Effects of Early Integrated Palliative Care in Patients With Lung and GI Cancer: A Randomized Clinical Trial

Jennifer S. Temel, Joseph A. Greer, Areej El‐Jawahri, William F. Pirl, Elyse R. Park, Vicki A. Jackson, Anthony L. Back, Mihir Kamdar, Juliet Jacobsen, Eva Chittenden, Simone Rinaldi, Emily R. Gallagher, Justin Eusebio, Zhigang Li, Alona Muzikansky, David P. RyanJournal of Clinical Oncology 2017 · DOI

TL;DR

This randomized clinical trial demonstrates that integrating palliative care (PC) early in the treatment of patients with newly diagnosed incurable lung and GI cancers significantly improves their quality of life (QOL) and reduces depression, particularly in the later stages of the disease. The study highlights that the benefits of early PC are more pronounced in lung cancer patients and that it also leads to more frequent discussions about end-of-life care preferences.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

For patients diagnosed with incurable cancers, the journey often involves not only managing the physical symptoms of the disease and its treatment but also grappling with profound psychological, emotional, and existential challenges. Traditional oncology care primarily focuses on disease-modifying treatments, and palliative care (PC) has historically been reserved for the very end of life. This approach can lead to a disconnect between patients' needs for symptom management, QOL improvement, and clear communication about their prognosis and end-of-life wishes. The problem this paper addresses is the suboptimal integration of PC into the early stages of advanced cancer care, potentially leading to worse QOL, increased depression, and a lack of preparedness for end-of-life decisions. The authors aim to evaluate whether early, proactive integration of PC alongside standard oncology care can mitigate these issues.

Methods

The study employed a randomized controlled trial design. Patients with newly diagnosed incurable lung or noncolorectal GI cancer were randomly assigned to one of two groups:

  1. Early Integrated Palliative Care (PC) and Oncology Care: These patients met with a PC clinician at least once a month until death, in addition to their regular oncology care.
  2. Usual Care: These patients received standard oncology care and could consult a PC clinician only upon request.

The primary outcome measured was the change in Quality of Life (QOL) from baseline to week 12, assessed using the Functional Assessment of Cancer Therapy-General (FACT-G) scale. Secondary outcomes included QOL at week 24, depression symptoms (measured by the Patient Health Questionnaire-9, PHQ-9), and differences in end-of-life communication. Statistical analyses included independent-samples t-tests, analysis of covariance (ANCOVA) to control for baseline differences, and a terminal decline joint modeling approach to analyze outcomes backward from death, accounting for missing data. The study also explored whether the intervention effects varied by cancer type.

Datasets

The study utilized patient-reported outcome measures collected through validated questionnaires:

  • Functional Assessment of Cancer Therapy-General (FACT-G) scale: Measures physical, functional, emotional, and social well-being.
  • Patient Health Questionnaire-9 (PHQ-9): Assesses symptoms of major depressive disorder.
  • Hospital Anxiety and Depression Scale (HADS): Measures anxiety and depression symptoms.
  • Prognosis and Treatment Perceptions Questionnaire: Assesses patients' understanding of their prognosis and communication with oncologists.

These data were collected at baseline, week 12, and week 24, with additional analysis using a terminal decline model that considered data up to the point of death. No new benchmarks were introduced; the study relied on established instruments.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Timing is Crucial: The benefits of early PC aren't always immediate. While QOL didn't show a significant difference at 12 weeks, it did at 24 weeks, suggesting a cumulative or delayed effect.
  • Cancer Type Matters: The impact of early PC is not uniform across all advanced cancers. Lung cancer patients saw clear improvements in QOL and mood, while GI cancer patients showed improvements regardless of the intervention group, hinting at different disease trajectories or responses to care.
  • Beyond Symptom Management: Early PC is more than just pain and symptom relief. It empowers patients with better understanding of their prognosis and facilitates crucial end-of-life discussions, which are often avoided.
  • Preparing for the End: A significant finding is that patients receiving early PC were twice as likely to discuss their end-of-life wishes with their oncologist, indicating improved preparedness and communication.

