Effects of cinnamaldehyde on the germination and growth of Bacillus cereus spores in ready-to-eat boiled ground beef

Menghan Zhang, Ruixiang Zhou, Sixu Jin, Yuhang Song, Nuonuo Xu, Yuexia WangQuality 2022 · DOI

This research paper, published in Quality Assurance and Safety of Crops & Foods, explores how cinnamaldehyde—the organic compound that gives cinnamon its flavor—can be used as a natural weapon against a common and resilient foodborne pathogen in ready-to-eat (RTE) meat.

TL;DR

Researchers developed high-precision mathematical models to show that cinnamaldehyde significantly delays the "wake-up" time (lag phase) and slows the growth of Bacillus cereus spores in boiled ground beef. This provides a quantitative roadmap for using natural plant extracts to extend the shelf life and safety of cooked meat products.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Bacillus cereus is a major headache for the food industry. It is ubiquitous in the environment and, crucially, forms endospores that can survive the heat of boiling. In ready-to-eat products like boiled ground beef, these surviving spores can germinate and multiply if storage temperatures aren't perfect, leading to food poisoning.

While chemical preservatives exist, there is a growing consumer demand for "clean label" products using natural alternatives. Cinnamaldehyde is known to have antimicrobial properties, but the industry lacks the precise "predictive microbiology" models needed to know exactly how much to add and how it interacts with different storage temperatures to ensure safety.

Methods

The researchers used a systematic experimental design to track the behavior of a four-strain cocktail of B. cereus (including both cold-tolerant and heat-loving strains) in boiled ground beef.

  • Variables: They tested four concentrations of cinnamaldehyde (0% to 1.0% vol/wt) across four storage temperatures (12, 20, 28, and 36°C).
  • Primary Modeling: They used the Huang model to fit the growth curves. Unlike simpler models, the Huang model is mechanistic, accurately capturing the lag phase, the exponential growth phase, and the eventual plateau (stationary phase).
  • Secondary Modeling: To make the data useful for real-world applications, they developed cubic polynomial models. These equations allow a user to input a specific temperature and cinnamaldehyde concentration to predict the resulting lag time ($\lambda$) and maximum growth rate ($\mu_{max}$).

Datasets

The study relied on a custom-generated experimental dataset:

  • Matrix: Boiled ground beef seasoned with salt and MSG.
  • Inoculum: A cocktail of B. cereus CICC 23828 and three isolates from meat samples, standardized to $10^8$ spores/mL.
  • Data Points: 16 distinct combinations of temperature and concentration, with each growth curve built from multiple sampling intervals and performed in triplicate.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Lag" Leverage: The most dramatic effect of cinnamaldehyde was on the lag time—the duration spores remain dormant before they start dividing. At 12°C, adding 1% cinnamaldehyde extended this safety window from roughly 18 hours to nearly 76 hours.
  • Temperature Synergy: The antimicrobial effect isn't static; it's highly dependent on temperature. Cinnamaldehyde was most effective at "suboptimal" temperatures (12°C and 20°C). As the temperature rises toward the bacteria's ideal range (36°C), the relative effectiveness of the preservative decreases, though it still provides a measurable delay.
  • Growth Rate Suppression: Beyond just delaying the start of growth, cinnamaldehyde physically slowed the bacteria down. At 20°C, the maximum growth rate dropped by a staggering 66%.

Key Results

The mathematical models proved to be exceptionally robust, with $R^2$ values exceeding 0.98 and "Bias factors" ($B_f$) and "Accuracy factors" ($A_f$) very close to 1.0, indicating the predictions closely match real-world observations.

Specific quantitative highlights include:

  • Lag Time Extension: At 12°C, 1% cinnamaldehyde resulted in a 4.3-fold increase in lag time compared to the control.
  • Growth Inhibition: Even at the lowest concentration (0.1%), there was a noticeable slowing of the growth rate across all temperatures.
  • Model Utility: The researchers provided two specific equations (Equations 8 and 9 in the paper) that food engineers can use to calculate safety margins for RTE beef products.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Sensory Impact: The paper focuses strictly on microbiology. While 1% cinnamaldehyde is highly effective at killing bacteria, the authors do not discuss whether the resulting beef tastes too strongly of cinnamon for the average consumer.
  • Static vs. Dynamic Temps: The models were built using static temperatures. In real-world logistics (the "cold chain"), temperatures fluctuate. Future work could validate these models under dynamic temperature profiles.
  • Matrix Specificity: The results are specific to boiled ground beef. Different fat contents or pH levels in other meat products might alter the effectiveness of the cinnamaldehyde.

Summary updated

Abstract

The study quantitatively described the effects of cinnamaldehyde on the germination and growth of Bacillus cereus spores in boiled ready-to-eat ground beef. With the combination of the concentrations of cinnamaldehyde 0, 0.1, 0.5, and 1.0% vol/wt at temperatures 12, 20, 28, and 36°C, the Huang model was successfully used as the primary model to predict the lag time (λ) and maximum growth rate (µmax). Thereafter, the cubic polynomial models were used to estimate the values of Ln λ and Ln µmax considering both the storage temperature and cinnamaldehyde concentration. The models were highly accurate, because they produced acceptable root mean squared error (RMSE) values that were close to 0, while the determination (R2), accuracy factor (Af), and bias factor (Bf) values were all close to 1. As indicated by the fitted models, the supplementary of cinnamaldehyde in samples increased the lag time of B. cereus significantly from 17.7 to 75.8 h at 12°C of storage. Increasing the storage temperature from 12 to 36°C led to only 0.80-fold prolongation of lag time from 1.6 to 2.9 h in the sample containing cinnamaldehyde. However, the µmax value declined most obviously at 20°C, while 66% decrease was determined. According to the results, the cinnamaldehyde can be used as a natural antimicrobial agent in boiled ready-to-eat ground beef in staple food industry by inhibiting the germination and growth of B. cereus. The results also provided regressing models that can be used for effectively designing the storage temperature and cinnamaldehyde concentration for a specific requirement.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhang2022effects,
  author = {Menghan Zhang and Ruixiang Zhou and Sixu Jin and Yuhang Song and Nuonuo Xu and Yuexia Wang},
  title = {{Effects of cinnamaldehyde on the germination and growth of Bacillus cereus spores in ready-to-eat boiled ground beef}},
  booktitle = {Quality},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.15586/qas.v14i2.1046},
}
Figure