactions. Pearson correlation coefficients were used to assess relationships between neural measures (LZ changes) and subjective reports (visual analogue scale - VAS ratings). Conditional predictive analyses were used to build network diagrams illustrating how different brain regions and subjective reports predict each other.

Datasets

The study utilized data from a previous experiment by Carhart-Harris et al. (2016), combined with previously unpublished data from the same experimental setup. No new datasets were introduced or benchmarked.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Setting Matters, Quantitatively: This study provides robust, quantitative evidence that the environment significantly impacts the neurobiological effects of psychedelics. It's not just anecdotal; measurable brain changes are affected.
  • Eyes Closed Amplifies the Effect: The largest increases in brain entropy due to LSD were observed when participants had their eyes closed, suggesting that minimizing external visual input allows the drug's effect on neural complexity to manifest more strongly.
  • Competition Between Internal and External Stimuli: The relationship between brain entropy and subjective experience was strongest in the eyes-closed conditions. When participants watched a video, this relationship broke down, suggesting a "competition" between the drug-induced internal imagery and the external visual stimulus.
  • LZ Complexity as a Key Biomarker: LZ complexity proved to be a more sensitive and reliable marker of the psychedelic experience and its subjective correlates compared to other measures like alpha power.
  • Hierarchical Predictive Relationships: The study suggests a hierarchical structure in how brain entropy and subjective reports relate, with lower-level sensory areas often mediating the relationship between higher-level cognitive regions and subjective experiences.

Key Results

  • LSD Increases Brain Entropy: Consistent with prior research, LSD significantly increased LZ complexity across all experimental conditions.
  • Largest Entropy Increase in Eyes-Closed Conditions: The most substantial increases in LZ complexity were observed in the eyes-closed conditions, with the resting eyes-closed state showing the largest effect.
  • Stimulus and Eye Opening Effects: Both stimulus presence and eye opening independently increased brain entropy, but the drug effect was significantly larger.
  • Drug x Eye Opening Interaction: A significant negative interaction between the drug and eye opening indicated that increased external stimulation (eyes open) reduced the drug's effect on brain entropy.
  • Neural-Psychometric Correlations Disrupted by Video: Positive correlations between brain entropy (LZ) and subjective reports (e.g., ego dissolution, positive mood) were observed in the eyes-closed and music conditions but vanished when participants watched a video.
  • Subjective Reports Predict Brain Entropy: In a reciprocal analysis, more abstract subjective reports (like ego dissolution) were often mediated by less abstract ones (like imagery) in predicting brain entropy.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Generalizability: The study was conducted on healthy volunteers. Future research should investigate these effects in clinical populations undergoing psychedelic therapy.
  • Specific Stimuli: While music and video were used, other sensory modalities and types of stimuli could yield different results. The study acknowledges that certain experiences, like feelings of "communitas," might be better assessed with eyes open.
  • LZ as a Proxy: While LZ is a robust measure, it primarily reflects local signal complexity. The authors suggest that future work should explore higher-order network dynamics and emergent brain states for a more comprehensive understanding.
  • Pharmacological Specificity: The study focused on LSD. Further research could explore how other psychedelics or even non-psychedelic agents interact with setting.
  • Mechanistic Understanding: While the study demonstrates the influence of setting, further work is needed to fully elucidate the precise neurobiological mechanisms underlying these interactions.

The findings strongly support the importance of "setting" in psychedelic experiences, providing a neurobiological basis for why controlled, introspective environments are often favored in therapeutic contexts.

Summary updated

Abstract

Recent findings have shown that psychedelics reliably enhance brain entropy (understood as neural signal diversity), and this effect has been associated with both acute and long-term psychological outcomes, such as personality changes. These findings are particularly intriguing, given that a decrease of brain entropy is a robust indicator of loss of consciousness (e.g., from wakefulness to sleep). However, little is known about how context impacts the entropy-enhancing effect of psychedelics, which carries important implications for how it can be exploited in, for example, psychedelic psychotherapy. This article investigates how brain entropy is modulated by stimulus manipulation during a psychedelic experience by studying participants under the effects of lysergic acid diethylamide (LSD) or placebo, either with gross state changes (eyes closed vs open) or different stimuli (no stimulus vs music vs video). Results show that while brain entropy increases with LSD under all of the experimental conditions, it exhibits the largest changes when subjects have their eyes closed. Furthermore, brain entropy changes are consistently associated with subjective ratings of the psychedelic experience, but this relationship is disrupted when participants are viewing a video─potentially due to a "competition" between external stimuli and endogenous LSD-induced imagery. Taken together, our findings provide strong quantitative evidence of the role of context in modulating neural dynamics during a psychedelic experience, underlining the importance of performing psychedelic psychotherapy in a suitable environment.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{mediano2024effects,
  author = {Pedro A. M. Mediano and Fernando E. Rosas and Christopher Timmermann and Leor Roseman and David Nutt and Amanda Feilding and Mendel Kaelen and Morten L. Kringelbach and Adam B. Barrett and Anil K. Seth and Suresh Muthukumaraswamy and Daniel Bor and Robin Carhart‐Harris},
  title = {{Effects of External Stimulation on Psychedelic State Neurodynamics}},
  booktitle = {ACS},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1021/acschemneuro.3c00289},
}
Figure