Key Results

  • QOL Improvement: Intervention patients showed a statistically significant improvement in QOL at week 24 (1.59-point increase) compared to a decrease in the usual care group (-3.40 points; P = .010). This difference was not significant at week 12.
  • Depression Reduction: Intervention patients reported lower depression scores at week 24 (adjusted mean difference of -1.17; P = .048).
  • Differential Effects by Cancer Type:
    • Lung Cancer: Patients in the intervention group showed improvements in QOL and depression at both 12 and 24 weeks, while usual care patients experienced deterioration.
  • GI Cancer: Patients in both groups showed improvements in QOL and mood by week 12, with no significant differences between groups.
  • End-of-Life Communication: Intervention patients were significantly more likely to discuss their end-of-life wishes with their oncologist (30.2% vs. 14.5%; P = .004).
  • Terminal Decline Analysis: Using a model that looks backward from death, intervention patients had significantly higher QOL and lower depression scores at 2 and 4 months before death, but not at 6 months.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Lack of Blinding: Patients and clinicians were not blinded to group assignment, which could introduce bias.
  • Sample Size for Subgroup Analysis: The study was not powered to detect differences between cancer types, making subgroup analyses exploratory.
  • Usual Care Contamination: A significant portion of patients in the "usual care" group received PC services, which may have diluted the intervention's effect.
  • Single Institution: The study was conducted at a single institution with a predominantly white, English-speaking population, limiting generalizability.

Future work should focus on:

  • Understanding the specific mechanisms driving the differential effects observed between lung and GI cancers.
  • Developing targeted PC interventions tailored to the unique needs and trajectories of different patient populations.
  • Investigating the optimal timing and integration models for PC within the broader landscape of rapidly advancing cancer treatments.
  • Further research into how to best describe and implement patient-centered PC interventions.

Summary updated

Abstract

Purpose We evaluated the impact of early integrated palliative care (PC) in patients with newly diagnosed lung and GI cancer. Patients and Methods We randomly assigned patients with newly diagnosed incurable lung or noncolorectal GI cancer to receive either early integrated PC and oncology care (n = 175) or usual care (n = 175) between May 2011 and July 2015. Patients who were assigned to the intervention met with a PC clinician at least once per month until death, whereas those who received usual care consulted a PC clinician upon request. The primary end point was change in quality of life (QOL) from baseline to week 12, per scoring by the Functional Assessment of Cancer Therapy-General scale. Secondary end points included change in QOL from baseline to week 24, change in depression per the Patient Health Questionnaire-9, and differences in end-of-life communication. Results Intervention patients ( v usual care) reported greater improvement in QOL from baseline to week 24 (1.59 v -3.40; P = .010) but not week 12 (0.39 v -1.13; P = .339). Intervention patients also reported lower depression at week 24, controlling for baseline scores (adjusted mean difference, -1.17; 95% CI, -2.33 to -0.01; P = .048). Intervention effects varied by cancer type, such that intervention patients with lung cancer reported improvements in QOL and depression at 12 and 24 weeks, whereas usual care patients with lung cancer reported deterioration. Patients with GI cancers in both study groups reported improvements in QOL and mood by week 12. Intervention patients versus usual care patients were more likely to discuss their wishes with their oncologist if they were dying (30.2% v 14.5%; P = .004). Conclusion For patients with newly diagnosed incurable cancers, early integrated PC improved QOL and other salient outcomes, with differential effects by cancer type. Early integrated PC may be most effective if targeted to the specific needs of each patient population.
BibTeX
@article{temel2017effects,
  author = {Jennifer S. Temel and Joseph A. Greer and Areej El‐Jawahri and William F. Pirl and Elyse R. Park and Vicki A. Jackson and Anthony L. Back and Mihir Kamdar and Juliet Jacobsen and Eva Chittenden and Simone Rinaldi and Emily R. Gallagher and Justin Eusebio and Zhigang Li and Alona Muzikansky and David P. Ryan},
  title = {{Effects of Early Integrated Palliative Care in Patients With Lung and GI Cancer: A Randomized Clinical Trial}},
  journal = {Journal of Clinical Oncology},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.1200/jco.2016.70.5046},
}
Figure