Effects of chamber shapes on maneuverability and control property of endoscope-support soft actuators

Yuxi Lu, Zhongchao Zhou, Pablo E. Tortós Vinocour, Shota Kokubu, Tatsuo Igarashi, Wenwei YuFrontiers in Bioengineering and Biotechnology 2023 · DOI

Abstract: Introduction: Minimally Invasive Surgery (MIS) offers targeted surgical access with reduced invasiveness; however, the maneuverability challenges of traditional instruments in this domain underscore the need for innovative solutions. Soft actuators activated by fluids or gases present a promising strategy for augmenting endoscopic capabilities, thereby enhancing the surgical precision in MIS. This study aimed to explore the intricate dynamics of the interactions between soft actuators and endoscopes, with an emphasis on the pivotal role of cross-sectional chamber shapes. While previous studies have touched on the influence of chamber shapes on bending properties, we provide a comprehensive exploration. We explore how these shapes modulate friction forces, which in turn influence the interactions governing bending, response, and stiffness adjustability, all of which are essential for enhancing endoscope maneuverability in MIS contexts. Methods: A novel bilateral symmetrical air chamber design was adopted to investigate various chamber shapes. We employed finite element analysis (FEA) simulations followed by prototype testing to evaluate the interactions driven by these chamber shapes and to discern their impact on actuator properties. Recognizing the pivotal role of friction in these interactions, we conducted dedicated friction experiments. These experiments further deepened our understanding of the relationship between chamber shape and friction, and how this synergy influences the properties of the actuator. Results: Our findings showed that actuators with wider chambers generate larger friction forces, thereby enhancing the interaction and improving the bending, response, and stiffness adjustability. Additionally, the soft actuator significantly improved the maneuverability and bending radius of the endoscope, demonstrating enhanced navigation capabilities in complex environments. Discussion: The shape of a cross-sectional chamber plays a pivotal role in designing soft actuators for MIS applications. Our research emphasizes the importance of this design component, offering key insights for the development of endoscope-supporting soft actuators that can effectively handle intricate actuator-endoscope interactions, thereby enhancing surgical outcomes.

Introduction

In the world of Minimally Invasive Surgery (MIS), precision is paramount. Surgeons often rely on flexible endoscopes to navigate the tight, unstructured environments of the human body. However, these tools can be difficult to maneuver and lack the ability to adjust their stiffness dynamically. Soft pneumatic actuators offer a promising "support" system to enhance these capabilities, but their design must be optimized to handle complex interactions with the endoscope.

A recent study published in Frontiers in Bioengineering and Biotechnology by researchers at Chiba University investigates the geometry of these actuators. The study reveals that the cross-sectional shape of the air chamber is the key to mastering the friction that makes these devices effective in a surgical setting.

Methods

The research team proposed a novel bilateral symmetrical air chamber design. Unlike traditional adjacent-chamber designs, this approach places two chambers on opposite sides of a hollow central channel where the endoscope is inserted. The study investigated seven distinct chamber geometries to evaluate their influence on performance.

The researchers investigated seven distinct chamber geometries, including circular, square, and crescent shapes, to evaluate their influence on actuator performance.

The study employed a three-pronged approach:

  1. Finite Element Analysis (FEA): Using COMSOL Multiphysics, the team simulated the seven chamber shapes to predict bending angles and internal stress distributions.
  2. Prototype Testing: Physical versions of the most promising designs were fabricated using silicone rubbers (DragonSkin 10 and 30).
  3. Friction & Control Experiments: Dedicated tests measured the relative "sliding" between the endoscope and the actuator. PID controllers were used to evaluate how quickly and accurately the different shapes could reach target bending angles.

Results

The experimental results demonstrated that friction is a critical functional feature. Higher friction between the actuator's inner wall and the endoscope's outer wall prevents relative sliding, allowing the actuator to effectively "grip" the endoscope and force it to bend, which improves overall control.

Comparison of FEA simulations (A), physical prototype bending (B), and displacement measurements (C) used to validate the performance and interaction dynamics of the soft actuators.

The crescent-shaped chamber emerged as the most effective geometry. Due to its wide and thin profile, it expands more easily toward the central channel when pressurized, increasing the contact area and beneficial friction. Key performance highlights include:

  • Efficiency: The crescent chamber required approximately 50% less air pressure (40 kPa) to reach a 15° bend compared to the standard circular chamber (80 kPa).
  • Responsiveness: In PID control tests, wider chambers (crescent and long fake crescent) demonstrated significantly faster rising and settling times.
  • Stiffness Adjustability: By activating both chambers antagonistically, the crescent design could support a 1 Newton load while maintaining a straight (0°) posture.
  • Clinical Impact: When tested in a 3D-printed bladder model, the crescent-actuator-supported endoscope provided a six-fold increase in the surgical viewing area compared to a standalone flexible endoscope.

Discussion

The cross-sectional shape of the air chamber is a pivotal design component for soft actuators in MIS applications. Wider chambers, such as the crescent shape, enhance maneuverability by optimizing the friction-driven interaction between the actuator and the endoscope.

While these results are promising, future work must address potential inter-chamber interference at high pressures and investigate how varying endoscope diameters and stiffness levels affect these dynamics. The next step for this research is moving toward animal testing to validate these findings in dynamic biological environments.

Summary updated

Abstract

<b>Introduction:</b> Minimally Invasive Surgery (MIS) offers targeted surgical access with reduced invasiveness; however, the maneuverability challenges of traditional instruments in this domain underscore the need for innovative solutions. Soft actuators activated by fluids or gases present a promising strategy for augmenting endoscopic capabilities, thereby enhancing the surgical precision in MIS. This study aimed to explore the intricate dynamics of the interactions between soft actuators and endoscopes, with an emphasis on the pivotal role of cross-sectional chamber shapes. While previous studies have touched on the influence of chamber shapes on bending properties, we provide a comprehensive exploration. We explore how these shapes modulate friction forces, which in turn influence the interactions governing bending, response, and stiffness adjustability, all of which are essential for enhancing endoscope maneuverability in MIS contexts. <b>Methods:</b> A novel bilateral symmetrical air chamber design was adopted to investigate various chamber shapes. We employed finite element analysis (FEA) simulations followed by prototype testing to evaluate the interactions driven by these chamber shapes and to discern their impact on actuator properties. Recognizing the pivotal role of friction in these interactions, we conducted dedicated friction experiments. These experiments further deepened our understanding of the relationship between chamber shape and friction, and how this synergy influences the properties of the actuator. <b>Results:</b> Our findings showed that actuators with wider chambers generate larger friction forces, thereby enhancing the interaction and improving the bending, response, and stiffness adjustability. Additionally, the soft actuator significantly improved the maneuverability and bending radius of the endoscope, demonstrating enhanced navigation capabilities in complex environments. <b>Discussion:</b> The shape of a cross-sectional chamber plays a pivotal role in designing soft actuators for MIS applications. Our research emphasizes the importance of this design component, offering key insights for the development of endoscope-supporting soft actuators that can effectively handle intricate actuator-endoscope interactions, thereby enhancing surgical outcomes.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{lu2023effects,
  author = {Yuxi Lu and Zhongchao Zhou and Pablo E. Tortós Vinocour and Shota Kokubu and Tatsuo Igarashi and Wenwei Yu},
  title = {{Effects of chamber shapes on maneuverability and control property of endoscope-support soft actuators}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Bioengineering and Biotechnology},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3389/fbioe.2023.1319922},
}
Figure