Effects of Climate Change on Surface Runoff and Soil Moisture in the Source Region of the Yellow River

Jianhua Si, Jianming Li, Sujin Lu, Xuejiao Qi, Xiuzhi Zhang, Wenjin Bao, Xiaoyan Zhang, Shipeng Zhou, Cheng Jin, Lijuan Qi, Yue Qi, Xiaojing Zheng, Yanhong Gong, Zhanqing WangWater 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This study uses the SWAT hydrological model coupled with CMIP5 climate projections to predict future surface runoff and soil moisture in the Yellow River's source region. The findings indicate a concerning trend of decreasing runoff and soil moisture despite potential increases in precipitation, likely due to amplified evaporation, highlighting the urgent need for water resource management.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The source region of the Yellow River, a critical area for China's water resources and ecological stability, is facing significant environmental challenges due to global climate change. Observed impacts include permafrost degradation, vegetation loss, and altered hydrological cycles. While previous studies have examined climate change impacts on this region, there's a need for a comprehensive analysis of future surface runoff and soil moisture dynamics under various climate change scenarios. This paper aims to fill this gap by providing a scientific basis for the rational use and protection of water resources in this vulnerable area.

Methods

The core of this research involves coupling the Soil and Water Assessment Tool (SWAT) hydrological model with climate projections from the Coupled Model Intercomparison Project Phase 5 (CMIP5).

  1. SWAT Model Setup: A detailed database was constructed for the Yellow River source region, including soil, meteorological, and runoff data. The SWAT model was then established, dividing the basin into 80 sub-basins and 286 hydrological response units.
  2. Model Calibration and Validation: The SWAT model's performance was rigorously assessed. A calibration period (1961-2013) and a validation period (2014-2019) were used, with simulated runoff values showing good agreement with observed data (R² of 0.876 for calibration and 0.972 for validation), indicating strong model applicability.
  3. Climate Scenario Integration: Future climate projections from CMIP5 under three Representative Concentration Pathways (RCPs) – RCP2.6 (low emissions), RCP4.5 (intermediate emissions), and RCP8.5 (high emissions) – were used. These projections were statistically downscaled to match the spatial resolution of the SWAT model.
  4. Future Prediction: The calibrated SWAT model was driven by the downscaled CMIP5 climate data to predict future surface runoff and soil moisture from 2023 to 2100.
  5. Trend Analysis: Linear regression models were employed to analyze trends in historical (2011-2022) and projected (2023-2100) surface runoff and soil moisture in relation to temperature and precipitation.

Datasets

  • Meteorological Data: Average annual temperature and precipitation for the historical period (1961–2022) were obtained from the Climate Center of Qinghai Province, China.
  • Hydrological Data: Surface runoff data (1961–2022) and soil moisture data (2011–2022) were sourced from the Qinghai Provincial Hydrological and Water Resources Survey Bureau, China.
  • Future Climate Scenarios: CMIP5 data under RCP2.6, RCP4.5, and RCP8.5 emission scenarios for the Yellow River source region were used. This data was provided by the China Climate Center and underwent statistical downscaling.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Temperature's Dominant Influence: The study strongly suggests that surface runoff in the Yellow River source region is significantly influenced by temperature, with a highly significant correlation observed between runoff trends and temperature trends.
  • Paradoxical Hydrological Response: A key insight is the projected decrease in both surface runoff and soil moisture even under scenarios where precipitation might increase. This points to a critical role for increased evaporation, likely driven by rising temperatures, in overriding any potential gains from precipitation.
  • Model Reliability: The high R² values for both calibration and validation of the SWAT model lend significant credibility to its predictions for this region.
  • Regional Vulnerability: The findings underscore the vulnerability of the Yellow River source region's water resources to climate change, emphasizing the need for proactive management strategies.

