Effects of CO2–water–rock cycling cycles on sandstone pore structure

Hao Huang, Qiang Sun, Duoxing Yang, Jishi Geng, Liwei Zhang, Yanning PanFrontiers in Energy Research 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates how intermittent, cyclic CO₂ injection into saline aquifers alters the physical "plumbing" of reservoir sandstone. The researchers found that repeated injection cycles trigger a complex tug-of-war between mineral dissolution and salt precipitation, ultimately degrading the rock structure and shifting the dominant pore space from large macropores to medium-sized mesopores.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Carbon Capture, Utilization, and Storage (CCUS) in deep saline aquifers is a front-runner for large-scale carbon mitigation. However, in real-world scenarios, CO₂ injection isn't always a steady stream; it is often intermittent due to fluctuations in CO₂ supply or maintenance schedules.

When CO₂ enters a saline aquifer, it reacts with water to form carbonic acid, which then reacts with the reservoir rock (sandstone). While we know the basic chemistry, we don't fully understand how repeated cycles of injection affect the rock's pore structure over time. If the pores clog up with precipitated minerals or the rock structure weakens significantly, the reservoir's storage capacity and long-term safety could be compromised. This paper seeks to map those physical and chemical changes across multiple injection cycles.

Methods

The researchers used sandstone samples from the Ordos Basin in China and subjected them to five injection cycles of varying durations (up to 168 hours total) in a specialized reaction vessel. To simulate deep underground conditions, the tests were run at 40°C and 5 MPa of pressure.

The study compared three different fluid environments:

  1. Sodium Sulfate ($Na_2SO_4$) brine: Common in many aquifers.
  2. Sodium Chloride ($NaCl$) brine: The most common saline environment.
  3. Deionized water: Used as a control group.

To track the changes, they employed a suite of high-tech analytical tools:

  • Nuclear Magnetic Resonance (NMR): To "see" the internal pore size distribution without destroying the rock.
  • ICP-OES: To measure the concentration of metal ions (like Calcium and Magnesium) leaching into the brine.
  • Ultrasonic Wave Velocity: To assess the structural integrity and homogeneity of the rock samples.

Datasets

As an experimental laboratory study, the "dataset" consists of primary data generated from 21 sandstone core samples. The authors provide detailed mineralogical compositions (50% quartz, 13.5% calcite, etc.) and initial physical parameters (density and porosity) for all samples to ensure reproducibility. No external large-scale datasets were used.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Pore Shift" Phenomenon: The most striking finding is the redistribution of pore sizes. Initially, the number of large macropores increases as the acidic CO₂-brine dissolves minerals like calcite. However, as the cycles continue, secondary minerals begin to precipitate, filling these large gaps. The result? A significant increase in mesopores (medium-sized pores), which become the dominant feature of the rock's architecture.
  • Sulfate is the "Clogger": Not all brines are created equal. $Na_2SO_4$-type aquifers showed much more dramatic structural changes than $NaCl$ aquifers. This is because sulfate ions ($SO_4^{2-}$) readily react with leached calcium to form gypsum ($CaSO_4$) precipitates, which are highly effective at blocking pores.
  • The Two-Phase Mass Change: The rock samples didn't just steadily dissolve. In "Phase I," samples in sulfate brine actually gained mass (up to 0.18%) because precipitation outpaced dissolution. In "Phase II," as cycles continued, the trend reversed toward mass loss as structural degradation took over.
  • Non-Homogenization: Longitudinal wave velocity measurements showed that cyclic injection makes the rock less "uniform." The repeated chemical shocks create localized areas of high density (clogging) and low density (dissolution), which could lead to unpredictable fluid flow in a real-world reservoir.

Key Results

  • Ion Surges: In the sulfate brine, $Ca^{2+}$ concentrations skyrocketed to 210.9 ppm—a 47.1-fold increase from the initial state—highlighting the aggressive dissolution of calcite during early cycles.
  • Pore Volume Expansion: In $Na_2SO_4$ brine, the volume of mesopores increased by 300% (three times the initial volume) by the second cycle.
  • Structural Weakening: While wave velocity initially spiked (likely due to pores being "stuffed" with precipitates), it eventually dropped to 0.85–0.92 times the initial value, signaling a net loss in structural integrity.
  • Mass Loss: By the end of the experiment, $NaCl$ and deionized water samples showed mass reductions of 0.78% and 0.67%, respectively, while sulfate samples showed a smaller net loss (0.21%) due to the offsetting effect of salt precipitation.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that this was a laboratory-scale study over a relatively short timeframe (16.5 days). Real-world sequestration happens over decades.

Future directions include: * Long-term Stability: Investigating how these pore changes evolve over years rather than days. * Numerical Modeling: Integrating these laboratory findings into large-scale simulations to predict how an entire basin might react to cyclic injection. * Field Data: Comparing these results with actual monitoring data from active CCUS sites to bridge the gap between the lab and the field.

Summary updated

Abstract

As global CO 2 levels increase, the storage of CO 2 in saline aquifers is considered a large-scale and cost-effective method for mitigating CO 2 emissions. To examine the impact of cyclic CO 2 injection on sandstone formations within various saline aquifers, five cyclic injections of differing durations were performed, and the effects of the frequency and duration of CO 2 injection cycles on sandstone pore structure were monitored using nuclear magnetic resonance. Additionally, ICP-OES was employed to assess changes in the total dissolved solids and metal ion concentrations in the saline water layer post-injection. The findings reveal that sandstone samples experience structural degradation as a result of cyclic injection. Initially, the proportion of macropores in sandstone samples increases with the number of injections but subsequently decreases. SO 4 2– ions exert a more significant influence on the sandstone pore structure compared to Cl − ions. The concentrations of Ca 2+ and Mg 2+ ions in the solution initially rise, followed by a subsequent decline. By integrating the principles of pore structure and considering the formation of crystals through the combination of metal cations and anions, the mechanism underlying the changes in sandstone pore structure due to cyclic injection is elucidated. This study explores the effects of CO 2 cyclic injection on reservoir sandstone and evaluates how different saline aquifer types affect pore structure deterioration. The research offers valuable reference points and a foundation for laboratory investigations of underground CO 2 storage in saline aquifers.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{huang2024effects,
  author = {Hao Huang and Qiang Sun and Duoxing Yang and Jishi Geng and Liwei Zhang and Yanning Pan},
  title = {{Effects of CO2–water–rock cycling cycles on sandstone pore structure}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Energy Research},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.3389/fenrg.2024.1485241},
}
Figure