Effects of biquadratic exchange on the spectrum of elementary excitations in spin ladders

S. Brehmer, H.-j. Mikeska, Matthias A. Müller, Naoto Nagaosa, S. UchidaPhysical 1999 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

This study investigates the influence of biquadratic exchange interactions on the low-lying excitations of a $S=\frac{1}{2}$ ladder. Utilizing a combination of perturbation theory, numerical diagonalization of finite systems, and exact results for ladders with matrix product ground states, we specifically examine ring exchange on the basic ladder plaquette. Our findings indicate that a moderate amount of ring exchange substantially reduces the spin gap, allowing for a model with equal bilinear exchange on legs and rungs to remain consistent with experimentally observed spectra in cuprate materials.

Introduction

In the study of quantum magnetism, $S=1/2$ spin ladders represent a critical bridge between one-dimensional chains and two-dimensional planes. By the late 1990s, these systems—particularly quasi-one-dimensional cuprates like $Sr_{14}Cu_{24}O_{41}$—became a focal point for condensed matter physics. However, a significant discrepancy emerged: while the geometric and electronic structures of these materials suggested that the exchange interactions along the "legs" ($J_{leg}$) and across the "rungs" ($J_{rung}$) should be nearly identical, experimental fits using standard bilinear models consistently required $J_{leg}$ to be approximately twice as large as $J_{rung}$.

This paper addresses this anomaly by introducing higher-order interactions, specifically biquadratic "ring exchange," where four spins on a square plaquette interact simultaneously.

The Role of Ring Exchange

The primary hypothesis is that the exclusion of cyclic four-spin exchange (ring exchange) in earlier models forced an artificial inflation of the leg coupling constant to match experimental data. In a standard ladder, the Hamiltonian typically only accounts for pair-wise (bilinear) interactions. By adding a biquadratic term—representing the process where electrons hop around a four-site loop—the researchers introduce a new energy scale that fundamentally alters the excitation spectrum.

Methodology

To test the impact of these interactions, the authors employed three distinct theoretical and numerical techniques:

  1. Perturbation Theory: The researchers calculated the dispersion of the lowest triplet excitation by expanding around the "dimer point," a regime where rung interactions dominate leg interactions. This provided an analytical framework for understanding how ring exchange shifts the energy levels.
  2. Numerical Diagonalization (Lanczos Method): To verify the analytical predictions, the authors performed exact calculations on finite systems of 24 spins (arranged as 12 rungs) using periodic boundary conditions. This allowed for the precise determination of low-lying energy levels and the spin gap.
  3. Exact Analytical Results: The study utilized specific parameter sets, such as the generalized Bose-Gayen model, where the ground state can be expressed as a matrix product state. This enabled the derivation of exact solutions for excitation branches, serving as a benchmark for the numerical data.

Key Insights and Results

Reconciling the Leg-Rung Ratio

The most significant finding is that a positive ring exchange ($J_{ring} > 0$) effectively mimics the behavior of a stronger bilinear leg exchange. The authors discovered a "magic ratio": by setting $J_{leg} \approx J_{rung}$ and introducing a moderate ring exchange of $J_{ring} \approx 0.14 J_{rung}$, the model perfectly reproduces the experimental spectra of materials like $Sr_{14}Cu_{24}O_{41}$. This resolves the structural mystery, as it allows the theoretical model to align with the physical symmetry of the copper-oxide rungs and legs.

Sensitivity of the Spin Gap

The spin gap—the minimum energy required to create a triplet excitation—is remarkably sensitive to ring exchange. Without ring exchange, a ladder with $J_{leg} = J_{rung}$ exhibits a gap of $\Delta \approx 0.51 J_{rung}$. With the inclusion of $J_{ring} \approx 0.14 J_{rung}$, this gap drops significantly to $\Delta \approx 0.28 J_{rung}$. This reduction is crucial for matching the steepness of the dispersion curves observed in inelastic neutron scattering experiments.

Energy Scale Normalization

By accounting for ring exchange, the basic exchange energy $J_{rung}$ for these ladders is renormalized from approximately $800K$ to $1400K$. This higher value is much more consistent with the exchange constants found in related 2D parent compounds like $La_2CuO_4$, providing a more unified picture of cuprate physics across different geometries.

Discussion and Limitations

While the inclusion of ring exchange provides a compelling solution to the $J_{leg}/J_{rung}$ problem, the study acknowledges certain limitations. The numerical calculations on 24-spin systems, while robust, are subject to finite-size effects, particularly near quantum phase transitions where the system may undergo spontaneous dimerization. Furthermore, the paper notes that the presence of a maximum in the dispersion curve between $k=0$ and $k=\pi$ is highly sensitive to the exact value of $J_{ring}$. At the time of publication, experimental resolution was insufficient to confirm this specific feature, suggesting a need for higher-precision neutron scattering data.

Conclusion

This work demonstrates that biquadratic exchange is not a negligible correction but a fundamental component of the physics of $S=1/2$ spin ladders. By incorporating ring exchange, the researchers successfully reconciled theoretical models with experimental observations, maintaining the physical integrity of the material's geometric structure while accurately predicting its magnetic excitations.

Summary updated

Abstract

We investigate the influence of biquadratic exchange interactions on the low-lying excitations of a $S=\frac{1}{2}$ ladder using perturbation theory, numerical diagonalization of finite systems, and exact results for ladders with matrix product ground states. We consider in particular the combination of biquadratic exchange interactions corresponding to ring exchange on the basic ladder plaquette. We find that a moderate amount of ring exchange reduces the spin gap substantially and makes equal bilinear exchange on legs and rungs consistent with experimentally observed spectra.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{brehmer1999effects,
  author = {S. Brehmer and H.-J. Mikeska and Matthias A. Müller and Naoto Nagaosa and S. Uchida},
  title = {{Effects of biquadratic exchange on the spectrum of elementary excitations in spin ladders}},
  booktitle = {Physical},
  year = {1999},
  doi = {10.1103/physrevb.60.329},
}
Figure