Effects of confinement-induced non-Newtonian lubrication forces on the rheology of a dense suspension

Alan Rosales-Romero, Adolfo Vázquez-Quesada, S. S. Prasanna Kumar, J. Esteban López‐Aguilar, Marco ElleroJournal of Non-Newtonian Fluid Mechanics 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel "Functionalised Bi-Viscous" (FBV) model to explain how the rheology of dense suspensions changes when the liquid lubricant between particles is squeezed into very thin gaps. By accounting for this confinement-induced non-Newtonian behavior, the model successfully reproduces complex phenomena like discontinuous shear thickening and negative normal stresses, offering a new perspective on suspension mechanics.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Dense suspensions, like paints or slurries, exhibit fascinating and often counter-intuitive flow behaviors, most notably "discontinuous shear thickening" (DST), where viscosity abruptly increases with shear rate. While friction between particles has been a key focus in explaining DST, the role of the suspending liquid, especially under extreme confinement (when particles are very close), has remained less understood. Experiments show that even simple liquids can behave non-Newtonianly when squeezed into nanometer-scale gaps, exhibiting significant viscosity increases. This paper aims to bridge this gap by developing a model that explicitly incorporates this confinement-induced non-Newtonian lubricant behavior into the lubrication forces between particles in a dense suspension.

Methods

The core of this work is the development of a Functionalised Bi-Viscous (FBV) model. This model builds upon existing bi-viscous lubrication theories but introduces two key functionalizations:

  • Gap-dependent viscosity: The viscosity of the lubricant, $\eta_{conf}$, is made to depend on the inter-particle gap size ($h_0$). At very small gaps, the viscosity increases significantly, reflecting experimental observations of confined fluids. This is modeled using an exponential function.
  • Gap-dependent critical shear rate: The shear rate ($\dot{\gamma}_c$) at which the lubricant transitions from its high-viscosity confined state to its low-viscosity bulk state is also made dependent on the gap size. This is modeled as inversely proportional to the gap.

These functionalized viscosity and critical shear rate are then used within a lubrication force calculation. The authors employ a lubrication dynamics method, a numerical technique that efficiently handles the strong forces arising when particles are close. This method uses a semi-implicit splitting integration scheme, which is robust for simulations involving highly viscous fluids. The simulations are performed in a cubic box with periodic boundary conditions, except for the top and bottom walls which impose a simple shear flow.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on numerical simulations and comparisons with existing experimental data from the literature.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Confinement is a powerful rheological tuner: The paper strongly suggests that the non-Newtonian behavior of the lubricant under confinement is not just a minor effect but a crucial factor in dictating the overall rheology of dense suspensions, potentially explaining phenomena like DST without solely relying on inter-particle friction.
  • Bi-viscous behavior as a bridge: The FBV model's ability to capture both shear-thinning and shear-thickening regimes by switching between different viscosity states (confined vs. bulk) provides a compelling framework for understanding complex suspension flow.
  • Negative normal stresses are achievable: The model predicts negative normal stress differences, which are experimentally observed but difficult to reproduce with simpler frictional models. This suggests the FBV model captures important aspects of the stress tensor.
  • Microstructure dictates macro-behavior: The paper links specific rheological regimes (thinning, thickening) to changes in particle interactions, such as the number of interacting pairs and the magnitude of lubrication forces, highlighting the interplay between microscopic particle arrangements and macroscopic flow properties.

Key Results

  • The FBV model successfully reproduces discontinuous shear thickening (DST) and a first shear-thinning regime at low shear rates, followed by a second shear-thinning regime at high shear rates.
  • The model predicts negative normal stress differences ($N_1$ and $N_2$) across a significant range of shear rates, consistent with experimental observations.
  • The model's predictions for effective lubricant viscosity under confinement show good qualitative agreement with experimental data for polymer melts.
  • Parametric studies reveal that the model's behavior is sensitive to the parameters controlling confinement effects ($L^*$, $A^*$, $\Delta \eta^*$), allowing for the tuning of rheological responses from continuous shear thickening (CST) to strong DST.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Smooth particles: The current model assumes smooth particles. The authors suggest that future work should incorporate rough frictional particles to explore a wider range of contact physics, including dry, lubricated, and mixed lubrication regimes.
  • Tangential forces: The current model primarily focuses on normal lubrication forces. Future research could include tangential forces to better mimic tribological interactions.
  • Complex matrices: The study uses a simplified bi-viscous lubricant. Extending the model to more complex fluid rheologies (e.g., viscoelasticity) or interactions with specific particle materials is a promising avenue.
  • Experimental validation: While qualitative agreement with experimental data is shown, further quantitative validation with a wider range of experimental conditions would strengthen the model's impact.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{rosalesromero2024effects,
  author = {Alan Rosales-Romero and Adolfo Vázquez-Quesada and S. S. Prasanna Kumar and J. Esteban López‐Aguilar and Marco Ellero},
  title = {{Effects of confinement-induced non-Newtonian lubrication forces on the rheology of a dense suspension}},
  journal = {Journal of Non-Newtonian Fluid Mechanics},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1016/j.jnnfm.2024.105248},
}
Figure