Key Results

  • Historical Trends (2011-2022):
    • Surface runoff showed an overall increasing trend.
  • Soil moisture showed a general decreasing trend.
  • Surface runoff was significantly influenced by temperature.
  • Trends between soil moisture and annual mean temperature were highly significant.
  • Future Projections (2023-2100):
    • Under all three CMIP5 scenarios (RCP2.6, RCP4.5, RCP8.5), surface runoff is projected to display a downward trend.
  • The decrease in surface runoff is projected to be most pronounced under RCP8.5, followed by RCP4.5, and then RCP2.6 (RCP8.5 > RCP4.5 > RCP2.6).
  • Similarly, soil moisture is also projected to show a downward trend, with the magnitude of decrease following the same pattern (RCP8.5 > RCP4.5 > RCP2.6).
  • Annual precipitation is projected to increase to some extent, but this is offset by increased evaporation.
  • Surface runoff and soil moisture exhibit a similar seasonal distribution, peaking between May and August.

Limitations and Future Work

  • SWAT Model Limitations: The paper acknowledges that the SWAT model's glacier and snowmelt modules are relatively simple and may not fully capture the complex processes in high-altitude cold regions. This could lead to discrepancies, particularly during spring floods.
  • Downscaling Model Applicability: While SDSM showed good performance for temperature, its precipitation simulation was noted as potentially too high, suggesting room for improvement in downscaling techniques for this region.
  • CMIP6 Comparison: The study did not compare CMIP5 results with CMIP6 projections. CMIP6 models are generally more advanced and could offer improved simulations, especially for high-altitude cold regions. Future work could explore CMIP6 for a more refined understanding.
  • Interrelationships: The authors suggest further research is needed to clarify the complex interrelationships between evaporation, sunshine hours, grazing, land use, and their impacts on soil moisture and runoff.
  • Flood Simulation: The model's accuracy in simulating large and medium floods was noted as having some discrepancies, possibly due to reservoir regulation upstream. Further refinement of flood simulation capabilities is suggested.

Summary updated

Abstract

The impact of climate change on surface runoff and soil moisture in the source region of the Yellow River is analyzed, which will provide a scientific basis for the rational use and protection of water resources in the source area. In this paper, the SWAT hydrological model was coupled with the Coupled Model Intercomparison Project (CMIP) to predict future changes in surface runoff and soil moisture in the source region of the Yellow River. The prediction of surface runoff and soil moisture in the Yellow River Basin was analyzed by a linear regression model. The SWAT model rate had a calibration period R2 of 0.876 and a validation period R2 of 0.972. The trend of surface runoff and annual mean temperature in the source region of the Yellow River from 2011 to 2022 showed an overall increasing trend, and soil moisture showed a general decreasing trend. 2011–2022 trends between surface runoff and annual mean temperature in the source region of the Yellow River showed a highly significant difference, indicating that surface runoff flow was significantly influenced by temperature. The difference between the trends in soil moisture and the annual mean temperature was highly significant. The surface runoff fluctuated greatly in different years, and the surface runoff changed greatly in different scenarios of CMIP5 (RCP2.6, RCP4.5, and RCP8.5). For all three climate change scenarios, the surface runoff displayed a downward trend. The surface runoff showed a similar uneven distribution for all scenarios on a yearly cycle. Under the three climate scenarios, the runoff was highest between May and August, with a slowly increasing trend from January to April and a slightly decreasing trend from September to December. The interannual and interannual distribution of soil water was basically consistent with the distribution of surface runoff, and there was an overall trend in the length of all soil water reduction scenarios. Surface runoff and soil moisture are and will be greatly affected by climate change (mainly temperature and precipitation). Under the three climate scenarios, the precipitation increases to some extent, but the surface runoff and soil moisture will both decrease, which may be attributed to the greater evaporation than the precipitation.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{si2023effects,
  author = {Jianhua Si and Jianming Li and Sujin Lu and Xuejiao Qi and Xiuzhi Zhang and Wenjin Bao and Xiaoyan Zhang and Shipeng Zhou and Cheng Jin and Lijuan Qi and Yue Qi and Xiaojing Zheng and Yanhong Gong and Zhanqing Wang},
  title = {{Effects of Climate Change on Surface Runoff and Soil Moisture in the Source Region of the Yellow River}},
  booktitle = {Water},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3390/w15112104},
}
Figure