Effects of Contemporary Land Use Types and Conversions from Wetland to Paddy Field or Dry Land on Soil Organic Carbon Fractions

Di Zhao, Junyu Dong, Shuping Ji, Miansong Huang, Quan Quan, Jian LiuSustainability 2020 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates how converting natural wetlands into paddy fields or dry land impacts soil organic carbon (SOC) fractions. It reveals that paddy fields can sequester carbon, primarily through heavy fraction organic carbon (HFOC), but this capacity may diminish over time due to decreasing clay content.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Soil organic carbon (SOC) is crucial for soil health and plays a significant role in climate regulation. Land-use change, particularly the conversion of natural ecosystems like wetlands to agricultural land, is a major driver of changes in SOC. Wetlands are known carbon sinks, but their conversion can alter this role. Understanding how different agricultural land uses, specifically paddy fields and dry land, affect the various fractions of SOC (dissolved organic carbon - DOC, light fraction organic carbon - LFOC, and heavy fraction organic carbon - HFOC) over time is essential for accurate carbon accounting and developing sustainable land management practices. This paper aims to fill this knowledge gap by examining these effects in the context of wetland conversion in China.

Methods

The researchers collected soil samples from natural wetlands, constructed wetlands, fishponds, paddy fields, and dry land in the Nansi Lake region of China. They analyzed these samples for various soil organic carbon fractions (DOC, LFOC, HFOC) and other soil properties like moisture content, bulk density, pH, texture (clay, sand, silt), and nutrient availability (available phosphorus, LF-N, HF-N). To understand the impact of reclamation history, they specifically compared paddy fields and dry land converted from wetlands 20 and 30 years prior, analyzing soil profiles down to 60 cm. Statistical analyses, including Kruskal-Wallis tests and Redundancy Analysis (RDA), were used to identify significant differences and relationships between land-use types, soil properties, and SOC fractions.

Datasets

The study utilized soil samples collected from the Nansi Lake region in China. Land-use history was confirmed using satellite imagery (Landsat MSS/TM/OLI) and local historical documents. No new benchmark datasets were introduced.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Paddy fields as carbon sequesters: The conversion of wetlands to paddy fields shows a strong potential for sequestering carbon, primarily due to the accumulation of HFOC in the topsoil. This suggests that flooded agricultural systems can act as carbon sinks.
  • HFOC is key for paddy fields: The heavy fraction of organic carbon (HFOC) appears to be the most sensitive indicator of carbon sequestration in paddy fields, showing a significant increase compared to natural wetlands.
  • Time and clay matter: While paddy fields initially sequester carbon, the study highlights a concerning trend: HFOC content decreased by 22% after 10 years of cultivation, linked to a decline in clay content. This suggests that the long-term carbon sequestration capacity of paddy fields is not guaranteed and is influenced by soil properties like clay.
  • Dry land loses carbon: In contrast to paddy fields, the conversion of wetlands to dry land leads to a significant decrease in HFOC, indicating carbon loss rather than sequestration.
  • DOC and LFOC dynamics are complex: Dissolved organic carbon (DOC) showed varied responses across land-use types, increasing in constructed wetlands but decreasing in fishponds and dry land. Light fraction organic carbon (LFOC) generally decreased across converted land uses compared to natural wetlands.
  • Soil properties are influential: Soil characteristics like moisture content, clay, and available phosphorus play significant roles in influencing SOC fractions, particularly HFOC.

Key Results

  • HFOC: Increased by 72% in paddy fields and 50% in constructed wetlands compared to natural wetlands. Decreased by 62% in dry land.
  • DOC: Increased by 17% in constructed wetlands and decreased by 39% in fishponds compared to natural wetlands.
  • LFOC: Decreased by approximately 61% in converted land uses compared to natural wetlands, though differences between land-use types were not statistically significant.
  • Paddy Field Depth: LFOC and HFOC were significantly higher in the top 0.2 m of paddy field soil compared to deeper layers (0.2-0.6 m).
  • Reclamation History: HFOC content in paddy fields decreased by 22% after 10 years of cultivation.
  • Soil Properties: Paddy fields had the highest clay content and available phosphorus. Dry land had the lowest HF-N content.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that the reclamation duration studied (20 and 30 years) might not be long enough to fully capture long-term carbon accumulation trends in paddy fields. They suggest that strict management practices are needed to favor clay accumulation in paddy fields to enhance their carbon sequestration capacity. Future work could explore the impact of different management strategies on clay content and HFOC accumulation, as well as investigate the long-term sustainability of carbon sequestration in these converted wetland ecosystems. The study also notes that the effects of land-use on DOC were primarily detected in the topsoil, suggesting further investigation into deeper soil profiles might be warranted.

Summary updated

Abstract

Soil organic carbon (SOC) concentration is closely related to soil quality and climate change. The objectives of this study were to estimate the effects of contemporary land use on SOC concentrations at 0–20 cm depths, and to investigate the dynamics of SOC in paddy-field soil and dry-land soil after their conversion from natural wetlands (20 and 30 years ago). We investigated the dissolved organic carbon (DOC), light fraction organic carbon (LFOC), heavy fraction organic carbon (HFOC), and other soil properties (i.e., moisture content, bulk density, pH, clay, sand, silt, available phosphorous, light fraction nitrogen, and heavy fraction nitrogen) in natural wetlands, constructed wetlands, fishponds, paddy fields, and soybean fields. The results indicated that the content of DOC increased 17% in constructed wetland and decreased 39% in fishponds, and the content of HFOC in constructed wetland and fishponds increased 50% and 8%, respectively, compared with that in natural wetlands at 0–20 cm. After the conversion of a wetland, the content of HFOC increased 72% in the paddy fields and decreased 62% in the dry land, while the content of DOC and LFOC decreased in both types. In the paddy fields, LFOC and HFOC content in the topmost 0.2 m of the soil layer was significantly higher compared to the layer below (from 0.2 to 0.6 m), and there were no significant differences observed in the dry land. The findings suggest that the paddy fields can sequester organic carbon through the accumulation of HFOC. However, the HFOC content decreased 22% after 10 years of cultivation with the decrease of clay content, indicating that paddy fields need to favor clay accumulation for the purpose of enhancing carbon sequestration in the paddy fields.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhao2020effects,
  author = {Di Zhao and Junyu Dong and Shuping Ji and Miansong Huang and Quan Quan and Jian Liu},
  title = {{Effects of Contemporary Land Use Types and Conversions from Wetland to Paddy Field or Dry Land on Soil Organic Carbon Fractions}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.3390/su12052094},
}
Figure