Effects of Concrete Cover on GFRP RC Bridge Deck

Jianwei HuangProceedings of the International Conference on Civil, Structural and Transportation Engineering 2018 · DOI

Abstract

In North America, steel-reinforced concrete (RC) bridge decks are highly susceptible to corrosion caused by the heavy use of deicing salts. Glass Fiber Reinforced Polymer (GFRP) bars offer a promising, corrosion-resistant alternative to traditional steel. However, current design practices often apply "legacy" concrete cover requirements—up to 2.5 inches—originally intended to protect steel from chloride ingress. This paper evaluates the influence of concrete cover depth on the design and cost of GFRP RC bridge decks through a parametric study of 48 design scenarios. The results demonstrate that reducing cover depth increases the effective depth of reinforcement, enhancing structural efficiency and significantly lowering material costs without violating AASHTO LRFD safety standards.

Introduction

The longevity of bridge infrastructure in the United States and Canada is significantly compromised by the corrosion of internal steel reinforcement. Chloride ions from deicing salts penetrate the concrete, causing steel to rust and expand, which eventually leads to the delamination and spalling of the deck.

GFRP bars have emerged as a robust solution due to their inherent resistance to chloride-induced corrosion. Despite these benefits, many demonstration projects continue to use conservative concrete covers (typically 2.5 inches for the top layer and 1.5 inches for the bottom). While these dimensions are necessary to protect steel from environmental degradation, they may be unnecessary for GFRP. Furthermore, excessive cover depth increases the dead load of the structure and reduces the "effective depth" of the reinforcement. This research seeks to quantify the relationship between cover depth, structural performance, and project economics to determine if thinner covers can optimize bridge deck design.

Methodology: A Parametric Approach

To determine the optimal cover depth, a comprehensive parametric study was conducted based on the AASHTO LRFD Bridge Design Specifications. The study analyzed 48 distinct bridge deck profiles by varying the following parameters:

  • Girder Spacing: 8 ft, 9 ft, and 10 ft.
  • Deck Thickness: 8 in and 9 in.
  • Top Concrete Cover: 1.0 in, 1.5 in, 2.0 in, and 2.5 in.
  • Bottom Concrete Cover: 1.0 in and 1.5 in.

For each combination, a full structural design was performed to determine the required GFRP bar size and spacing. These designs were required to satisfy both Service Limit States (addressing crack width and deflection) and Ultimate Limit States (ensuring flexural capacity). Following the design phase, the costs of the GFRP reinforcement were calculated and normalized to allow for direct comparison across different configurations.

Analysis of Structural Efficiency

The primary structural advantage of reducing concrete cover lies in the increase of the "effective depth" ($d$). In reinforced concrete design, the effective depth is the distance from the extreme compression fiber to the centroid of the tensile reinforcement.

In steel RC, the cover is largely "sacrificial," acting as a barrier against chemical ingress. However, because GFRP is immune to chloride corrosion, the cover serves primarily to provide bond strength and protect against mechanical wear. By reducing the cover, the effective depth is increased. This larger "lever arm" allows the reinforcement to resist bending moments more efficiently. Consequently, a deck with a thinner cover can achieve the same load-carrying capacity with less GFRP reinforcement (either through smaller bars or wider spacing) than a deck with a thicker cover.

Key Findings and Economic Impact

The study yielded several critical insights for the future of bridge engineering:

  1. Structural Viability: All 48 scenarios, including those with a minimal 1-inch cover, successfully met the AASHTO LRFD requirements. This proves that thinner covers are structurally sufficient for standard bridge deck geometries.
  2. Cost Sensitivity: The research demonstrated a direct correlation between cover depth and reinforcement cost. As the cover thickness increases, the required amount of GFRP reinforcement also increases to compensate for the reduced effective depth.
  3. Optimization of Standards: The current industry standard of 2.5-inch top cover is likely over-designed for GFRP applications. Moving toward a 1.0-inch or 1.5-inch cover could significantly lower the initial capital investment required for GFRP RC decks, making them a more economically competitive alternative to traditional steel.

Conclusion and Future Considerations

This research provides a quantitative basis for reconsidering the "one-size-fits-all" approach to concrete cover in bridge decks. By treating concrete cover as a design variable rather than a fixed environmental protection requirement, engineers can optimize GFRP RC decks for both performance and cost.

While a 1-inch cover is structurally sound according to design codes, future research should investigate practical implementation factors, such as constructability tolerances during large-scale concrete pours and the impact of reduced cover on punching shear resistance. Ultimately, the findings suggest that reducing concrete cover is a viable path toward more sustainable and cost-effective bridge infrastructure.

Summary updated

Abstract

In the United States and Canada, steel reinforced concrete (RC) bridge decks have suffered from steel corrosion due to the enormous use of deicing salts in winter seasons In order to resolve the steel corrosion problem, glass fiber reinforced polymer (GFRP) bars have been extensively researched as a promising substitute to the conventional steel reinforcement To date, several design specifications In addition, a number of GFRP RC bridge decks have been built in Canada and the US as demonstration projects, in which 2.5 in. and 1.5 in. were often used for the top and bottom concrete covers, respectively [e.g., 6]. The use of larger concrete cover could protect the internal GFRP bars in the deck; however, it may increase the cost of the project. Also, considering the excellent corrosion resistance of GFRP bars, the large concrete cover may not be necessary. In this regard, this paper aimed to assess the influence of concrete clear covers on the design and cost of the GFRP RC bridge deck. In order to discover the effects of concrete cover, a comprehensive parametric study was conducted in this research, where the AASHTO LFRD bridge design specifications Totally six bridge deck profiles were considered with three different girder spacing (i.e., 8ft, 9ft, and 10ft) and two different deck thickness (i.e., 8in. and 9in.). For each bridge deck profile, the top GFRP bars were designed for four different top concrete covers (i.e., 1in., 1.5in., 2in., and 2.5in.); whereas, the bottom GFRP bars were designed for two different bottom concrete covers (i.e., 1in. and 1.5in.). For each case, the bar size and bar spacing were determined for the top and bottom GFRP bars by a complete deck design with meeting the requirements at various limit states (e.g., service limit state, ultimate limit state) as specified in the design specifications The costs of GFRP bars were subsequently computed and normalized for comparisons among the different decks. Research results from this study not only provided a quantitative cost comparison among different concrete covers, but also suggested optimum design parameters for a GFRP RC bridge deck.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{huang2018effects,
  author = {Jianwei Huang},
  title = {{Effects of Concrete Cover on GFRP RC Bridge Deck}},
  booktitle = {Proceedings of the International Conference on Civil, Structural and Transportation Engineering},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.11159/iccste18.138},
}
Figure